Software
Houzz Logo Print
sdaigneault

Opinions on this paint + cabinet color - should I change it?

7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago

I'm not sure this paint color (which I otherwise love in this space) works with the cabinet colors. They look too similar - and maybe also the color tone clashes? I'm not sure - I am regretting not choosing navy cabinets in this room - that would look so good!

Do I leave it alone? Do I paint the cabinets a navy (what I want to do)? Do I paint this portion of the walls a navy (I don't love "feature" color walls but maybe that's the most practical solution?)?



Leave it
Paint cabinets navy
Paint wall above cabinets navy

Comments (44)

  • 7 years ago
    I know a family member that painted navy cabinets with white countertops and it’s just fab against grey wall Some pictures on houzz show kitchens like this for inspiration.
  • 7 years ago
    Did the cabinets come that color or did you paint them?
  • 7 years ago

    No navy. If it really bothers you, and you must change something, change the wall color—but all of ‘em, not just one. If those are factory finished cabinets, you don’t want to paint them.

  • 7 years ago
    The cabinets came painted like this. They’re Kraftmaid with a suede finish. I guess I should consider different wall colors, sigh.
  • 7 years ago
    Here are more photos from today w the updated countertops.
  • 7 years ago
    Disclaimer notice - not a designer but....if it’s going to cause a headache repainting I se nothing wrong with it. Gold door handles and accesories or even a kitchen blind in an accent colour may make all the difference
  • 7 years ago

    Now that the countertop is on, it looks more intentional to me. Accessories, an accent color, more white, maybe something that has a mix of the two grays to make it seem intentional. If you have to repaint, I'd paint the walls and not the cabinets!

  • 7 years ago

    Is this a basement kitchenette?

  • 7 years ago
    I don’t think the 2 grays work well together and I wouldn’t paint the cabinets since they are factory finished. What are the 2 colors?
  • 7 years ago
    Yes, it’s a basement wetbar, so I figured painting the cabinets may not be ideal, I know the factory finish is much better, but maybe it wouldn’t be that big of a deal since it’s a wetbar that’s not used as often as a kitchen.

    The cabinets are gray pebble by kraftmaid, and the wall color is silver samovar by SW.
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I just wrote a whole big thing but I somehow deleted it before it posted. So let’s try this again: I do like both colors, just not together. And that stone is very pretty. ;) What’d you have planned for the wall above/behind the cabinets—shelving? Tile? Art? Because you might be able to salvage the room’s paint job after all...

  • 7 years ago
    I would paint the wall above the cabinets the same as the trim color. Then, add some open shelving and artwork.
    Steve Daigneault thanked annied75
  • 7 years ago

    Hey! What happened to the white countertop from the original post?? I just noticed that when I was looking at all the pictures again.

  • 7 years ago

    I wasn't sure about the wall behind the counter. I was thinking of some wood floating shelves and maybe a large piece of art - but nothing is really firm or planned. I guess I could also just tile the wall behind the wetbar - maybe a subway with dark grout up to the ceiling? I still will have the paint on the side walls which is my main concern w/ just addressing the wall behind the wetbar - like - will the side wall paint color be close enough to the cabinets to clash? The floors are going to be a polished concrete - so another grey. Some of these choices were made last minute - which is why I'm in this predicament. I have midnight lower cabinets in the kitchen which I love and am kicking myself for not using here.

  • 7 years ago

    I would not paint the brand new cabinets—the finish will never be better than what it is now. Tons of prep work with so so results. Find a new paint color. Are there going to be upper cabinets? If so maybe do a great backsplash? Bring in navy accents in other ways. I LOVE navy so I feel your pain

    Steve Daigneault thanked sowkmom
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I guess I can be happy that I have navy cabinets in the kitchen upstairs - this makes me appreciate them that much more lol. No upper cabinets above the wetbar. I really don't want to repaint the entire basement - that's going to be expensive - but I guess that's probably worth considering at this point as an option.

  • 7 years ago

    I would never paint the factory finish, which is many times better just regular paint job. The wall color definitely does not go with them though. That is what I would be painting. Very pretty color on the cabinets.

    Steve Daigneault thanked cat_ky
  • 7 years ago
    I would also just paint the walls.
  • 7 years ago

    Thanks everyone - looks like I'm going to paint the walls. Now I just need some color suggestions. THANK YOU Judy for BM Alfresco - I'll put that on my list. Any others ya'll want me to pick up at the store?

  • 7 years ago

    Sammy... regarding the white counters, that was a mistake, so the counter top people came back and installed the stone that I paid for...

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago


    You mention “navy”…pick up B.M. Westcott Navy:




    not for cabinets, but for the walls. I know, dark, dark,,,,but, your floor?

    Steve Daigneault thanked JudyG Designs
  • 7 years ago

    I'm using Cyberspace upstairs in the great room and I LOVE It there but there are a lot of windows/light. I was toying w/ a darker color downstairs but worry it's a basement and that might be too dark/gloomy. But a part of me sees the allure of that...


    The basement is a walkout, northwest facing, but the yard has a HUGE tree in it so it's shaded...

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Why don’t you get your floors in/done first, hang your artwork or shelving and then re-assess. Like I said before, you might not have to repaint... Also, the light is going to change in the space when the floors are finished. Wouldn’t it suck if you went through the trouble and expense of repainting the entire basement only to find that the new color looks awful with the flooring?

  • 7 years ago
    I hear ya, Sammy. But I think at this point I’m always going to see the two colors and it’ll bother me. It’s pretty clear to me I need a color that contrasts more than what’s there. The painter still has work to do, and I can leave the samovar silver in the basement bedroom, so it’s really just the family room and stairway.
  • 7 years ago

    Another thing to do (after the floors are in, of course!) to trick the eye so that the two colors can get along is to mirror that wall and add shelving over it. That’d also help with the lack of natural light situation.

    You can also go in the opposite direction and create a darker, moodier space by dimming the lights. Then the color issue would be a non-issue! If you’re putting in a pool table, and this will be primarily used as a bar area, then that’s worth considering. After looking at the second set of pictures again, especially the last one, it’s really not looking as dire as I thought.


  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    For north and west light, you have chosen a great color in the cabinets (that hint of lilac). West light loves certain greens, and this one I have used before. It is a winner on the walls:

    B.M. Mount Saint Anne



    Do the floor light…color of the countertops.

    AquaGuardBuff Creme Water-Resistant Laminate




  • 7 years ago

    The cabinets are beautiful. You are also having polished gray concrete floors, why would you want gray on the walls too. Put a color on the walls, that will compliment other things that are going in that room. Its going to be way too much gray otherwise. I would certainly never paint brand new factory finished cabinets. They are not the problem here. All the shades of gray that dont go well together are.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I'm sold on not painting the cabinets, but painting the walls again. And I'm sold on it being a color - not a grey. I think some kind of blue. I liked both the Alfresco and Westcot Navy Judy recommended - open to other color suggestions.


    Judy - the floors will be polished concrete, so greys with some brown variations. I have a camel/tan colored leather couch, and a rug with blues, greens and purples in it.


    Also Judy - the BM Sainte Anne is pretty but I think it's going to be the same problem that I have w/ Samovar Silver - it's too close in shade to the cabinets. I think I need a color that's deeper so there's more contrast. A medium dark blue - or dark blue...

  • 7 years ago

    Pick a color in the blues, and greens, from your rug, and use that for your paint color.

  • 7 years ago

    Here's the rug that I'll be using


  • 7 years ago

    Couple colors I'm considering for swatches...


    SW 6243

    Distance


    SW 7615

    Sea Serpent


    SW 7602

    Indigo Batik


  • 7 years ago

    If you are doing just an accent wall where the cabinets are, then sea serpent or indigo batik, will work well. If you are doing all the walls then I would go for the Distance. The other two colors while beautiful, will be too dark for all the walls.

  • 7 years ago

    I'm leaning against the accent wall color. It just feels like a dated design tactic. I agree - leaning towards the Distance (or Alfresco) since they are more mid-tone.


  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Hard to tell from the photo but looks like the cabinetry may be a warm grey and the wall a cool grey. Sometimes those don't mix so well.

  • 7 years ago


    SW Distance and SW Sea Serpent - I like both of them - and don't mind how dark Sea Serpent is. We have plenty of lighting and there will be art on the walls, etc. Will probably get some samples tomorrow to try them out. Also got a Color Muse that's coming to see if there are some other colors I should try.






  • 7 years ago

    The darker Color looks really nice!

  • 7 years ago
    I like the darker one. Really good contrast
    Steve Daigneault thanked Kobi
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    We agree. The darker color on the wall (bottom photo) looks great! It also works well with the rug you chose.

    Steve Daigneault thanked HomeDecorAZ
  • 7 years ago

    The cabinets look like they have a purple undertone, whereas the wall more blue? They are very similar, but not the same, yet don't have enough contrast between them either. I think the navy would look a lot better.

  • 7 years ago
    So it’s kinda hard to see these samples, the dark paints are not this dark in person. The second one from the left is Sea Serpent and the second one from the right is Cadet Song. These I think are my fav two. The far left is too purple. The others are too grey I think.

    I like cadet song a lot but not sure it goes as well with the cabinets as sea serpent.
  • 7 years ago

    Sherwin Williams 6529 Scanda could be good here? Not too deep nor light. It's a cool blue.


    Abolos also makes a reflective blue mirror tile called Echo, and in a couple of subway sizes. Also their Catherine is a different type of reflective as well, a lighter tone frosted blue, but I suspect it would be too light.


    Both have the nice beveled edge for interest. You can even order just one sample piece through Home Depot as a special order with free shipping :) but available elsewhere too. HD would be the way I'd go for sampling, which is probably even still returnable (I've done this before).

    Steve Daigneault thanked spisland
  • 7 years ago
    SW Distance has a higher LRV number of 15 and the coordinating colours are in your area rug.
  • 7 years ago

    I'm noticing new ('80's) 8 x 8 size in that blue mirror tile as well, a nice update size for those tired of subway.