if you can't stomach the different look, return it or it will drive you crazy every day.

I can’t tell finish differences from the photo but the harsh angles of the square knob don’t look right with the pull. Sorry... I wouldn’t want to deal with that return either.

Sorry square knobs with those pulls don't look good together, you will be happier changing them.

I would definitely return the square knobs and get round shaped knobs. They will go better with the pulls you picked. I know it's hard dealing with that right now, but you'll be happy you did it on time.

Return both, your old pulls look better.

Why not save some money and spray paint all of your old pulls and knobs matte black? Use the money you save after the return and go out to dinner with the cash. I went through the same dilemma and finally kept my original 1937 pulls and latches. Everything I liked was too expensive and everything else either needed new holes drilled or looked cheap. I almost drove myself crazy. After returning two sets, I gave up and used the money to buy myself a new set of everyday dishes. Best decision that I ever made and the original painted hardware looks great and fits perfectly.

I’m agreeing with the others. All your accessories coordinate with what’s on there already. If you do go forward with the cups, I agree no square.

Pretty kitchen! The mismatched finish would drive me nuts. Agree that round knobs would look nicer.

Thanks everyone! I've decided to send it all back and live with the old stuff for now. I'm partial to ORB over nickel but this just wasn't a fit.