My first thought is Not Gray.

Is your cedar fairly dark or more orangey?

Photo?

My thoughts are that rules are made to sometimes be broken, but a photo would help.

Hi! had trouble posting a photo but just uploaded. Responses are appreciated!:)

I'm wondering about navy with your siding color. This is Ben Moore's Hale Navy. Think about painting your garage door the same color as your siding instead of white. That will help pull focus off of it since it's in the front.

Thanks chloebud! Love Hale Navy.

Thanks Color Zen.:) A strong teal makes sense but I was hoping to find a color to lighten up the place a bit.

It will still add a pop of happy.