First one. The others look so dark. Are you updating the cabs?

I would go with the Astoria, too!!

The Astoria reads more taupe than cream, so wait until you decide on the top before selecting your cabinet paint color. Also, your cabinets are showing a very deep grain, which will definitely show through your paint. You may want to test a door before committing to the entire kitchen.

Astoria

i second selecting and painting your cabs... then take a door with you to the stone yard and pick your counter. you could be very disappointed doing it way u r doing it now...

If you love the fantasy brown (it is beautiful!) use it on your island and use a simple quartz on the perimeter. By the way you're going to love not having soffits. I know it's a pain but it makes a HUGE difference.

@Kristin Petro Interiors, Inc. What tile did you use for the backsplash?

That was a Pratt and Larson mosaic in color R350.