Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_469081858

Outlet attached directly to baseboard

7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago

Hello,

I have a 100+ year old home that has a bunch of ungrounded outlets. To make them more safe I was going to replace them with GFCI outlets. I turned off the power and opened the first out up to find that it didn't have an electric box and that it was screwed directly into the baseboard. I imagine this is very unsafe. Would a decent way to address this be to go purchase a plastic electric box, widen the hole in the baseboard, attach the box to that baseboard and then mount the new GFCI plug?




Comments (13)

  • 7 years ago

    That looks like early second-generation NM cable to me, not knob and tube. The wires appear to be plastic-insulated, but the sheath looks like the old cambric stuff. I don't see a ground, no surprise.

    During about the first third of the 20th century, it was fairly common for light fixtures and receptacles to be mounted without boxes. I don't have references for the code of that era, so I don't know when boxes became a requirement, but I will say that when I've run into something like what you have there, it's always been knob and tube. So I'd be suspicious that your installation wasn't even to code when it was originally done.

    You could probably do as you mentioned -- enlarge that hole and install an old work box. You'd have to work carefully with your saw to avoid damaging the cable. For jobs like this I prefer a keyhole saw to any kind of power saw. It's slower, but errors are less likely.

  • 7 years ago

    DavidR is spot on. I actually like my litle Milwaukee cordless "Hackzall" for things like that. Most of the keyhole saw blades are a bit too wide for this work though I have one I call "the steak knife" which works well in tight spaces. Rather than having the normal saw handle it just has a handle like a file.


  • 7 years ago

    Call an electrician and have him come and repair it, and then ask him about the rest of the wiring in your house. If the rest of your wiring is like that, it probably should be rewired.

  • 7 years ago

    Appreciate suggestions about replacing the wiring but it's not in the budget to do so. Replacing outlets is the scope at this point.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    All good comments about box installation, but how will you install a GFCI outlet without a ground?

  • 7 years ago


    GFCI doesn't require a ground wire. Changing outlet to be TR and provide shock protection.

  • 7 years ago

    As HU points out, GFCI doesn't require a ground. In fact, it is the allowed way to provide a grounded-type receptacle without actually having a ground. You can also use a GFCI breaker. It is required that you mark all such receptacles "NO EQUIPMENT GROUND" on them when you do this.

  • 7 years ago

    My guess .....your house burning down isn’t in the budget either....I would have an electrician check the whole house out...then rest easy or keep a suitcase packed in your car....whichever applies

  • 7 years ago

    I appreciate your concern, ritasj (person on the internet I don't know providing no additive information to this post). An electrician has been out here to look at the wiring already.

  • 7 years ago

    When it's treated with respect and used within its capabilities, old wiring is not usually unsafe.

    In fact knob and tube technique kept the conductors separated by several inches, and added supplemental protection where the conductors were closer together or potentially exposed to damage. Although there are good reasons that code now requires all the conductors of a circuit to run close together in the same raceway or cable, K&T's separation had other safety advantages.

    Also, K&T splices were soldered. Solder adds mechanical strength to a splice, and keeps out moisture and air. I've run into wirenutted splices that had developed high resistance and were overheating, but I've never yet seen a soldered splice that did.

    Finally, while I'm sure there were exceptions, from what I can tell, most K&T was installed by pros and not DIYed.

  • 7 years ago

    I usually ignore sarcastic remarks...but when I see...I have a 100 year old house...with electrical problems...I imagine it is unsafe...can I just do this little part myself....asking the advice of “persons on the internet” how a layman should do it...... no mention of an electrician....duh...

  • 7 years ago

    I apologize and acknowledge my comment was a little sarcastic...as well ...so can we just call it even?