Software
Houzz Logo Print
forevernow

6 3/4" "deep" drawer depth too shallow?

7 years ago

I've found a cabinet style I'm liking a lot (waiting for the sample to arrive today to see if it looks as good in real life) at All Wood Cabinetry. They do semi-custom and have a limited selection but the quote I got is good and I like the general layout but I'm trying to figure out which base cabinets exactly. I found out the base drawer height is only 6 3/4" deep for the big bottom drawers. That doesn't sound deep enough to me, though the face frame is 8 1/2" so maybe that is the actual clearance? I have questions in but the designer I've been working with is out this week, someone else is supposed to get back to me but it may not happen if they are short staffed and I'm not going to be another designers priority. To complicate matters they are having a 30% off sale until the 30th so I'd like to take advantage of it if I can make this work (and the sample lives up to my expectations), but the drawers are concerning me. My large fryer that I use most often is 22" long and 7" high with the lid on. Also all the drawers are just over 5" narrower than the base width, so a 30" base has drawers that are only 24 7/8" wide inside. So inside dimensions are 6 3/4"H x 19 11/16" D x (Base width - 5 1/8")


Do these drawer depths sound workable? I've attached the pictures of the layout and how I"m thinking of organizing. I'm curious if people think this will work?


Here is a rendering of the layout. The island will have a trash pull-out, sink and dishwasher so no storage (well there is some on the back but the is just for "extra" stuff we wouldn't need access too much.


Here are the cabinets, I'm not really focusing too much on the uppers right now, I won't have many and may not even order them for a while longer because I need to think through some things first (like do I want to have a microwave shelf, do I want glass doors, do I want to go all the way to the almost 10" ceiling?


Here is the back wall. I'm thinking two 30" drawer bases and a 3" pantry pull out filler, but I could also do a 12" base for flat things (cookie sheets, cutting boards) a 15" for knives, cooking accessories (can opener, meat thermometer, garlic press, etc) and towels for the sink across the way, and 30" for dishes. The thing is a 15" drawer base will only have 9-10" drawers widths, that's not very big. I wish they had a bank of 4 narrower drawers but they have very limited selection.


And the side. I feel like to get any kinds of pan in these drawer bases I'd need at least a 36". I'd like to change the out cabinet to 24" and probably the upper too so that it is more centered between the window and door, but that only leaves room for an 18" in the middle.



Would really love some opinions. I'm getting exhausted trying to figure this all out.

Comments (11)

  • 7 years ago

    Bumping because I could really use some advice. I'd be curious to know what the average depth is for a drawer base. Thanks!

  • 7 years ago

    The interior width of my full-overlay drawers is 3.5" less than the drawer front. That is with side-mount glides and 1/2" drawer box sides.

  • 7 years ago

    Thanks Fori, that is really how it seemed to me too and I wondered if it was just me. I'm really liking the look of these cabinets, and got my sample today and it's lovely but the drawers may not be super useful. I could just get some standard shelves, or a base with one pull out and one adjustable shelf, but I'd hoped to do more drawers. Wish I had more time to think about it! I might just have to let this sale past and keep looking and thinking, but a part of me is so ready for this part to be over so I can start actually moving forward! Another kitchen designer at the cabinet company did get back to me today though and answered some of my questions so I may actually just try to call tomorrow and talk through it with them.

  • 7 years ago

    I would not buy these cabinets because it sounds like there is too much wasted space. I have a 28” drawer face with the interior of the drawer being 25”. Are the drawer slides on the sides of the drawers? The height you list is comparable to mine: an 8” drawer face has 5.25” inside.

    forevernow thanked traci_from_seattle
  • 7 years ago

    It does sound like there is either an error in sizing or a lot of wasted space. One other possibility is that they are planning for 4 drawers per unit, whereas your photo shows 3 drawers.

    For comparison, I have two 3-drawer units that are 36" wide (bottom drawer opening is 14-1/2" tall x 33" wide and inside of drawer is 13-1/8" tall x 31-1/2" width) and one 4-drawer unit that is 15" wide (bottom drawer has 7" tall and 13" wide opening, and inside dimensions are 5-5/8" tall x 11-1/2" wide). So my widths are 1-1/2" less than the opening width. Face frame elements are mostly 1-1/2" wide, but my math won't compare to yours because some of my cabinets were built as longer banks (e.g., the 15" drawer unit shares a wall and face frame stile with the adjacent prep sink and trash pullout).

    If the math is not making sense for the cabinets you're looking at, take a tape to a showroom if possible. Also, if you want to add more shallow drawers but don't have the option to get 4-drawer units, you may be able to find an aftermarket drawer-within-a-drawer unit that fits your drawers.

    forevernow thanked salex
  • 7 years ago

    traci - the slides are on the bottom.


    I asked for clarification of what the actual clearance was and was told that the actual opening is closer to 8" but the wall height of the drawer is 6 3/4". I stopped by Lowes today and just measured the drawers of several different cabinet floor models they had and it did seem that a 5" difference between the cabinet width and the interior drawer width was very common and most of the drawers depths were around 6 inches but the size of the actual opening varied. 8" is a much better clearance, though I am thinking after playing around more with the various cabinet types that for holding my pots and pans the pull outs might be better than the drawers.


    Salex - that is a lot like the cabinets we have now, they are all custom and part of one frame so the drawer widths to the frame is wider. Unfortunately, that is part of my problem, there is no way for me to cobble in a dishwasher when its all one big interlocking piece. This might all be a moot point. DH wants to build our cabinets himself, now that I"m pretty much ready to order some he's fighting harder for that. Though building it ourselves would give us more options, mostly it will take forever and though he is handy I am not 100% confident in his ability to build them all from scratch the way that I would want them. I really like the look of these cabinets. They are not custom so it would be accepting some limitations, or I could let DH try and build them and maybe get more custom options, or just a big headache.

  • 7 years ago

    Oh, yes, Salex I was wondering if you could find drawer within a drawer that was more generic or it they were only generally sold by the cabinet company. Does anyone know where to look for that kind of thing?

  • 7 years ago

    Ikea makes a drawer within a drawer. There's a bit of discussion of that product in this thread: https://www.gardenweb.com/discussions/5564904/ikea-cabinets-around-range-symmetry-or-function#23382175

    About making the cabinets rather than buying: I made my own cabinets (and am still making the last run of uppers). It's doable, but difficult to do production work in a small home shop. Even though I have a small shop at home, I am buying evening shop time at a local tech school so that I can use their industrial tools, their spray room, and their storage. Before starting on the kitchen, I "practiced" by making several shop and bathroom cabinets. I consider the minimum list of tools to be: a source of rough-cut lumber (or good S4S, but not home-store lumber), a jointer, a thickness planer, a table saw, a miter saw, a router table (and rail/stile bits), a drill press or drilling jig for drilling cup hinge holes, miscellaneous hand tools (depending on personal preference, but I use chisels and a hand plane regularly), and a good sander. Also, finishing is a dilemma - I typically finish my pieces with wipe-on custom stain and poly-varnish, but for my kitchen I'm doing spray lacquer. I would not do that at home.

    If I billed myself and DH for my time, at $50/hour (which is what our GC says my level of "craftswomanship" is worth) my kitchen cabinets would be ~$30k. They are 100% custom, inset, vertical grain Douglas-fir with top-of-the-line fittings - and purchasing them would have been about the same price in my area, compared to my price of ~$5k for materials plus my time. It would cost more if I had to buy tools. However, I also love woodworking and DH has the patience of the saint. Otherwise I would not recommend it.

    forevernow thanked salex
  • 7 years ago

    Salex, I knew I recognized your name. I believe you commented on one of my earlier posts about building cabinets yourself. When we first moved in we were just going to add an island and DH was going to build it, which I was fine with but we've had some big changes since then. He was laid off suddenly shortly after we bought the house and I had to go back to work (the timing worked out as my son just entered kindergarten).. He did find more work and we are much better off then we were before with me working as well, however our kitchen is extremely dysfunctional and he doesn't help with any cooking or cleaning. Working and trying to hand wash dishes for my family and deal with the wonky space with no storage and I am at the end of my rope. I do not have patience for DIY right now when it comes to this major source of angst in my life. There are so many things in our house that he could work on and build for and I would welcome everyone one of them but I just can't get excited about him doing the kitchen. I think he has most of the tools you mentioned but does not have a good source of wood. He also really isn't "in practice" with woodworking. He knows it, but hasn't honestly done much in the 10 years we've been married (think he did more when he was younger) so I'm not confident in him doing this. I do think he's capable of figuring it out, I just don't know what we'll have to go through to get to the end result. I think I'm about to find out though. He's insistent on doing it and as much as I am against it I can't just go drop $8K on cabinets if he's not in agreement with me. I thought I'd gotten him open to at least considering buying if I found something decent at a decent price but I guess not. I'm sorry, I'm feeling very disappointed right now. I'm not ready for this journey.


    Thank you for the link about the drawer in a drawer, I'll check it out!

  • 7 years ago

    Sorry for your disappointment - I sympathize and hope you get something more functional sooner rather than later. If he really insists on giving it a go, perhaps one option that could speed things along would be making the boxes and then ordering doors and drawers to size. I know Rockler sells them at custom size, and several others on this forum have posted threads about other sources. Good luck.