Color 1 is Benjamin Moore Ashwood

color 2 is sherwin Williams color match of Ashwood

The pink undertone on 2 is only noticable in certain lights on certain walls. It’s so frustrating

and color 1 sometimes looks too silver And not warm. Again depending on lighting.

None of the colors go with the warm wood flooring. The flooring needs warm off whites and a warm gray, not a blue gray. Paint a couple of big pieces of foamcore with samples to help you finalize your choices.

I dont like either 1 or 2. Both have a muddy almost dirty look to them.

Need some pictures to better indicate the light in the room. That will really help the decision making process. How much sunlight, etc

I agree with cat_ky, the samples look dirty. Also, why a SW colour match of a BM colour? If you're planning on buying SW paint, disregard BM samples. And yes, the colours will look different depending on the light which is why it's recommended to live with colour samples (on boards or canvases, not actual wall) in the room for a few days to observe in natural and artificial light throughout the day.

We have our main walls painted a beige with pinkish undertones. BM Barely Beige. Works great in our home, since we have mostly windows facing north and east (hate this in the winter, grateful in the summer). Back when greys were the IT color, we tried pretty much every popular BM and SW grey, but they all made our home look ice cold and drab and we hated them all. So the moral of the story is that you really have to paint a sample on multiple walls (or at least paint poster board) and watch it at all times of day. As a little funny story, when we first moved in, we painted everything two shades of blue that I loved on paper and in photos. When we finished, we realized we created our very own ice palace. Made us cold for the entire 3 months that we lived with it!!! Lol!

Hi Alicia, with those floors I would go with Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter.

Good luck