Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_31748969

Experienced Cabinet Painters Please Help Advise

7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago

So I was gonna refinish these old maple cabinets but they won't take a stain well. Heavy blochyness. I've stained, didn't like the result, resanded, used wood conditioner (pre-stain), stained again and the same result. I personally think what happened is that the doors are a veneer. Certain spots I had to sand deeper to remove huge dents and gouges. So those thinner spots are soaking up less stain. Leaving it blochy even with pre-conditioner. On top of this, some of the doors have a really ugly grain pattern. Probably low grade veneer.

I'm an experienced wood worker and I think refinishing these cabs are a lost cause. I already wasted almost 2 weeks. So that being said, I think I'm done trying to refinish them and gonna paint. I already know how to do do this but I was looking at some refresher videos on youtube. One suggested that some people like to put on a coat of water based polyurethane after its painted for extra durability. Is this a good idea with an enamel paint?

Comments (5)

  • 7 years ago

    Maple has a tendency to stain blotchy and much as I like wood, maple tends to turn yellow - not due to the finish - though oil based finishes do not help. Maple has as a trait of the wood itself a tendency towards turning yellow. It does make a good paint grade wood. I am not a professional cabinet painter - just done some cabinet refinishing and painting in my own home.


    A good cabinet paint doesn't need a polyurethane coat. The biggest cause of lack of durability in my opinion is the prep work - so the bond between the wood and the paint is not as good as it should be. This won't be helped by another top coat. Since you have sanded the old finish off, a good primer will give you a good bond. Also, it is easier to touch up something which does not have a coat of polyurethane on top. Someone once pointed out, we don't poly our exteriorly painted homes - and they get lots of abuse.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I have half the cabinets stained light walnut. Turned out ugly. So I will have to sand that out yet again before I paint. What I did to prep for stain was sand them with 80-120 grit, then finished them off with 220 grit. Smooth as a babies bottom. What finish grit would you suggest I do before painting? Is 220 too smooth for paint to adhere? Im used to staining wood not painting. The only thing I usually paint is walls. lol

  • 7 years ago

    I think the 220 is fine. You might be able to go over the stain with Zinsser BIN or 123 if it is totally dry with just a minimal sanding. I have mostly used Zinsser 123 and it has held up well - over previously finished wood, but the cabinets are in my laundry room and not a high traffic area. The Zinsser 123 works great on bare wood.


    You could do a test area on the back of a drawer or door thats been stained. Give the primer a few days to cure and then try to scratch it off.

  • 7 years ago

    I use zinsser to prime everything. Thats my other concern, durability. This is a rental unit and I'm worried about how painted cabinets are gonna last. I'm gonna be using Sherwin Williams Emerald Urethane Enamel designed for cabinets. Its like $95 a gallon, I had a 40% coupon. I used their lower grade ProClassic paint on closets and trim for the tenants downstairs 3 years ago. They let me in the other day and they look just like they did when I painted them. And they have 5 kids lol. So I'm hoping this Emerald will be tuff. Its interior/exterior. So if it can withstand outdoor elements then cabinets should be no problem.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I painted my kitchen cabinets 17 years ago with an alkyd paint (when it was still available) and they still look great. We had 3 young teenage boys and a very small kitchen. I only ever sanded with 120 grit. I did use a primer (not Zinsser, which I've always been disappointed with) and sanded lightly between all coats. The most difficult part (for me) these days is getting a good end result with no brush strokes. I put the paint on with a roller and quickly tip it off with the paint brush.