Software
Houzz Logo Print
emily_urben28

Full scale reno? Or small, cosmetic changes?

8 years ago

We just bought our first home - yay! It’s a large, outdated house in a neighborhood where homes generally sell for at the very least - $75k above our price. While we have no intention to sell any time soon, we would love to add value to the home & add our personalities to the space. I’ll be posting more pictures soon, but currently stuck on what to do with the kitchen.


Small cosmetic updates such as paint, hardware, maybe countertop, etc.? Or should we invest in blowing out the wall separating the dining room/kitchen (load bearing, will need beam), new cabinets along the exterior wall, add an island, etc? I am bursting with ideas, but given that I’m a young, first time homebuyer without a sugar daddy in sight (I’m kidding, don’t judge me) - I would have to borrow to get it done.


Any who, here is the “ugly, but functional” current state of affairs.









Comments (25)

  • 8 years ago

    I second writersblock's advice. What I have found over many home purchases is that I get a much better sense of what I would like to change about a house after I have lived there for a while. In my current home, for example, I was almost certain when we moved in that the bathrooms would be the first things that I renovated because they are not really my taste. Five years later, the bathrooms are untouched because after living there, other things made a lot more sense to renovate. (Honestly, it will be another five years or so until the make it to the top of the list.)

    Congratulations on your new home! It really looks quite lovely.

  • 8 years ago

    agree,,,settle in for awhile and see what does and doesn't work for you. Make a list of priorities.

    ultimately, what would you like to see? house rehab will go on for years, so pace yourself w/the things that you feel you need immediately. If the house is sound, inside and out, then you're lucky.

    Do you have central air? Because the first thing I'd do is lose that 1993 fan in the kitchen. The kitchen is livable for now. if you know you're going to renovate in a year or so, then maybe you'd like to practice and paint the cabs. Look on craigslist for kitchen cabs (you can't believe the full on 3 year old kitchens that often go up for sale! less than$!500) Save up until you have enough to reconfigure the space and maximize your storage and prep areas. hire a kitchen designer.

    while you're looking on Craigslist, look for a new front door. that victorian style doesn't work. you can find used doors in your size that you can paint.

    The next thing you should do, is take some classes on basic homeowner DIY. local hardware stores offer them. get a book and read the how-to's for basic repairs for plumbing, electrical, carpentry, etc. you will save hundreds of dollars if you learn how to change your garbage disposal or hook up a new toilet. all easy, 15 min jobs.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Congratulations on your first home! My advice is don't ever borrow money or take equity out of your home to improve it. Save up and pay everything upfront in cash.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Before taking out any walls find out which walls or support walls. Did a blueprint of the home come with home? If not, ask a Pro.

  • 8 years ago

    best to look at the first floor as a whole. Front door opening to dining room is not customary...probably was the living room at one time....so is there an added space beyond the kitchen?? these spaces are part of your "whole plan". I would rather NOT have dining space at the front door..would consider a hall with closet and maybe a study in the front. do you have living space beyond kitchen that is your "great room" , potentially? this is why its best to live live in space and see the reality of the layout before any planning. the kitchen is nice, usable..I would think about a counter installed under window with stools for coffee/cereal/quick meals so you could eat in kitchen somewhat--it's a completely pleasant space and the window is great.

  • 8 years ago
    It’s not that bad. Agree with the others to live with it for a while. You will have tons of other unpredictable things to address after you get in the house—you need to find out what those are before addressing cosmetic issues or tackling a major remodel. Paint and change that hideous ceiling fan out for a better light fixture, accessorize with your stuff, and it won’t be so bad.
  • 8 years ago

    Wow, I was expecting something really bad! The only thing " wrong" with your kitchen is that it is not gray and white! :)

    I would suspect that 90% of the world's population would love to have your kitchen. You may have the desire for a different look but that can happen gradually. I would remove those blinds and get pretty window treatments. Then remove the fan, add a colorful rug, remove that freestanding cabinet, add some accessories, and enjoy your lovely new home. I would surely replace that front door, too.

  • 8 years ago

    Congratulations on buying your first home. I agree with the others that you should move in and enjoy your home. Live there for 6 months and figure out what you love and what you hate about the space. Figure out your new budget and start saving. Save for retirement, save for major repairs, save for the surprises that life may throw at you and save for home renovations. Figure out how to make one extra payment on your mortgage a year (bi-weekly payments vs monthly).
    While you are doing all this boring financial stuff have fun planning and window shopping and figuring out what style furniture and decor fits your lifestyle and taste. Figure out your personal color pallet. What colors make your heart sing and how you may want to incorporate those colors into your home. Window shop like crazy, learn what is available and what things cost. Pay attention to how you actually live your life. Do you actually have formal dinners and fancy parties or do you have casual get togethers with close friends and family. Find a style that fits how you live your life.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    I agree find out what you love/ hate about the kitchen then start saving for a redo I can see great possibilites with the space but it will cost money. IMO the best place to spend your money is a good kitchen , I have no idea what the exterior looks like but with the inside I would change that front door

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    ".......take some classes on basic homeowner DIY. local hardware stores offer them. get a book and read the how-to's for basic repairs for plumbing, electrical, carpentry, etc. you will save hundreds of dollars if you learn how to change your garbage disposal or hook up a new toilet. all easy, 15 min jobs."

    This is a great idea, but pretty ignorant at the end. You don't change out a garbage disposal or toilet in 15 minutes. Most people probably can't even get the old ones out in 15 minutes. But I'd love to see the real-time video proving me wrong.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    This really boils down to money and how much you've got to invest in your home. Depending on where you live, doing a remodel can be a good investment over time. But the reality is, it should be more about how you live and the functional requirements you have to make your kitchen (and other parts of your home) more livable. Bottom line, if you've got the money, do it, but hire someone who knows how to design a kitchen to help you. If you don't have cash on hand, then start making a priority list to tackle things over the long haul. One thing that will always remain constant, however, is that remodeling costs never go down, only up. So waiting until just the right moment to do the job may end up being never.

  • 8 years ago

    I have not timed it but I have seen my husband change out both a garbage disposal and a toilet in about 15 minutes. Definitely live in your house for a while before making major changes. There is nothing wrong with your existing kitchen that is readily apparent but perhaps there are flaws that will only become known by you living there. Save up and plan. Before you make changes ask the advice of an excellent realtor in your area as you want to make sure that you will get a good return on investment. It is a great idea to learn how to DIY as it will save you major $$$ and give you insight on what to spend on and how to oversee jobs you contract out.

  • 8 years ago

    It took us a year for our kitchen remodel, from the first conceptual conversation with our remodeler to the finished product. (Actual reno only took 6 weeks.) And that was after living in the house for eight years. So take your time and do it right.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    well Coleman, If you honestly can't get a toilet up and out and a new one set down and hooked up, in less than 15 mins, then maybe you should get someone to teach you. It's not that difficult. And my suggestion of her taking some classes is a great idea. Ignorant at the end? what does that even mean? That it can't be done? or that you can't do it, therefore it can't be done? Because it can be done. But i'll be sure to video tape it, just for you, the next time I do it. SMH.

    The entire point of that statement was for her to learn to do things herself. But of course you have to knock everything I say, because that's what you do with my comments. The fact that I happened to pick a toilet and a garbage disposal were just random(although, entirely, easy DIY's)

    Apparently you aren't sharp enough to see the entire comment for what is was, "the ability to learn things yourself and what you're capable of as a homeowner, in order to save yourself from having to call in a handyman for every little thing".

  • 8 years ago

    For now, I would:

    I would replace the front door.

    New pulls on the cabinets.

    Remove the cutesy cut out valance.

    New counter-tops because I would replace the sink with a single bowl stainless sink. Pre-made cash & carry laminate counter tops from Home Depot or Menard's are quite inexpensive.

    Remove the backsplash tile. Either replace or, what I would do, is just paint the backsplash area with a good scrubbable paint. (Relocate that switch that is sitting on the window trim when the backsplash tile comes down.)

    Paint the metal parts of the ceiling fan w/ a silvery metallic paint. Would keep the fan for now because it is often nice to be able to move some air in the kitchen when you're cooking even if you have central AC.)

    LED tape lighting under and on the top of the upper cabinets. (Looks like the kitchen is deficient in lighting.)

    IF you can DIY, you should be able to accomplish all of the above for +/- $1500-$2000 w/ careful shopping, Craig's List finds. Depending on how many tools you need to buy and if you need to call an electrician.

    Establish a New Appliance Kitty for replacing dishwasher, range, water heater, etc. when they go kaput.

    Save the borrowing money option for when/ if you have a real emergency like having to replace HVAC, the roof, discover termites...


  • 8 years ago

    Congratulations! I agree with other posters, save your money and remodel when you can pay cash. Also, know that remodeling work is seldom a good investment as you usually put in more money than you get back on resale.

  • 8 years ago

    Congratulations on your new home!

    I was expecting to see a fugly kitchen, but your kitchen isn't bad at all! I get that it's not your style, but I agree with living with it for a while first before you decide to make major changes.

    In my area, it isn't uncommon to have a dining room at the front of the house, right off the front door and have the living room on the other side, so I wouldn't worry about that issue right now. I personally would never remove a load bearing wall unless it was my forever home. It's very expensive and you have to decide how much money you want to invest in this house.

    If you want small changes, change out the ceiling fan, take the wood cutout cutsey piece that's above the window out and get new window treatments. I would then paint the trim white as it looks like both windows have different color trim. I don't think your space is big enough for an island. I would get rid of that small cart that's in front of the window and put something more functional there for storage.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Congratulations on your first home purchase!

    I agree with what everyone has been commenting. I definitely would not borrow money to renovate this kitchen even though it is a bit outdated. You have to remember when you renovate, there might be obstacles in the way which will result to you spending even more money than you thought so you definitely want to be ready financially for it.

    If I was you I would replace the fan with a nice fixture and maybe replace the faucet. Cant really see the quality of paint on walls/ceiling, so if it is in bad condition you could explore that option.

    Replacing countertop on old cabinets will be a waste of money for you because eventually you'll have to replace the cabinets and if the contractor can't save the countertop, you will pay for it twice. Don't touch the cabinets if they function and in decent condition. If you wanted to change handles you can but remember holes of new hardware have to match existing.

    Good luck and enjoy your new home!

  • 8 years ago

    Windows on two walls of the kitchen - Score!

    You can certainly make this work, and it doesn't need much. Take out the valance and replace the hardware will make an instant change with little $ and effort. I think the wall color can be brightened up a bit.

    I'm not keen on the backsplash, but it's not so bad that I would risk the damage to the wall (and hiring a pro to fix it) to change it.

    Congrats on your new adventure!

  • 8 years ago

    Wow! You have an amazing kitchen layout that is screaming for that wall to be removed between it and the dining room. The rest of the kitchen can be relocated to the window wall (remove the window) add a large cook island. I wouldn't wait to redo a kitchen. Time is not on our side, things happen and change quickly. Kitchens sell homes if you needed to move. I would do a kitchen always- every time! You get to enjoy it sooner than later (if at all) too.

  • 8 years ago

    Congrats! You have a FULLY FUNCTIONAL HOME! That is a BIG plus! The kitchen can work for many more years. I would plunk in a cheeky 2man table with some cute chairs where the chopping block is sitting under the window.

    It looks like the floors are laminate (the t-molding in the threshold between kitchen and front room tells me lots) which means the current floor may only have 5-7 years worth of life.

    If I'm right and those are laminate floors, you now have your renovation time-line. I would keep everything as-is and simply update with paint and some sweat. Once those floors in the kitchen start to fail, you know it is time to bring out the wallet, talk to a Certified Kitchen Designer who has an engineer on speed dial.

    Opening up a house isn't cheap. It isn't easy. It is a SCHWACK of money. You state that the rest of the homes are $75K more than what you paid for yours (total score!). Your wonderful plans could be MORE than $75K! So be aware and be prepared.

    A full kitchen renovation averages $50K. Adding in a beam can start at $15K. And we haven't touched the wood trim or replace laminate flooring. If you estimate flooring at a conservative $7-$10 per square foot, you get a quick estimate as to what this will cost.

    I think you should be VERY proud of this STUPENDOUS purchase (yep...you found a great house at a great price)! Please live in it to find out it's quirks. Remember the IMPORTANT things come with big price tags. New roofs, new water tanks, new furnace, new A/C units, new drainage should the basement be leaky, etc all cost plenty of money.

    You won't know how much really needs to be done until you get in and LIVE with the dripping taps or the loud motor on the fridge, or the wonky dishwasher or the dead-as-a-door-nail washer/drier. You won't know how much the electrical bills are. Or the natural gas or water bills are. Only after living for a full cycle (12 months = 4 seasons = full cycle) - including paying your yearly tax bill - will you have a firm idea as to what needs doing and what can wait....and how much you have left in the bank after that.

    I say enjoy your new home. Love it for the steal that it is! Start saving your money and your renovation ideas. Know that living in it will equip you for the future you will have with it. And be happy in that knowledge. Time will tell you what is needed and when.

  • 8 years ago

    Not much to add in terms of things that need doing, and I agree that the longer you wait, the better you can anticipate what would fit your family's actual life.

    Wanted to add, though, that it seems like your kitchen is wide enough that you could do an Actual Something under the windows there. If you'd love to be able to share wine or coffee with a friend/spouse, then maybe a cafe table with two chairs, or a counter-height rolling island that could do double duty. If you're short on storage, then I think you could do a whole set of cabinets (even an Ikea type designed for the living room ) most of the way across, leaving clearance for the dishwasher/floor vent and walkway. You'd get extra prep surface that way too, or at least a place to keep the coffee maker (etc) out of your most useful counter zones...

  • 8 years ago
    This has been incredibly helpful! Digesting all of your suggestions thank you so much!!!!!
  • 8 years ago

    All very good advice above: to live with the house for awhile and especially to learn to DIY many repair and replacement issues. One thought specific to your suggested wall removal: I would think twice about having the kitchen in full and immediate view from the front door unless your kitchen is kept pristine all the time. If I were shopping for a house, that would be a deal-breaker for me.

Sponsored
Whisler Home Improvement
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars9 Reviews
Franklin County's Committed Home Improvement Professionals