Software
Houzz Logo Print
newshockerguy

Question on new maple growing in the back yard. Multiple trunks?

Last year we had a little seedling and it started growing where we couldn't grow a lilac. See picture below of what it looks like last year.




What it looks like now:





As you can see it's grown quite a lot in a years time which is awesome. The question I have is it appears that it's going to have three trunks or is it? At this point in the game should I cut the two side branches/trunks off or let it be?

I've never seen that before on such a little tree. There is actually a seedling by the house that took off from last year: See pictures below. You can see that looks like a normal single trunk tree.




Just mainly wondering on the first triple trunk baby maple growing..lol I can't foresee it really being a problem until I am long gone but figured I'd ask. I plan on transplanting the single trunk maple that's right by the house/patio and putting it in the common area space behind our house so it can grow into a big tree.

Thanks much,

-Nigel

Comments (12)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Young maple trees, especially in full sun, tend to produce multiple leaders, branches that are too close together and are coming out of the tree at sharp angles.

    You'll want to subordinate all but the central leader. That will leave the tree with a high percentage of existing leaves, continuing making food for the roots this season.

    Removal of all the extra leaders would leave the tree with a weak area because of the concentration of all 3 branches encircling the trunk at the same portion of the small trunk.

    You could remove one of them now, using proper pruning techniques, leaving the branch collar and then do another next year, or both.

    So while there's no hurry to remove all the extra leaders, subordinating them by cutting off about 1/3 to 1/2 of them, will give the tree a chance to form more of a branch collar on these and the central leader will become more dominant as time goes on.

    Structure pruning a maple is a multi year project so next year you'll be looking at this one again, higher up and doing the same thing.. Try not to take off more than about 15% to 20% of the foilage each season.

    Crossed branches and branches that grow toward the inside of the tree can go too, in time. Next season you can look at branch spacing, which ones stay and which ones need to go, where the branches start, how high up. :-)

    July is still a good time to prune bc the wounds will heal enough by fall so the tree won't bleed profusely next spring. Doesn't hurt that much, just kind of ugly.

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks Bill!

    Lots of great information. I have a couple questions then for you with some pictures. I hope I understand this. I googled to research more. Looks like in urban environments you end up with a tree that has it's own branches competing for sun as opposed to it being in a forest that grows tall and straight.

    I took the picture above and made a few edits. The red lines are where I would cut and the long straight vertical red lines would be where there would no longer be that leader. Give or take a few inches up/down on where to make the cut?

    I would NOT want to cut where the blue X's are closer to the trunk? Does this look correct to you?

    My next question is the below image. Why would the little maple above not after (lots of years later) not have multiple trunks like the below picture? I ask only because I often wonder how the multiple trunk tree grows like that.


    My parents have a silver maple behind their house that has to be over 70 years old but has three trunks that almost look like one. Closest picture I could find is something like the below.... How does that happen?


    Appreciate all the info!


    -Nigel


  • 8 years ago

    every leaf is a food making machine .. if you cut to many off a babe ... it might suffer .. and secondly ... start thinking in tree time .. there is rarely a hurry ... and you can always take more later ....


    so bill wants you to take half of a trunk.. to leave some leaves ... but also.. to make what will end up being the main one.. dominant .. and then later.. you can remove them all the way down ....


    imo.. you have a nightmare seeding maple in the area ... and you are encouraging them to procreate even more ... there are so many better trees .. and perhaps.. after practicing with this one.. you could invest in some better trees for your area ...


    you need to get the one out from the downspout ...and though you can practice messing around with it ... i would not recommend you add a second reseeding nightmare maple to your yard ...


    anyway.. thats my opinion on maples .... you just knock yourself out.. and plant whatever you want ... just have fun learning ...


    ken

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks Ken for the info. That clears it up. I am definitely moving the maple from the downspout. That from the beginning was never going to stay that close to the house. I planned on removing it this fall and putting it in our common area behind the house that is open. What tree do you like compared to maples? I ask only because I don't dislike maple trees, and the ones we've ever had growing up or currently never caused issues or problems. I really like most trees with the exception of pines. I've never been a fan of those and I can't stand the dropping of needles/sap if you park under them. Plus they are ugly to me.


    We have a more mature maple by the shed. In the corner of the back yard I planted a purple robe locust. Beside the one neighbor I planted a crab apple tree. Looking for privacy eventually from the next door houses by us.


    Thanks,

    -Nigel

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Nigel,

    Multiple trunks on large specimen trees is never a good idea. I see so many yard trees left to themselves, with extra trunks coming out of the base and branches going in every direction. My BIL has a huge Silver maple with 7 trunks and now is worried about any one of them toppling over and crushing his house and looking at around $3000 to remove.

    Like ken said, you can do what ever you want but as far as structure, support and health of the tree goes, young specimen trees should be kept single trunked, single leader tree as long as it's feasibly.

    Your Red/Blue line photo is basically right and there's plenty of structure pruning of small trees tutorials on the www if you want to look them up.

    Your picture after that is some sort of Japanese maple. Certain ornamental trees can be multiple trunks and look better in that form so this is apples to oranges.

    I cringe when I see large trees like your last picture growing near a residence. Those multiple trunks aren't as well connected together as you might think, leaving crevasses where disease can fester and the trees can break apart during storms.

    And remember to plan on what trees you want growing in what location for your yard. Some trees can easily out grow their space in a short amount of time or look 'out of place' in their setting. Consider your neighbors also, what they think when your once little tree overhangs the fence infringing on their yard. You may not be able to grow much of anything under a large maple tree because of root issues is another consideration. Not to mention seeds sprouting up everywhere over the years.

    Also, all landscaping will eventually get to the end of it's practical usefulness and have to be redone at some point. Something else to keep in mind.

  • 8 years ago

    I knew it was a red. They love multiple trunks. I'd yank it and plant a sugar. They're single trunk trees and much prettier in the fall. Or a black tupelo or sourwood. They flame in the fall too.

  • 8 years ago

    I agree Molly, If I lived in 7a, I can think of a hundred other trees I'd rather have than a red maple.

  • 8 years ago

    Appreciate all the info everyone! This will help in terms of what I should do. No love for red maples it seems...lol

    I planted an October red glory maple behind the house in the common area and that's really pretty in fall.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Oh, I have a few reds in my yard and I don't mind them and they can be pretty in the fall, but in 3b, I'm limited in tree selection that I can plant. Warmer climates can grow much better more durable trees than I can and if I could, I would. :^)

  • 8 years ago

    Red maples are fine. Sort of a red-leaf-turning version of silver maple, but not as big.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    "Red maples are fine. Sort of a red-leaf-turning version of silver maple, but not as big."

    I have to beg to differ. Compared to many other various shades trees you can plant in zone 7, they are not as bad as silver maples but still tend to be short-lived and prone to storm damage and formation of weak crotches. Also, impossible to garden under once they reach shade-making size, because of the network of surface roots.

    Fine if you have a huge, rural property and want to plant one far away from everything else. Way overplanted in suburbia because they are fast growing (satisfy an instant gratification culture) and super cheap for wholesalers to grow.

    And also, weedy. The mere fact this is a seedling should be a clue that it's going to produce a lot of seedlings. And they are hard to pull as tree seedlings go.

    I suppose sugar maple is the best of the large eastern maples, Molly? I don't have much experience with them.