Software
Houzz Logo Print
aineskow

Best heat source for tiny kitchen that currently has none?

7 years ago

Hi all,

I started planning my new kitchen over a year ago (see one thread here which has photos/dimensions: https://www.houzz.com/discussions/5116529/preliminary-layout-for-tiny-galley-feedback-welcome). Things are going slowly due to life/work/funds etc.


My kitchen is very small - ~9x9 - and has no heat source, which isn't ideal when it's 30 below outside (I live in Minnesota). I'm tough and all, but I'd still like to get some kind of heat source in there and am considering the following options: get proper ductwork in there so I have heat and AC, do a toekick heater, or infloor radiant heat.


I have had 2 remodeling companies give bids for the kitchen ($50K+), and I asked both about heating options. Both poo poo'd the toekick heater saying it would be insufficient. One recommended simply getting HVAC work done - this would result in a vent at the end of the kitchen that is close to my dining area, which has its own vent (I'm skeptical of this). This same contractor said to NOT do infloor heat because they always break, and are very costly to replace because you have to tear everything out. The second contractor had better things to say about infloor heat.


I had thought a toekick heater would be the simplest/cheapest solution, but am unsure if these can be used with IKEA cabinets (which is the direction I'm headed in).


I would love to hear people's opinions on pros/cons, and keep in mind cost is a factor. Thank you!

Comments (18)

  • 7 years ago

    In-floor radiant is amazing. It takes a while to adjust to temperature swings (as in, it takes several hours), but once it reaches equilibrium temperature, it is oh so cozy. Much nicer than forced air.


    But I believe your contractor might be onto something. I have heard lots of stories of electric radiant floor heating failing over time. Also, unless your electric rate is really low, it tends to be expensive to operate, as resistant electric heating is just not a very efficient way to product heat.


    This is fine in a bath room, where you only want to take the chill off in the morning; and where failure isn't catastrophic. But if you actually need reliable heating throughout the entire winter, it probably isn't a great solution.


    On the other hand, we have hydronic radiant heating, and I can only recommend it. Those systems have been around for decades and when installed properly they can last forever. Initial investment cost is high though. It would absolutely be cheaper to extend your existing HVAC solution. Installing a boiler and all the necessary pipes only makes sense if you plan on installing heating for several rooms. On the other hand, I was surprised how cheap the marginal cost of retrofitting another room is, if you already have a working system in your house.


    Maybe, you could change tack completely and instead install a minisplit system. That would give you heating and cooling. I believe Mitsubishi makes a minisplit that is suitable for cold climates. Minisplit systems are extremely efficient and they can quickly adjust the temperature in the room that they are installed in. They are very much a point of use technology, though. You need one unit per room; but that seems to be exactly what you are asking for.

    AMS thanked M
  • 7 years ago

    what is your electric rate? How do you heat the rest of your home?


    TD

  • 7 years ago

    Thanks everyone for your comments!

    @User - thank you! I didn't know this was a thing, and I just did some searching on my electric company's website, and it turns out I can get a Home Energy Audit for $60, I will definitely sign up for this!


    @M - thanks for your thoughtful feedback. I have heard good things about hydronic radiant heat, but that isn't an option for me for precisely the reasons you mention (costly to get the whole system set up for a single room). I hadn't considered a minisplit, simply because my kitchen is so tiny. I don't really need the air conditioning part - it doesn't get that hot here, and interestingly the AC seems to reach the kitchen fine (from other rooms) - I really just notice the cold (I suspect the walls may not be well insulated - hopefully my home energy audit will confirm).


    @tigerdunes - I looked at my electric bill and did some math, it looks like $0.16 per kWh (is that what you mean?). I have central heat, with a gas furnace.

  • 7 years ago

    I would look into a 1 ton mini split HP..your electric rate is not cheap is there no way to add ductwork to your small kitchen and handle heat with existing furnace? After all, I suspect BTUS required would be very small. Just brainstorming...


    IMO

    AMS thanked tigerdunes
  • 7 years ago

    Thanks tigerdunes - I'm sure there is a way to get ductwork into the kitchen (I have a basement with unfinished ceilings), I just assumed it would be really expensive. I should just get an HVAC company out to give an estimate.

  • 7 years ago

    We are north of you and had the same issue in our 12x 12 kitchen. It did have one small radiator ( we had hot water rads), but it was so cold, I avoided the room whenever I could.

    We added a toe kick heater and it totally solved the problem for about five years until we changed our heat to a ducted system.

    We also added new windows so it was probably a combination of the two things.

    AMS thanked daisychain Zn3b
  • 7 years ago

    With such a small area to heat, I don't think running cost for resistance electric heat is going to be significant (maybe $10 per month for 6 months, if installed with reflective underlayment in a reasonably well insulated room)

    AMS thanked sktn77a
  • 7 years ago

    I'm in St. Paul and in my previous home, also a 9 x 9 kitchen in a 100 year old home, I did the toe kick heater. I don't know where you are located but Snelling Heating did it for me. I no longer live at that house but it worked out just fine.

    AMS thanked Rudebekia
  • 7 years ago

    another thing to look into is that our Province had a program running for awhile where if you had an energy audit done and then improved insulation or windows, you could get a rebate. You might want look into seeing if your state has any incentives like that if your doing the audit anyways.

    AMS thanked daisychain Zn3b
  • 7 years ago

    With such a small area to heat, I don't think running cost for resistance electric heat is going to be significant


    When we bought our house, it had electric baseboard heaters in the in-law unit. We live in coastal California; so it doesn't really get particularly cold. My parents visited and turned the heaters on very sparingly. Nonetheless, our electric bill that month had jumped to $600. Ouch. That's a lot more than what we usually pay. Our total utilities were always less than $200.


    Turns out, California has tiered electric rates, and the baseboard heaters were not only a really inefficient heat source, they also quickly pushed us into the highest tier.


    I immediately scheduled somebody to come out and install an extra furnace for that unit instead. It cost a couple of thousand and the cost was amortized in less than one year.

    AMS thanked M
  • 7 years ago

    We're in MN also and my hubs said toe kick heater. Otherwise just have a run added from your furnace in your basement.

    AMS thanked Tammy Sartwell
  • 7 years ago

    Thanks everyone! I'm glad to hear the toekick heaters worked for you daisychain and rudebekia, and it turns out Snelling Heating isn't that far from me, thanks for the recommendation!


    I have no idea if we have tiered pricing, but I will definitely ask the utility company when they visit, and also ask about any rebates if I make energy efficient changes.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    We have a bedroom with three outside walls and it was always cold, even after adding extra attic insulation. Our insulation guy recommeded this Lasko heater. It has an electronic thermostat (uses less energy). The bedroom is now comfortable in the winter. It was $60 at Costco.

    https://www.lasko.com/products/motion-heat-plus-whole-room-ceramic-heater-cc23160/

    AMS thanked User
  • 7 years ago

    If you had a boiler I would say look into Runtal radiators. They have some with vertical piping runs that takeup little space and pump out major BTUs. I used 3 to heat our kitchen and mudroom and dining room recently, love them.


    Mini splits are also good, more energy efficient than resistive electric heat.

    AMS thanked Pam A
  • 7 years ago

    Don’t underestimate the benefit improved air sealing and insulation can give you. Replacing old insulation with spray foam in the attic made a noticeable difference in my old house kitchen. That and running ductwork are upfront costs, but I wonder if you would notice any difference in your heating bill adding a small kitchen. Electric radiant is definitely nice underfoot for a tile floor, but not the cheapest to operate and sounds a little risky as a primary heat source. I’ve had it twice and one system failed.

    AMS thanked sandk
  • 7 years ago

    I'm in a more mild zone, coastal Washington, but we do get occasional snow and overnight freezing common in winter. Close to the ocean, lots of gray and rain many weeks too.

    I wonder how much it would cost to add a run to your ductwork. I had a small kitchen in my former house, heat pump there. The kitchen had a toe kick vent at the sink for warm or cooling air - just the one vent for the room. It was adequate, no complaints.

    AMS thanked morz8 - Washington Coast
  • 7 years ago

    Thanks everyone! I will get an estimate for getting ductwork in the kitchen. @User, do you mind sharing an image of your registers in the Ikea toekicks? I thought IKEA toekicks were basically plastic and wasn't sure how they would take a register...