Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_295461941

unidentified succulent not doing well

7 years ago

What kind of succulent is this?



Since purchase ~3 weeks ago, it has steadily declined in health. The leaves do not seem as plump as before, some are completely withered, and it is slowly browning. It doesn't look any better after watering.


It is usually in a south-facing window, and gets watered twice per week. Several other types of succulent were purchased at the same time, and are doing well with the same treatment.


Any suggestions?


Thanks.

Comments (10)

  • 7 years ago

    Maybe the photo was too large.. reduced version:

  • 7 years ago

    This isa mesemb, called oscularia. Cant tell you details about it aloebot is more knowledgeable on the subject. I can tell you that they are more finicky than most succulents in general , because they have rest cycles and whatnot.

  • 7 years ago

    Watering that often usually leads to problems, as evidenced by your O. deltoides in decline. The mix must be super-porous for such watering, and yours might not be there. IMO, succulents in general, unless they're pots in hot climates, don't need to be watered as often. This one pictured is not a needy Mesemb, as most Mesembs go, as long as you give it proper drainage and full sun. What kind of soil do you use? BTW, this one, and maybe the rest of the ones you got, grow best in full sun.


  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I’ve found this plant to be super easy to grow, but could be my climate. It’s a pretty common succulent to see in people’s yards in California.

    Like Cactusmcharris has said ”watering that often usually leads to problems”, and twice a week for this guy is too much imo. I water mine once every 10 days or so and recieves plenty of sun because mine lives outside.



    I personally like them really clumpy and tightly compacted. These guys can get lanky with insufficient light. Here’s an example of a piece that was in a pot that didn’t receive enough light.



    If you’re able to keep outside protected from summer rains then do so;).

    Lastly the soil should be amended with half pumice or perlite.

  • 7 years ago

    Thanks for the responses -- very helpful!


    Yes, it seems I've been overwatering. I'll reduce to once every 10 days or so, though I also found a recommendation on the internet to frequently water very lightly with a spray bottle.


    It's still in the pot that it came in from the store. As far as I can tell, there's a layer of sand on top, but regular potting soil underneath. I'll repot with a better draining mix as recommended.


    It won't be easy to give it more sun, given my living situation, but maybe I can figure out some sort of grow light.

  • 7 years ago

    Thanks cactusmcharris.


    As recommended, I took the plant out of the pot, and discovered four plants. I let them dry overnight, and managed to get most of the soil off.





    They are now repotted with half pumice and half soil.



    Hopefully they aren't already too far gone. I still need to work on a grow light.

  • 5 years ago

    Just to finalize this old thread, I can report that I eventually got around to setting up a grow light which adds to natural light, in time for one of my oscularia to survive and start doing fairly well.




    Thanks again for the help!

  • 5 years ago

    Excellent! I find that oscularia is either happy and grows well, or not

  • 5 years ago

    Wonderful!