Software
Houzz Logo Print
vp98aa

Front Door on a House

8 years ago

Pros,


For a new construction, I am looking at a double-door front entry with following parameters:

  • Door size: 6' wide (each door is 3') x 9' tall.
  • Front porch overhang / roof extends out about 9' 4" from door.
  • From the front elevation, front porch has vertical opening that is about 15' tall.
  • These doors are facing straight west direction.
  • House is located in the midwest (Indiana) area.


Questions:

  1. Since the house is facing straight west, would you recommend wood (i.e. Mahogany) doors? Or would you only recommend a fiberglass door?
  2. If we were to consider wood door, is 9' 4" overhang sufficient? If yes, would it be a maintenance nightmare?


I have spoken with a few different door companies as well as the builder about this -- I am getting mixed answers. Some door companies are saying wood will be OK, others are against it. Another factor is price - because we are looking at a 9' tall door, same door in Fiberglass is about more than double the price compared to wood (i.e. Mahogany). Your thoughts?


Appreciate your help. Thanks!

Comments (9)

  • 8 years ago

    You need fiberglass and a 9500 square foot non McMansioney mansion to go with what you want. It’s a little out of scale and style for a standard 4000sf suburban NeoEclectic.

  • 8 years ago
    Can you look at an oversized door instead of double!? When I was looking in to it it said double doors are super inefficient as far as energy efficiency. I could be totally wrong, but the few times I say it I just committed to not wanting double doors.
  • 8 years ago

    wood - Where I am, facing west it's a huge no. Unless you're going for the aged weathered look, which you'll have within two years.

    9' porch - pay attention to the interior. A porch is effectively a room, and reduces light to the interior spaces.

    Double doors - depends on the design, it can seem deliberate and appropriate, or over-the-top mc mansion style.

    vertical opening 15'??

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Thank you everyone. I have a follow-up question: has anyone heard
    of accoya wood? How does that compare to fiberglass? I'm reading that
    it is very stable and solid and holds up really really really well with
    moisture & sun exposure.

    See attached image - the
    front elevation of the house. The arrows in red (vertical opening) on
    the porch covers about 15'. Hope that helps.

  • 8 years ago

    (our house c. 1870 has a double door... its wonderful. most of the time you only have to open *that much* but when you are moving a piano in or renovating a bathroom, it opens 2x *that much*, which is awesome. just sayin'. )

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Are you under construction? For a home this grand you select a wood door.

    Here's where I get on my small soapbox. A house like this is a MONEY PIT, and since this is Indiana it figures that this trend would be 20 years behind the rest of the country. If you doubt what I post, then read these articles.

    https://www.realtor.com/news/trends/boomers-millennials-and-the-mcmansions-no-one-wants/

    https://www.realtor.com/news/trends/metros-with-most-mcmansions/

    http://www.businessinsider.com/americans-could-be-killing-the-mcmansion-for-good-2017-2

    Living in Indiana with that complicated roof design you'll be dealing with ice dams in the winter and roof leaks in the valleys in the spring in a few years.

    You'll have to hire people to wash your windows, people to clean your home, special people to clean your chandeliers & even people to install your Christmas decorations. Every contractor that comes to your home will up the charges 30% because you have a big house and they figure you can afford it. No kidding ........I saw it a number of times with contractors and my clients.

    Based on the size of your windows, just your window treatments, which will all be custom and oversized, could be $30k for starters. And since the front of your home is facing west, the heat load in certain months will up your utility bills. Landscaping to complement this design could run $100k for decent size trees etc. No telling the cost for furnishing because they can't be purchased at Rooms to Go.

    You'll find you only live in the kitchen, family room and the bedrooms.

    Then the cherry on the sundae is when you go to sell you'll be competing against thousands of other McMansions for sale because there is no longer a middle class moving up the economic ladder to afford these size homes. Of course if you have money to burn, none of this is any concern to you.

    Getting off my soapbox : (

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    aren't you glad you asked a question about doors now? Nice looking house btw.

  • 8 years ago

    Beverly is correct. Please don't do the McMansion thing. If you've not yet built, turn back, better late than never. Do I spy a turret?!

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert