Software
Houzz Logo Print
rddee

is this etching?

2 days ago

I tested some samples of “quartzite” from a supplier and this is what resulted. I placed 2 drops of lemon juice on the samples. Waited 30 seconds and then wiped with a dry paper towel. The result is this. Is this etching? Did I do the test correctly?

Comments (8)

  • 2 days ago

    The stains are in the right corner and also I put a small drop in the middle of the stone

  • 2 days ago
    last modified: 2 days ago

    Yes looks like it etched. The more quartzite looks like marble the more likely it is that it will etch as the calcium carbonate gives marble its lightness but is also what etches when an acid touches it. Acid breaks down calcite. Many white stones sold as quartzites have high cabonite properties and do etch like marble.

  • PRO
    2 days ago



    That ain't quartzite.

  • 2 days ago

    I was told by the seller that it was quartzite so I tested a sample… and this is what resulted

  • yesterday

    " I was told by the seller that it was quartzite so I tested a sample… and this is what resulted "


    Absolutely etching, and this is definitely more marble than quartzite as noted above, most white quartzites are closer to marble. And honestly the seller might have been told it was quatzite and took the wholesaler at his word.

  • yesterday
    last modified: yesterday

    Many of the "white" or gray quartzites are really dolomite/marble. They might be hard like quartzite, but are porous like marble/dolomite and will etch just like your sample. It would need to be sealed during installation and then at regular intervals. Sealing won't guarantee that you will never get stains or etching.

    Turns out you know more about stones than the slab yard salesperson!!

    Never believe what they tell you ... do your own research and testing.

  • 22 hours ago
    last modified: 22 hours ago

    Regular sealants will only prevent staining not etches. The Etch is not due to the porousness of a stone it is a chemical break down as acid eats through calcites. A resin like coating is the only thing to prevent etching.

  • 18 hours ago

    I'd say you did it right. The only thing that will attack Quartzite that quick is hydrochloric acid, but the citric acid in lemon juice will have no effect at all.

    If you want to test a slab when shopping the key is in the hardness. Quartzite is twice as hard as dolomite marble, and harder than window glass or steel. Using the edge of the slab try and scratch it with a knife, if it scratches the edge it's dolomite, if it doesn't it's quartizite. Then pull out the piece of glass, if the edge doesn't scratch the glass it's dolomite but if the glass scratches it's Quartzite.


Sponsored
Mary Shipley Interiors
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars34 Reviews
Columbus OH Premier Interior Designer 10x Best of Houzz