Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_597358875

Polyurethane Vs Soy Based Foam In Couch Cushions

8 years ago

Hey Houzz Experts!


I am curious to know if anyone here knows anything about soy based foam vs polyurethane foam in couch cushions. I have read a fair amount online but can not find anything based upon their durability in relation to one another.


If anyone has any experience with this subject, my question is, are soy based foams more resilient to breaking down over polyurethane foam or are they generally the same? Such as 1.8lbs density polyurethane foam may last, let’s say, 3-5 years before breaking down, does 1.8lbs density soy based foam last 5-7 years or something around that or does soy based not make any difference whatsoever?


Any info on this topic would be great!


Thanks everyone!

Comments (4)

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    First of all their is no such thing as 100% plant based polyurethane foam. At the most its 10 to 15 percent plant based (soy or palm) with rest petrol based.


    Flexible polyurethane foam is produced from a reaction with these key chemicals, a polyol which can be petrol based or plant based and an isocyanate, adding reacting toluene diisocyanate (TDI) with water. These are mixed together vigorously in high intensity mixers in specific amounts with other ingredients, and the foam reaction begins almost immediately. Bubbles are formed, and the mixture expands. It’s been compared to bread rising.


    The denser the foam, the more material used to produce it, and the more material there is in the cushion to provide weight support. Additionally higher density foam can be created to have higher resilience, referred to as HR or ultra-cell foam. For a much higher performing foam. It is important to remember, though, that foam surface firmness is independent of foam density. High density foams can be produced to be very soft. Low density foams can be made to be very firm. Therefore, there is no such thing as “hard” or “firm” density. High density foam products generally offer great deal of support, but they can be manufactured to be fairly soft foams.

    Thus all standard polyurethane foam is petrol based and some is partly plant based polyol, will perform the same, their is no advantage other than environmentally.


    The only true environmentally safe and high performance foam that will last 10 + years is Latex foam.

    Jeff Edmundson thanked iCustomSofa
  • 8 years ago

    Wow! Thank you iCustomSofa for your extremely detailed response. You answered over and above my question. You are clearly very knowledgeable in this area.


    Now you have arisen a new question in my mind with your final comment. You mentioned that “The only true environmentally safe and high performance foam that will last 10 + years is Latex foam.“ Let’s say we took the “true environmentally safe” out of the equation, are there polyurethane foams or such that last 10+ years or is this not possible? Such as does a 2.5lbs or 3.0lbs HR polyurethane foam last 10+ years?


    Again thank you for sharing your knowledge.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Conventional polyurethane foam for upholstery is poured to maximum 2.5 lbs and HR or ultracell maximum is 2.2 lbs, their is no benefit for higher densities, thus the reason you wont find the higher densities at any retail stores. Its been said before how long it will last depends on the mileage.

    Jeff Edmundson thanked iCustomSofa
  • 8 years ago

    This is very interesting information that I have not been able to find anywhere else so thank you for this.


    That makes perfect sense that the “mileage” of the cushions affects the lifespan of the foam. You come across as quite experienced in this area. I have done some searching around for information on the lifespan of the cushions based off every day use but have not been able find anything. For example, how long would 2.2lbs HR foam last if the couch was used for a few hours every day? If you’re able to even give an idea on this that would be awesome! Although if this is one of those questions that’s too complicated for an easy answer I still appreciate your time and the info you have already provided.


    Thanks again.