Software
Houzz Logo Print
mlee1976

Wood for Custom Kitchen Cabinets

7 years ago
I am deciding between two different craftsmen for custom kitchen cabinets. I am planning to do a stained wood island and painted cabinets along the perimeter. Other than price, one of the main differences is the wood they plan to use for the cabinets. The more expensive bid prefers to use soft maple for the painted cabinets and cherry (he says it’s a very high grade cherry) on the island. The less expensive bid (actually by 12-13k) would like to use poplar for the painted cabinets and gave me the option of walnut or mahogany for the island. I will note that the difference in price also relates to the first bid including paint and instillation while the second bid does not. Any suggestions on what I should use? I live in South Carolina BTW. The room will get a moderate amount of exterior light. Honestly, I like the look of cherry, walnut, and mahogany equally. My concern is more related to durability.

Comments (13)

  • 7 years ago

    Soft maple is superior to poplar in several ways (stronger under load, less likely to dent, etc), though they both sand smooth and paint very nicely. Poplar is cheaper, so the lesser material cost is no doubt part why the poplar guy's quote is lower.


    As for high grade cherry vs mahogany, they are both lovely in my opinion, and cherry can be stained to have a hue similar to mahogany- they are both reddish woods.



  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Any cabinet maker who does not finish and install is a wood hobbyist, not a cabinet maker. Finishing is half the cost of building the cabinets if it’s being done with the right products, in a clean roof. The right products are not “paint”. It’s a post catalyzed varnish.

    Poplar moves a lot more than maple. That guarantees more normal finish separation at the stiles and rails of the door. It’s also much softer. It’s fine for a low budget projects with the right expectations of how it will wear. But it’s not what I‘d want for most custom grade jobs. Remember that custom is not synonymous with quality. Someone can custom butcher wood badly, slap some house paint on it, and label it “custom”. You have to look a lot deeper than the label. Specifics matter.

    The second guy is a rule out completely. You need much more information on the specifics from the first about what hardware he uses and his finishing process.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    The first bid includes paint and installation, and offers more high quality and more durable material. In the long run, you will be better off with the first bid in my opinion.

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    IMO wood cabinets for painted ones are not the right choice I think MDF takes paint much better does not expand and contract so no unsightly little crack lines in the paint finish.BTW without knowing your style hard to comment on the island material but I love all white cabinets with a walnut island counter or if you are a bit more contemporary a whole kitchen done with white uppers and walnut lowers



  • PRO
    7 years ago

    MDF is the recommended material for paint cabinets doors. No crack lines.

    IMO there is little reason these days to use a custom cabinet maker.

    Are they using full extension glides on drawers?

    Soft closing hardware?

    Concealed hinges?

    All these features cost a lot on the part of the shop and if they are not buying in volume this costs them too much to offer as standard.

    Big cabinet companies have the proper equipment and latest finishing techniques to provide you with the best finish. Custom IMO is a step down as it relates to kitchens.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    For paint, MDF will always give better performance. Wood expands and contracts, which will show as normal cracks between the individual wood joins. People hate that. They want it smooth, no cracks, which means wood not behaving like wood. Which is why MDF gives better performance for those who want wood to not look like wood.

    For recessed center panels, veneer over MDF has been industry standard since the 60's. It's a much smoother surface that accepts veneers without telegraphing the wood grain of the plywood underneath. Yes, you can do a reverse raised panel, but again, glued up bits of solid wood WILL behave like solid wood, and that means cracks telegraphing between joins, and ghosting around the perimeter during dry winters. Cracks in the finish will lead to issues if people don't take care of their cabinets and not drip all over them and flood them with water.

    Some people don't mind wood behaving like wood, and embrace the finish cracks between pieces as showing that they bought "real wood". Those people are in the distinct minority.

  • 7 years ago

    Um what? Since when is custom solid wood a step down from mass produced MDF?

    I was at my city's home and garden convention earlier this spring and got to see a lot of custom Amish cabinetry - it was exquisite, whether stained or painted, and the drawers and doors used all the fancy soft close and hinges. Amish carpenters have access to all that stuff too, so it's not like making decent hinges is some secret capability of big cabinet factories or anything. Also dovetailed drawers and stuff. What mass manufacturer is going to bother with stuff like that?

    Also custom cabinetry has the large benefit of being designed and built specifically for your space. And offering you truly custom designs.

    Agreed.

    Some people don't mind wood behaving like wood, and embrace the finish cracks between pieces as showing that they bought "real wood". Those people are in the distinct minority.

    Guess I'm in the minority, but then again, I have marble and onyx in my master bathroom and am ok with etching, spotting, etc.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    I'm SO happy I did NOT go with a local custom cabinet maker! I've VERY HAPPY I went with Shiloh cabinets, an upper-mid-range cabinet company.


    I decided a couple of months ago to re-claim my dog cubby in the kitchen. Since Godfrey died, it's not being used by the dogs the way Godfrey and Shimmer did, and I decided I wanted the "real estate".. I called my KD company and asked them to order a sample drawer front in the same color as I used before: SW Repose Gray. I was warned it might not match - the cabinets are 3 years old. If they didn't, I had ordered a door and shelves when I did the cabinets, and could order pull-outs.


    The drawer sample came in and we looked and looked and looked at it and it was a very good match. So I ordered 2 drawers. This AM, they were installed and you would never know they had not been there from the beginning. I doubt a local cabinet guy could have matched them as well. So much of cabinet making these days is run by computers, and frankly the quality is more uniform and reliable. A large company can afford the latest, state of at the art, paint techniques.


    When I did my kitchen 2 years ago, we used Shiloh's standard hinges - did not pay for the upgrade to Blum. Now, the cost of the upgrade is only a few dollars so I did order them. All work perfectly.


    I'm thrilled with my new drawers. When DGS1 gets home from college this weekend, I'll try to grab him for an hour or so next week to line these drawers with cork and fill them with their new occupants. I'll take pictures then and post them.


    I could not possibly be any happier with Shiloh. The guy who came today is not the one who installed my cabinets but he did do the final trim work. When he was finished with the drawers, he looked around and started adjusting doors and drawers throughout the kitchen - he has that kind of eye. I mentioned that I had always wondered why the doors under my sink were kind of "concave" where they met in the middle. He opened them and said the stops had never been installed, went to his truck, found some, and installed them. How, all on the same plane as the panel above! This guy is gifted! I asked him if he preferred Shiloh or Mouser (the other brand carried at this store). He said he could not imagine paying that much more for Mouser - Shiloh was very high quality.


    From the horses mouth...

  • 7 years ago

    I would only use custom cabinets if installation is included. That way if a problem arises the cabinet maker is able to deal with it rather than the installer blaming the cabinet maker or the cabinet maker blaming the installer.

  • 7 years ago

    I am SO happy I went with a custom cabinet maker! At every meeting, he repeated 2 phrases: "I don't want there to be any surprises", and "I just want you to be happy". He lived up to both statements.

    We were able to customize sizes exactly - the sink cabinet was built with the sink in hand, so it was a perfect fit, and the cabinets on each side sized to fit - no extra fillers at all. I was able to specify sizes precisely: I needed my rice cooker to fit on the Super Susan, so the middle shelf was not positioned in the middle, but a little higher, so the rice cooker would fit on the bottom turntable. I specified the depth of my bottom drawers, so my cake pans would fit vertically. I described a pullout for over the fridge (thinking I had come up with something unique), and he said "Sure, I've done that before!"

    The installer, who had been with the company for 22 years, was a magician, and very conscientious. At the end of the first day, one of the drawer fronts wasn't installed. He told me that he wasn't happy with the way it looked, so he called the shop and had them make a new one. I never even saw the one he rejected. He showed me how to adjust the hinges, in case they needed seasonal adjustment.

    There were a couple of things that were different from the plans - and they were changed quickly and cheerfully.

    Oh, yes, we have full extension glides and soft-close hinges from Blum; heavy-duty glides for my larger drawers; the stain color was mixed at the shop, with a number of test pieces for me to bring home, so I could choose the one I liked best (or start over, if I didn't like any of them); I was able to tour the shop while my cabinets were in process, which was pretty cool; yes, they applied the finish in a clean room.

    My project did get delayed a bit, and Hubby and I were on vacation when the countertops were installed. My cabinet guy (Dan) came to the house to supervise the installation. It's been 6 years, and I know that if I had any problem at all with my cabinets, he would take care of me.

  • 7 years ago

    This is the internet. Just because someone says it forcefully, doesn't make it true. I far prefer the look of paint on wood than the fake look on MDF - reminds me of thermafoil. But that's just MHO.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    So many old lies still about custom cabinetry, while still true in some places (I'm sorry if you live there), in general they are a result of lack of current information as of the mid 2000s. Most old school non CnC shops that earned this old rap are long gone as they also focused on tract housing, which is now dominated by factories.


    You should be able to find high level custom cabinets for comparable costs to mid-upper range factory. Look carefully at store displays of both, measure heights and depths of cabinets, examine hardware, look under the uppers, look at the bare bases without counters... often its hard to examine in a showroom setting, but while there look at the filler joints.


    For the same price as upper/mid range factory, I'm getting custom, euro frame local cabinets with superior hardware, superior construction deeper boxes with thicker walls, no plastic corners, thicker doors, superior finishing, arriving in better condition with fewer service issues. I know the guy selling CnC machines to most higher end custom cabinet shops in the region for the past 1-2 decades. Many including my fav, have climate controlled finishing rooms.


    Less middlemen, commissions, mistakes, shipping makes up a lot of hidden dollars. There isn't a bean counter (former one here) shaving a few more pennies from each box or piece of hardware at your expense, worried about the shareholders and their bonus. If its close, compare installation costs between custom vs factory. Count the extra load of waste. Factory requires more on site fabrication and usually doesn't include any accommodations for counters, cantilevers & built in appliances, crown & light rails, all which are usually ready to go when built in a custom shop. I do occasionally buy factory cabinets but only if there is a significant cost advantage.