The tiles you purchased have a pink hue to them, won't work with the tones in the counter. It's your kitchen, you'll be there everyday, do you like the metal mosiacs enough? That's the question that needs an answer, not a poll.

If it's not your style and you want to replace, do not use what you have - keep looking

don't like the new ones. keep the current until you find something else.

I'd replace the current ones but not with the ones you picked. Pick the lightest color from your countertop and go with that (so it looks like it would be a tan/beige)

Replace with something! Squares on the floor, reflective squares on the back splash, busy granite...it's too much as a combo.

I voted keep as is because I figure if you just moved into a new place you probably have other things to deal with first. Those tiles are not really my style either, but I'd live in the place for awhile and see if I like the kitchen cabinets/layout before replacing them.

I don't like the suggested tile because they seem too pink and too cool for your warmer toned kitchen. I also don't love the graining it has to it. You already have a tone of movement in your kitchen. A solid colored tile would work best.

Tale out the backsplash, repair dry wall, and slap on some paint until you find a tile that works well. Tile needs to work with flloors, counters and paint so it is hard to give an opinion on your tile since we cannot really see the counters.

Use caution (would just cut out sheet rock with tile attached) when removing tile since it looks like there is glass in there. Prep work and plastic will be well worth the effort.

I would go with Sina's suggestion...lightest color from the countertops.

Pretty kitchen. I am sure you will find the right solution on your space.

Replace, but not with the option shown in the "Replace" vote

I would definitely replace but not a fan of your replacement choice, (sorry). The reason why is because they look too modern for your style of granite and kitchen. I also am not a fan of the graining in the tile. I agree that a lighter tile that matches the lightest color in your granite would look great. I'm a fan of subway tile, just not these particular ones.