Thanks justdesserts! :)

Beautiful home!

Camelot is beautiful and unique but the Sienna is a little more timeless. It will work with more finishes and styles as your taste transitions with time.

Best of luck with your project!

Thanks!

Both work. I would not white wash it. Beautiful as is.

Here's 2 additional/better photos of the Sienna and the Camelot choices.

Sienna. Also, no to the whitewashing! Love your home - if you want more cohesiveness, I'll exchange your garage doors for wood and paint the whiter areas a warmer color. LOVE your house!

Thanks Sammie J ! :) I think I'm leaning toward the Sienna. My concern was whether the diamond or kind of fish scale nature of that design will clash with the brick. When driving around the neighborhood I saw two older homes with much older Sienna like roofs...

Sienna. Remove the shutters but for the window over the entry, remove the "scroll work" on the garage, leave the brick as is, wood-look garage door. Lovely classic home.

Thanks! Do yo u have an example of what a wood look garage door looks like ?

Alli-I think the texture/color of the other roof sample would be more distracting than the "fish scales" of the Sienna. Here's a pic of a wooden garage door - if you go this route, match the stain color to your brick. You might also consider painting the white trim around the doors to match...

Thanks Sammie that's quite helpful.