Software
Houzz Logo Print
goldblush

Is this normal? - Air scoop

8 years ago

Hello All,

I've just had an annual heating check up which revealed that the pipe connected to air scoop has been leaking and the water is affecting the integrity tank below. It's going to cost $600 dollars to replace.


This furnace was installed 4 years ago. Is it normal to have this expensive a problem to fix after just a few years? I wanted to ask for some perspective on whether this is normal or possibly a sign that it was not done correctly when it was installed?


Thank you so much for your input.





Comments (9)

  • 8 years ago

    Thank you so much for your insight Mike. It definitely warrants further investigation before paying so much. I wouldn't want to cut corners by any means but I do wonder if this was not installed properly and whether the repairs should cost so much. I will check out some youtube videos and see if any plumbers have dealt with this.

    Thanks again Mike:)!

  • 8 years ago

    Well, you say the $600 is to replace the tank? If it can be repaired, by all means do that. The problem is most likely the original installation. I'd all the folks who did that.

    goldblush thanked sktn77a
  • 8 years ago

    He said it was the air scoop and the copper piping that needed replacement.

    When I asked why it would have started leaking water like this he alluded to it being the manufacturer's fault. The company that procured all the parts and installed this furnace is the same one that does the yearly maintenance. If it had been installed properly could this have been avoided? Shouldn't there be a little more responsibility taken on the quality of their installation?

    Sincerely wondering.

  • 8 years ago

    I am not a plumbing expert but I will share my opinion. I think you are seeing corrosion caused by the connection of two dissimilar metals. The scoop is made from galvanized steel. This will cause a problem when connected directly to the threaded cooper fitting. One way to avoid this problem is to use a dielectric union. Here is a YouTube video explaining it. You should ask the plumber if he will make the proper installation this time.

    You can also ask him how may hours it will take to do the job. I feel he is taking advantage of you for a problem that could have been avoided with proper installation.

    goldblush thanked mike_home
  • 8 years ago

    Thank you so much Mike for your insight on this issue. My apologies for the late response. I've had computer issues for days.


    I will check out the video and get back to the installers about what I also believe is their responsibility.


    Thanks again Mike!

  • 8 years ago

    No need to apologize. Computers and plumbing always seem to create a crisis in our lives!

    Please post back any updates. I would like to learn how this resolved.

  • 8 years ago

    The green scale is a very good indicator of a leak along with the "bubbled rust" on the cast iron or brass fitting. All areas of the plumbing that shows the scale should be addressed first and foremost.



    If the tank is showing signs of pitting from the rust.. Replace it.. For the integrity has been compromised and it could fail.

    goldblush thanked Mule Meat
  • 8 years ago

    Everyone,

    I wanted to give you an update on the air scoop.


    The company agreed that the installation was not quite right and agreed to cover most of the cost of replacing most of the parts and installation. They asked us to cover the cost of some installation procedure they did that has a 50 year warranty which cost $200. Not sure it was worth that much:)...but honestly, I just wanted to get it done in a reasonable amount time and without too much acrimony.


    We just had it installed and here is how it looks:




    Thank you so much for your helpful advice and insight that I could refer to as I talked to them. Hoping that there will be no more stories of the heater for another 10 years at least:)!


    Thank you again everyone! Happy thanksgiving!


Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio