China Doll is very light and Griffin is very dark. Since stucco is made of sand, I looked at the Sherwin Williams colors that have “sand” in the name. Downing Sand is a popular exterior color, and they have suggested some colors to go with it: chateau brown and sun dried tomato. The brown would be good on the trim and the tomato would be good on the front door. I would paint the garage door the same color as the body of the house to make it less prominent.

I would go even better than all your neighbors. I would go with white. :-))

Or off-white/ivory

celery girl,,,can you do a white/cream with black or maybe a patina green? and a wood garage door?

i like this one too, but because of the tile and arbor detail, it keeps it from looking boring

if you amped up your landscaping a bit, the house would really look good. or think about doing some stone or slate accents to the home.

The last photo of Beth looks really good! I would go with white warm walls and the same trim.

To change the door it is more money than just to paint.

Thank you for all of your ideas! I’ll definitely consider all those choices.