Black seems too dark for your home. While there might be black in the brick it is not obvious from afar. Something like a charcoal grey would be a better option if you want black, it's a little softer. Brown would complement your warmer toned bricks, so if it really is between the brown and the black, I vote brown.

ALSO, a few other tips- the shutters are too small, consider getting properly sized ones. The dark garage door is also very prominent. Most people don't want their garage to be the star of their home's exterior. Something lighter and softer that matches the trim/siding/ or blends in with the brick would be better.

https://www.iko.com/na/residential-roofing-shingles/architectural/cambridge/?gclid=Cj0KCQjw8svsBRDqARIsAHKVyqF8iIPR1osGuCkx26znDNQqHCcULZct7wNpCTCpfoeqF1Y0jD5YkuoaAgAWEALw_wcB

Weatherwood would look good too. Looks like a dark gray/brown

Looks like reclaimed brick. Yes black for sure.

Don't know why I'm having so much trouble adding photos...My apologies!

I'm afraid a black roof will make it look like a Halloween house.

It doesn't have to be black or brown...looking for some direction, here's my options

Groveraxle, is that pic with a black roof?

I would stick with a dark expresso brown, so your paint colors for the siding and trim will always work with both the brick and the roof.

Vdion, it's either black or dark gray. I removed all color from your current roof.