I like the ones that have a green undertone. Don't think they were your picks.

I prefer lighter version.

Currently considering Rodeo, what did you end up using?

Off topic but i have to say that I LOVE your counter tops! Lighter paint that your choices would look nice.

Looking at each online, several times, Rodeo is the winner out of these two!

Hi Jballard 2006,

I have been in the same situation as you! Both colours look great, but ultimately which one do you choose. What helped me decide was to understand how much natural light was coming into the room. I aways prefer brighter living space, so whenever I selected a paint I made sure it did not comprise the natural light. Looking at it in a different perspective, if you invest in a paint that allows light to bounce easily (lighter colours) rather than absorb it (darker colours), this can technically lower your electricity bills as you won't have to put your lights on frequently during the day.

So if this were my project, looking at these photos I would probably steer closer to the lighter colours. The photos you provide show your kitchen and living area to be moderately lit with natural light. I would not say bright, however I am not to judge, as these photos may have been taken during the evening. But that said, I hope my intuition and approach helps you to choose the best paint tone for your kitchen/living.

Good Luck :)