Software
Houzz Logo Print
fatima2007

Over the range microwave vs. hood vent?

7 years ago

I'm torn between the two. We cook quite a bit and want maximum ventilation of fumes/smoke/etc. out of the house. We have an open floor plan with our living room a floor above our kitchen..meaning the smells rise fast! BUT, we don't have a ton of extra counter space for a microwave. Can we have both? (save space with an OTR microwave, along with comparable venting?) Are CFMs all that matter or is it also design? Pls vote based on your experience and help me decide! Thanks :)

Microwave, it vents just as good
Hood range, it vents better
Either, they vent equally
Other ideas/rationale, please comment.

Comments (30)

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    No question about it. Hood vent it the way to go considering your layout and how much your family cooks. Over the range microwaves could work well in kitchens where the residents do little actual cooking or which have window placement that provide natural air flow.

    Ladybugs212 thanked HomeDecorAZ
  • 7 years ago

    Thanks poppiepink for sharing. I’m curious do u think the microwave held onto the grease because of its shape or bad suction? Are you seeing grease on the vent hood? I only use the microwave to reheat or defrost food, if got rid of it I could reheat on the stove but I’m curious how do u defrost if u haven’t planned ahead?

  • 7 years ago

    If you have to keep the microwave, could something like this work for you?

    Also, def some things are easier with a microwave, but nearly everything is still doable without one :)


    Ladybugs212 thanked damiarain
  • 7 years ago

    HomeDecorAZ, thx for the input. we have a window in the kitchen, but most of the yr it's too cold to open it. That's what I suspected... the HD salesman has been trying to convince me that micro vents are just as good now and can pull 400 cfm and that i dont have to give up counter space.

  • 7 years ago

    damiarain, thx for the idea and picture. we're planning on putting in 42" cabinets, so i guess if we put in 30" we can mount the microwave under...i hate to lose cabinet space to a microwave, but perhaps its a better tradeoff than good venting? The more i'm thinking about it, i really want to have the convenience of a microwave for when i need it but don't want it bad enough to sacrifice counter, cabinet, or venting lol!

  • 7 years ago

    Yeah it’s all about trade offs. Another thought: is there a pantry space that could give up a shelf?

  • 7 years ago
    You are welcome Fatima! The splatters from grease collected underneath, even though i’m diligent to cook most things on the grill. The grime collected up and around the overhead cabinets from poor ventilation. As far as using the microwave for defrosting, i really have not had success using the microwave for that, since sometimes the edges get too warm. If i haven’t planned ahead; I use pantry items or something else to cook; say perhaps from frozen in the airfyer which does a great job! The new hood range is stainless steel and yes it will get grimy; but i imagine will be much easier to clean and less likely to hold any odor.
  • 7 years ago

    I suppose so...My kitchen is fairly small and i haven't had a pantry so i've used other storage spots in the house, which is partly what inspired the remodel. So i'm feeling a bit protective of giving up any storage space, but that very well could work, if we could get an outlet in close by.

  • 7 years ago

    Just as an aside, folks here can be pretty helpful when planning a remodel to get the best layout. If you want, you can share a drawing of the space, with dimensions - tho might be best to start a new thread (also: there’s a ‘new to kitchens’ post around here that is a great read for planning your layout and writing your post!)

  • 7 years ago

    A 600 CFM rated blower can barely move 400 CFM through a hood and its duct; to do that with tiny microwave oven vent passages would require a hearing threatening screaming mimi aerospace blower. An "eyebrow" hood (used in commercial baking) above a microwave oven might work, so long as one doesn't mind cleaning grease out of the microwave base.

    My preference is to use a Sharp OTC (over the counter) microwave oven mounted somewhere away from the range. Consider traffic to the MW to be independent of traffic around the range if more than one person is involved.

  • 7 years ago

    The salesperson knows not whereof he speaks. For your situation, you would be much better served with an actual hood over your stove. To save counter and shelf space, consider a microwave that can be hung from beneath a cabinet elsewhere. What you want to look for is a microwave with an accessory called a "mounting kit." (FWIW, that was my solution for where to put a microwave in my "space challenged" kitchen.)

    OTRs have limitations that put them in in the "better than nothing category." Higher fan CFM does not do much to overcome those limitations.

    The limitations start with OTRs being rather shallow in depth (15 to 16 inches deep) and having rather small intake ports positioned in a flat base and positioned towards the back of the unit. That does not offer much coverage of steam and other effluent from your stove's or cooktop's front burners. A hood with an actual canopy helps collect cooking steam and effluent plumes and direct them to the intake ports. An OTR's flat base does nothing to collect or direct the plume to the intakes.

    There are, to be sure, vent hoods with flat bases. Those hoods can be short in height -- something to be considered if your kitchen cabinets do not leave room for a taller hood with an actual canopy. (That was the case in my own kitchen.) If your choices are constrained that way, you could consider a slim hood but try to find one that is as deep (front to back) as you can get and with intake ports as large you can get so as to cover as much of the stove top as possible. Further complicating the limitations of OTRs, you have described an open kitchen and large adjoing space. That often means there will be air currents in the room which further complicate the difficulties of good capture of effluent plumes.

    In addition to damarian's suggestions, you might also note that this topic has been coming up several times per year so you might want to try searching for past threads, too. Maybe go out to google/bing/whatever and include "gardenweb" in your search string (the onboard search engine here can sometimes be hit or miss.).


    Ladybugs212 thanked jwvideo
  • 7 years ago

    Microwave vents do not work well, the mirowave ends up falling apart, gets filthy and discoloured, then you have an eyesore prominently and permanently on display in your kitchen. We don’t use a microwave enough to deal with that again. We put a microwave on our fridge, inconvenient? Maybe, but we don’t use it much. And if it starts to fall apart it will be easy to remove.

    Ladybugs212 thanked J Williams
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    jwvideo, you made a lot of great points that are helpful...we have an adjoining dining space that's large and then a balcony style living room a level higher, so both contribute to the challenge i suppose. I read through as many related posts as i could find, but i couldn't find a specific answer about if CFMs are equal between the 2 styles...the HD salesman was adamant that OTR micros have gotten better and that i can't pull>400 out of the kitchen anyway and that performance is equal. Obviously i was skeptical, so i'm glad i came here to ask. I'm considering adding a 30" cabinet next to the pantry and mounting the microwave under, or just mounting the microwave alone, next to the pantry.




    J WIlliams, thanks for weighing in. That grime and gunk is exactly what i fear. Many people i know deny that it happens, but i guess i agree with you, it's not a permanent fixture.

  • 7 years ago
    That’s a perfect spot to add something like the picture that damiarain posted/suggested. Put it in a cabinet above the counter, then the counter can be used to rest the plate/bowl/mug/whatever on when putting in or taking out of the microwave. The HD salesperson doesn’t know dookie, a proper hood will beat any micro with venting any day in any test - it’s really not even a competition.
    Ladybugs212 thanked iamtiramisu
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    >>>"I'm considering adding a 30" cabinet next to the pantry and mounting the microwave under ..."<<<

    Good idea. Is there an electrical outlet at that location where you could plug in the MW? Maybe one on the wall too low to show up in your photo? If so, get it raised up to where you can use it when the cabinet is in.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Just get a small microwave and have it on your counter. You have a perfect place in the pictures shown. Have a wall outlet put there. When it dies, it will be easy to replace (and microwaves DO die!).

  • 7 years ago

    Jwvideo I have an outlet next to the light switches but I think it goes to 15 amps. We may need to look at an additional outlet on that wall. I think I’ll either mount the micro alone, under an additional cabinet, or inside of it.

  • 7 years ago

    We are doing something very similar to the picture damiarain posted above. Only ours has a shelf so that the microwave can have space to vent out of the back or be deeper (our wall cabs are the standard 12"). We also got one that was 3 inches taller than the cabinets next to it so it could be placed a little lower to the counter for easier access. We will find a small countertop microwave to put there so it is easily and cheaply replaceable if needed. In our case it is going between the fridge and the pantry so we wanted it raised up so the counter can still act as landing space/ breakfast prep area.

  • 7 years ago
    I would not put in a microwave for cooking purposes unless it is vented out of your house in some way and our microwave/vent combo did work that way. The majority of these types of microwaves just circulate the air within the room. It is not that type of exhaust fan. We are just finishing up a renovation where we installed a vent hood vented through the attic up and out of the roof. It is actually very attractive, even though you see very little of it. The baffles are easy to remove and wash. Great lighting and three speeds. It was more of an investment than the typical microwave/vent, but worth every penny. We ended up purchasing a counter microwave and placing in the cabinet in a shelf at the same height as most place them over a stove or in a tower cabinet. All in all, it wasn’t that much more in cost, cause the microwave was cheaper and it eliminated the trim kit if installed in a tower cabinet with a wall oven. Here are a couple pictures of the hood and the cabinet where we have the microwave neatly tucked away. Again, I will never have a kitchen where the exhaust fan is not vented to the outside. Good luck!
  • 7 years ago

    Sandra, i agree a vent to the outside is lightyears ahead of the idiotic fans that recirculate the same air...i was trying to choose between a vent out microwave vs. hood vent. I'd never consider a microwave that recirculates.

  • 7 years ago
    I’m sorry I didn’t read the post well enough to understand what you were asking Fatima. And I learned something new. I didn’t realize you could vent a microwave like that. Ours was over the stove and I hated it for many reasons. Glad it’s gone. Good luck with your project!
  • 7 years ago

    Hood fan. No question about it. For me, anyway.

  • 7 years ago

    Recirculating fans are generally pretty pointless. Their only redeeming feature is that they can redirect hot air from a gas stove to a location where it is less annoying. That's really very little benefit overall.


    There really only is a single recirculating vent hood that has been reported to actually work in reducing cooking smells. It's made by Vent-A-Hood. It's pretty pricey and has bulky filter cartridges that need to be removed every 5 years (give or take). If you live in an apartment that can't vent to the outside or if make-up-air is impossible to install, then this actually is a really good product and nicely fills this niche market. Everybody else is better served by a hood that vents to the outside.


    After reading the above, it should become apparent that there is no way a similar system could fit into the tiny confines of a microwave oven. So, don't expect recirculating over-the-range microwave/hoods to do much if anything. Microwaves that vent to the outside are moderately more useful, but they still suffer from the same physical limitations of simply being to small to effectively capture cooking fumes.

  • 7 years ago
    My opinion is that a real vent hood is a necessity if you cook. And the hood size, design, and fan flow rate (typically measured in cubic feet per minute) all dictate how well the system works to capture and exhaust fumes, heat, moisture, and smoke.

    We put in a large wood hood with a zephyr DCBL insert. It exhausts straight to the roof. Height above the cooking surface is also important. Too low and it could get dangerously hot and you’ll be banging your head. Too high and it may not be effective. Too small in either width or depth and it may not perform adequately.

    I will note that ours works great but I do have to be careful of the corners if I move from working at the countertop to the stove. I have bumped my head.
  • 7 years ago

    I'd go for the hood venting. Just for even the added head room while you cook is a great luxury. We have a bosch speed oven combo microwave over a a bosch wall oven. We contemplated the drawer microwave but the drawer opened too slow for me plus I am a little clumsy and saw myself spilling things putting them in below a counter.

  • 7 years ago

    Unfortunately, we don’t all have the option for hood venting and a microwave. I stayed with an over the range microwave in my remodel because I just don’t feel I had the space for both. And it’s really fine. Could a hood be better? Most likely, but this is functional enough.

  • 7 years ago
    Most over-the-range microwaves have an “exhaust” fan which simply blows smells and fumes back into the kitchen. I prefer to have an actual exhaust hood which sends fumes and odors to the outside of the house through the wall or roof.
    I am not aware of an over-the-range microwave which is part of an exhaust ventilation system which vents to the outside.
  • 7 years ago

    We had one, it still didn’t work great, the handle ended up falling off, it got coated in grease, the plastic deteriorated. We also have a very small kitchen with limited counter space and unless this kitchen was in a closet, ie. I was in a 1 bed 1 room apartment, never again.

  • 7 years ago
    Replacement cost for micro vent combo is another consideration. When ours died it was >$700 to replace, plus the cost to repair the wall since we couldn't find one with the exact dimensions. The always greasy vent slats were a huge pain to clean and it was hard/hazardous to get hot heavy items out (I'm short). I have a small cheap countertop microwave now. I pretty much only use it to reheat leftovers or coffee, and melt butter so I don't need a super powerful one. At $30 I consider it practically "disposable."
    Ladybugs212 thanked Danette