Software
Houzz Logo Print
eld6161

First Airbnb, very disappointing.

7 years ago

I'm new to Airbnb. My DD's use it quite often when they travel. I decided to book a cottage for Thanksgiving.

I corresponded with the owner and received a price of $541.92 for two nights. I didn't confirm at the time as my plans seemed to be changing and I told the owner that I will let her/him know.

I received a text a few weeks later asking if I made a decision.

Yesterday I tried to book the space. It came back with a much higher price at $711.00

I happened to have a screenshot of the first price and sent it in a message along with the newer price.

I said, "Is this how this works? Rates change?

No response. I then received a message from Airbnb noting that I was declined at this cottage but to review other suggestions.

My DD says I could report them. I don't want to go this route, but I really want to understand exactly what happened. This cottage received good reviews for the most part. My feeling is that they were trying to pull a fast one.

Sorry but I know many use Airbnb but this really turned me off. I also did not like not being able to talk directly to a person. This person went by J although in the reviews the name Jordan was mentioned.

I wound up booking a hotel instead, for much cheaper.

Comments (41)

  • 7 years ago

    That’s a shame. I have had only good experiences with Airbnb and vrbo. However, I have noticed that prices fluctuated. Sometimes when I am looking for an Airbnb and save them in my Favorites, I will come back and notice the price has changed. I’ve also noticed that vrbo has more extra charges than airbnb.


    Did the reviews for the place you wanted mention prices being jacked up? These places live and die by reviews. I always leave an honest review, but so far they have all been good. One place said there was a sofa bed which turned out to be unusable but the rest of the place was pretty special so I did leave a good review but mentioned the sofa bed.


    Dont forget that the owners also leave a review for you! I hope this one disappointing experience won’t turn you off to them in the future.

    eld6161 thanked dedtired
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    We were away this past weekend and part of it was at an Air Bnb which we loved. In fact I thought the design was so clever I"d consider stealing it if I ever built a house again. It is a small house connected to a smaller guest house by an open porch. Perfect for empty nesters.

    Hmm, well ...but rates change for everything in travel, don't they? Hotels, flights, rental cars? I always feel a bit frantic when I am planning because all of the elements re-price.

    As far as the person/entity renting to you, I'm kind of indifferent, but in most cases i have the person's name and a bit about them; more than I know about the desk clerk anyway.

    I do 100% agree that, for short stays, the fees and the separate cleaning charge can make AirBnB a "more expensive" option, but it is also usually a different product. That is, if you compared it to a hotel room of the same size with the same features (very rare in most markets anyway) then AIr Bnb is often much cheaper, even for short stays. OTOH, if it is overnight, you probably wouldn't even use a kitchen and laundry or a ton of room or a deck ete etc, so short stays may be better at hotels.

    For our stay this past weekend, it was only one night and also a little out of our way, but I liked the place so much that I chose it anyway. The hostess left us delicious cheese and crackers, and, in the morning, some of the best pastries I've had.

    eld6161 thanked mtnrdredux_gw
  • 7 years ago

    We recently had an interesting experience but through Booking.com. Booked a place (had the impression it was an airbnd/vrbo type situation) that had great reviews and turned out to be a dump. Questioning the rave reviews and whether they could be fake. Anyone else had that happen? We did submit our review along with photos to document some of our complaints and submitted a complaint to Booking.

    eld6161 thanked llitm
  • 7 years ago

    Darling place, Mtn!

  • 7 years ago

    I think the price could change and I might expect it to change as it gets closer to Thanksgiving, kind of like airline tickets. You said it was a few weeks later before you decided to confirm, so I don't think that is worth 'reporting', IMO.

    In saying that, before we found a beach house, same one we rent through vrbo every year, I had inquired about a few airbnb's and they never seemed to have worked out. I couldn't get a timely response back on questions, etc.

    eld6161 thanked OllieJane
  • 7 years ago

    I think I've written about this before, but we did have a "bad" experience with AirBnB. We booked a brownstone in Brooklyn. It was a shabby chic style, but when we got there it felt more shabby than chic to us. We took some photos and left. I contacted AirBNb and got a 100% refund, over $1000. I was impressed because it could have been a gray area as to whether it was misrepresented.

    eld6161 thanked mtnrdredux_gw
  • 7 years ago

    I haven't done ABB myself, but I do travel a lot. Prices in travel are fluid and you can't "save" without making a reservation. I don't think this should be any different in this case. Thinking from the homeowner's perspective, after receiving an email asking for a lower price, I would probably have passed as well to get my current price and also a guest who might be less likely to complain. Remember that all they know about you is based on the limited communication.

    eld6161 thanked 1929Spanish-GW
  • 7 years ago

    Also watch out for scammers. One VRBO ski condo I was considering had their VRBO account hacked. Luckily I had spoken/emailed with the owner a year or two before. The current communication through VRBO seemed a bit odd, so I went looking for my old notes and found the owner's info and contacted them directly. They were very happy to get my call.

    Had I booked that condo I would have sent the money to a hacker/scammer.

    eld6161 thanked chispa
  • 7 years ago

    We used to offer a property on AirBnB and our property manager used something that dynamically managed prices depending on demand and interest, based on nearby hotel and AirBnB/short rental occupancy, for example, or tracking cookies on the shoppers. I think AirBnB now has a feature that does something similar for hosts. The software would produce wild swings in pricing. Hotels use something similar to set their own pricing.

  • 7 years ago

    1929, I would be okay if they would have explained how the rates would keep going up if I didn't decide. The owner knew I was new to Airbnb as I had trouble registering initially.

    Mtn, I agree. I think Airbnb would be great when you need/want more space. In my case, I wanted the kitchen feature so I could bake.

    Whatsayyou, I agree about reviews. I look for honest reviews. The hotel I wound up choosing is basic. I liked that one of the reviews explained it as such. You have to look closely at the bad reviews as sometimes what thye are actually complaining about would not affect you, per se.

    I was talking to my sister and she had a few stories of complaints she read. One place was a three-story walk-up. The description clearly said that there was no elevator. Yet one person complained that there was no elevator.


  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Was the rate quoted the rental rate only, and the additional fees were included when you viewed it later? I'm usually somewhat taken aback by how much $$ the fees add, but they are what they are. I agree that rates seem to change at the drop of a hat, and I always lock in a property as soon as I'm satisfied that it's where I want to stay -- just in case pricing changes. I've had great luck with Airbnb and VRBO/Homeaway, but I look for properties with many excellent reviews ... with one exception. We're renting a house in Colorado next summer through Airbnb that was brand new to the market (it has since gathered a few glowing reviews from guests who stayed after I booked it for next year -- yes, I'm a long-range planner and book far in advance), but I was able to learn who the owner is and Googled him to learn that he is indeed a resident of the area where we're staying and active in community events. So I felt ok about proceeding to book a property with zero reviews (at the time).

    I don't like hotels, for the most part. Even the Four Seasons in NYC left me a bit cold. Well, literally, since there were two mornings during my stay when there was no hot water on my floor, making for VERY quick and miserable showers. Of course, similar situations can happen anywhere one might choose to stay, but I just prefer the convenience and comfort of being in an actual HOME when I'm away from home.

    That said, I'm glad you found a suitable place to stay, eld6161. I'm sorry that your first experience with Airbnb was not positive, but I would encourage you to try again at some point. There are scads of fabulous properties out there. (Our place in Iceland was one of them, and here's the adorable little cottage where my mother and I are staying next spring in England, in case anybody wants to take a peek. :-))

    https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/plus/26080321?source_impression_id=p3_1571248292_aZ95F1XjtLvwBhv5#modal

    eld6161 thanked User
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    OMG, Ida, I love that kitchen!

    I will add one more tip. Don't forget to put in your dates of travel when you are looking. If you look at properties with that blank, I am not sure if what it defaults to but I think it defaults to the low.


    eld6161 thanked mtnrdredux_gw
  • 7 years ago

    Me too, mtn! I can't wait for Mum and I to get in there and prepare our meals. We love to visit the village greengrocer for fresh veggies (Mum's vegetarian), and of course meal prep is always enlivened by a good bottle of wine shared between two ladies, right? ;-)

    Did you notice the different flooring in the kitchen? That amuses me. Of course, this is one of the newer homes in this little old medieval town, having been built in the 19th century in an area where many homes still stand from the 14th or 15th!



    Sorry for the slight highjack.


    By the way, mtn, LOVE that sweet little house you posted! Totally adorable!

  • 7 years ago

    We've done VBROs and AirBnB's for years and years. Two questions come immediately to mind: First, when you screenshot the price, was that for specific dates? The prices can vary dramatically depending on the date and there is usually a premium for holiday weeks. Secondly, as other posters mentioned, the nightly rate is just the beginning. There has definitely been some upward creep in extra fees over the last few years. In addition to cleaning and taxes, there is sometimes a transaction fee. In the first screen which shows you the nightly price, these fees won't show up, but they WILL show up before you book. You have to click on "Book Now" in order to bring up these additional fees, and then you WILL be shown the grand total before you ever give them a credit card or finalize your booking. Hope this helps....

    eld6161 thanked Bestyears
  • 7 years ago

    Anyway my long winded point is that my daughter told me I need to remember AirBnB is a different model of accommodation. It’s not a hotel, it is literally someone’s house (room/cottage/guest quarter) they they are marketing and leasing out via an online 3rd party ie AirBnB. So there simply will never be any assurance that an owner is going to adhere to standards of a hotel or other business entity. Should they.? Sure. Do they? Ehhhh not always.

    Yes and no.

    Personally, i tend not to like to stay in Air BnB's that someone else lives in, even part time. They are usually too cluttered. No one likes to use a kitchen with other people's 20-year old half used paprika in it IYKWIM. Many Air BnB units are not people's primary homes, though they may be owned by individuals, and a rising cohort of them are owned by corporations. For example, take a look at this company: https://www.sonder.com/about Some units are owned by individuals but managed by property managers.

    Yes, there is definitely some additional risk. But IME, as a luxury traveller, the risk has been totally worth it. I have stayed at 5 star hotels in Paris plenty of times, but my family and I far preferred staying in an old factory loft on a canal. If you like room service and being interrupted for turn down and need a concierge, then no. But if you want to stay somewhere interesting and be able to make dinner from a farmer's market bounty and then sit around a dining table playing cards, well that is what Air BnB can deliver.

    It requires extra vigilance. One, you need to read every review and read it carefully. People don't slam air bnb owners they way they would a 4S when something is off. If anyone mentions anything ever about cleanliness, run don't walk. Secondly, I don't book one in a place or at a time when back-up will be a problem. I wouldn't book a ski place for the first time over Pres Day w/e. If I don't like it I'm out of luck. The one time I had a problem, I was in a hotel to my liking inside of an hour, and was shortly refunded my entire stay.

  • 7 years ago

    We have stayed at AirBnb's and vrbo's for years, and have had only 1 bad experience with an AirBnb. I took the proper channels to report the incident and was fully refunded by AirBnB. Otherwise, our accommodations have been great. I agree that staying at those that are intended to be rented (vs. someone's private home) tend to be more accommodating and comfortable, to me, at least. We once stayed in a city apt. where one of guest rooms had a collection of rather salacious reading material on the bookshelves next to the bed. (sigh) Had to do a quick clearing of that before my kids settled in. The closet door was locked... can't imagine what was lurking in there. Overall, though, I prefer AirBnb's to hotels for most of my travels.

  • 7 years ago

    I am not kidding... this just popped up on my recommended reading list in Firefox.

    https://www.curbed.com/2016/12/13/13933554/airbnb-vacation-rental-alternatives?utm_source=pocket-newtab

    And I browse in private mode. Ugh.

  • 7 years ago

    Mtn, good points. In my debacle, we had a series of unfortunate events as it were. There was almost no choice in where to stay, we arrived late at night, even hotels were few and far between and the occasion itself was somewhat fraught (child’s wedding) so it was just not a good situation in which to do any kind of negotiating. And a huge yes to never staying in anyone’s home in which they actually live again, be it a vacation/weekend house (as this was) or a residence.

    That said, I’m still not sure AirBnB is for me. While I don’t particularly care about room service or resort activities, cleanliness, predictability and a responsible contact point at all times are personal priorities for me. I’m really not sure even a nice AirBnB can provide those factories to my standards with enough of a guarantee that I’d want to chance it. As they say, different strokes for different crazy clean nuts ;).

    eld6161 thanked runninginplace
  • 7 years ago

    Yeah, I totally get it. Your concerns are where the idea of franchises came from. Providing confidence that a certain set of standards will be met. That is valuable!

  • 7 years ago

    I think that's pretty common. I used to have a house on Airbnb and similar to what gooster said, the guy who ran it for me would adjust the pricing for certain weekends/holidays, taking into consideration how much time was left. I think it was nice that they reached out to see if you were still interested. Did you get back to their text? I'm guessing that when/if they didn't hear back from you, they adjusted the price since availability was getting lower closer to the holiday.

    eld6161 thanked User
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Gail, here's the thing. When I showed J he two different price screenshots, they could have gotten back to me with an explanation, like some of the above posters gave for reasons why.

    The fact that I was then "ghosted" and replied back by Airbnb with a decline is what turned me off.

    Both show the same Thanksgiving dates that I asked for. If one price is shown before actually booking then it would be understood that this will not be the actual price as other fees will be added. Still, I am not understanding why this happened in my situation.

    If J was not trying to price gauge, he/she would have messaged back and given the "logical" explanation. Again, KNOWING I was new to Airbnb.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Could it be that J is also new or inexperienced with the system? These are home owners for the most part, not rental professionals. I don't think one should attribute to ill intent what could very well simply be ineptitude.

    eld6161 thanked User
  • 7 years ago

    I was under the impression that some host to client contact (price negotiation?) was supposed to go through AirBnB? Was the host just following the rules of the site on his side?

    eld6161 thanked maddielee
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    You are able to send messages back and forth through the Airbnb site. I also seemed to receive text messages.

    Ida, no this is not a new place. I looked at its many reviews before deciding.

  • 7 years ago

    While many hosts are excellent, some are really not meeting standards. AirBnB is now offering a plus program that offers a higher level of standard. Superhosts also usually hustle to earn their status. Besides corporate or small business owned properties, many hosts use a professional manager who handled checkin/checkout, cleaning, etc. Ours was pretty good and the cleaners were generally good. And yes, where possible we offered a welcome basket of goodies plus hotel-style toiletries.

    On another property, we currently do short term rentals via a professional management company. They offer services above and beyond: standard quality linens, a welcome basket with wine and starter supplies, high-end toiletries, professional cleaning, staff handymen and a concierge desk in the area with luggage storage. They had us stock the place with a standard list of amenities, and we have an owner closet for our stuff.

    eld6161 thanked Gooster
  • 7 years ago

    Well, there's really no way for us to know why "J" didn't respond to you further. Maybe he rented the property before he heard back from you and he (for whatever reason) just opted not to engage further with you. Not the most polite way to end an exchange, but people can have strange ways of doing things. Airbnb and similar sites have overwhelmingly positive transactions, so I'd encourage you not to throw the baby out with the bath water on the basis of a less than stellar exchange of communication with an owner.

    eld6161 thanked User
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I would not be surprised by the change in fee closer to a holiday. I think that is normal with travel during high demand times. I don't try to explain communication skills -- some folks don't have them, or they may have seen a bad review coming and you may have dodged a disappointment,

    My only Airbnb stay was arranged by my son's GF so she could help pick a convenient place for a family event. It was ok -- though it was not clear what was expected in the kitchen -- there were several year old items partially used in the cupboard but nothing in the fridge. I thought the bathroom especially should have been in better condition if letting it out, but it was more to the level of odd than uninhabitable.

    The main reason I would never recommend it was that we had an early morning flight back home and then after arrival learned that the host wanted us to strip the beds (ok), wash and dry the linens for one bedroom, make the bed, and I think wash the other set and towels or there would be a $350 fee. The washer was a small stacked unit, so it would take multiple loads. Rather than us be up all night, the GF's father came to the house and did laundry after we left and I felt bad about that.

    DS and GF have both used Airbnb a fair amount -- here and in Europe. My son plays trombone and it gives him a better ability to practice when needed and I think they have come to like the non-hotel options. You really need to watch for those fees though -- and if that hadn't been disclosed, I hope GF or her family reported it.

  • 7 years ago

    I have only used VRBO and only had one kind of strange but turned out okay experience. I am pretty fussy about what kind of place I'll stay in so examine the listings and reviews pretty closely and am willing to pay more for what I want. I feel like you can usually tell who is cutting corners and who's not but again, I've never booked through Airbnb.

    I notice some places are listed on both and Airbnb has more rent a room in my house offerings which I'd never want. I have shopped Airbnb but didn't happen to find anything quite right for me. Though I wouldn't like it, I tend to think anything you're looking at online is subject to a price change prior to booking - pretty easy for the supplier to have dynamic pricing based on supply and demand.

    eld6161 thanked 3katz4me
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Lascatx, I understand that prices rise closer to holidays. But, 'J" could have explained that since I didn't lock in the price when I first started messaging this was common procedure. Or when I showed the comaparison he/she could have given me the explanation. We were communicating back and forth. And he/she did reach out to me when I didn't book right away.

    A $350 fee seems exorbitant. Clean your own linens? That is ridiculous.

    Both my DD's have had good luck with Airbnb. One rented in France. They called it a castle but it looked more like a manor house. Lovely.


  • 7 years ago

    I understand why AirB&B hosts want you to clean the house before you leave, but that's a negative for me.

    eld6161 thanked graywings123
  • 7 years ago

    I have stayed in Airbnb properties that did not charge a cleaning fee but asked that beds be stripped of sheets and a load started in the washer before departure. I didn't mind and would rather do a few things like that than pay a fee. You do have to know what you're getting into though, as this is very different form a hotel and the requirements do vary.

    eld6161 thanked User
  • 7 years ago

    No way would I clean, do a bunch of laundry or pay an exorbitant fee. I've paid cleaning fees, usually around $75, and I've run the dishwasher and thrown one load in the wash before departure, if requested, but that's it. I do however leave the place as I would leave my own home - tidied up - no trash or dirty dishes lying around. I guess if there are no competitors who have more attractive offers and one can get away with this then more power to them. I would not rent such a place.

  • 7 years ago

    Oh my, I would not clean - I don't at home so sure as heck not on vacation. Cleaning fees can vary a lot so you need to look at them (they are ALWAYS disclosed). Personally I have never seen the option to "clean or pay." I would not like that ... I don't trust how the prior guest cleaned as much as a "professional" cleaning staff.


    Usually, the cleaning fee is the reason AirBnB can look pricey, again, esp for a short stay in off season when the room rate may be low but the labor is unchanged.

    eld6161 thanked mtnrdredux_gw
  • 7 years ago

    The self-clean option probably is true to the roots of AirBnB, as a way to home share and keep costs low. But it is also one of the reasons I recommend renting properties that are professionally managed/operated, if you are wanting a higher level of service and amenities. If the owner is paying for another person to clean and setup, you know the cleaning will be decent (and it is not, then the owner likely will quickly take action).

    eld6161 thanked Gooster
  • 7 years ago

    The title made me think you had a bad experience staying in an Airbnb. While I understand your frustration with the communication you experienced, I would encourage you to keep an open mind for future travels. We used Airbnb’s in four countries in Europe a couple of years ago and last year along the CA coast and were extremely satisfied. I would recommend using the app and searching for super hosts. Just like with a hotel, the pricing is finalized at the actual time of booking. and is fluid up to that point.

    eld6161 thanked Bonnie
  • 7 years ago

    Eld6161, I agree -- the communication should have been better, but a lot of people are just bad about being able to talk to people.

    We left the house very clean, everything washed and clean in the kitchen, all the trash taken out, and had no problem stripping the beds or starting laundry, but I think the expectation of completing two loads and having the bed made is a bit much. Kind of negates a morning departure or doing much of anything else on your last day. I didn't make the reservation, so I don't know how clearly that was communicated in advance. We only learned of it after our arrival -- as we had to leave before 6 am to catch a flight home. At least there was someone who was able and willing to take care of it.

    eld6161 thanked lascatx
  • 7 years ago

    Lascatx, i guess you get better at all the details and become more familiar in what to look for if you do this often.

    I'm not ruling Airbnb out, but it has made me cautious. As I mentioned, both my DD's have used it many times and only once had an issue with an area being sketchy. But, that I think is up to us to look at the demographics of an area.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    We always do at least some "cleaning", even on rare occasions when we are in a hotel. I can't help but think of the person who has to scrub the toilet or wipe stray hairs from the shower floor, and especially make an effort to leave those areas as we found them (not that we're "gross", but want to leave certain areas pristine). I would object to remaking beds and doing complete laundry loads (I don't mind starting the machine). But for the most part, there will not be a ton of things to be cleaned after we depart. Our experiences with such privately owned rentals have, with only one exception, been dealings directly with the owners and we have enough communication or meet in person so that there's something of a warm acquaintance established. I've even become friends with a couple of these folks. (I knitted a scarf for the thoughtful housekeeper during our recent stay in a NM cabin.) It's definitely been much different than merely renting a place to stay, at least in our experience. Sure, we've paid for the privilege, but it has almost always felt like we are guests and not merely short-term renters. We like that very much.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    So I am an owner of a space that has an Airbnb listing. It’s kind of odd how it works in that the owner sets their nightly rate in the system. Then the Airbnb software constantly adjusts the rate in order to garner clicks. It is really annoying because people who are new to the format don’t always get a clear idea of the pricing. For example I set my rate at $109 per night. But if someone is doing a general search of my area it will pop up showing as low as $69 per night. An amount I would never accept. Then as a host you get constant messages from Airbnb telling you to lower your rate in order to get more bookings. So then I’ll get a request for a stay at the low rate which I have to decline, which is a black mark on a host per Airbnb. So sometimes hosts just don’t respond to a booking request like this as it is marked against you if you decline whereas no response doesn’t show up in your history. I’m about to take on a long term booking in my space so I will be interested to see what Airbnb does with their program in my absence. The other thing that drives hosts nuts is that the rating system punishes you for any rating below 5 stars. So you can go get knocked out of the searches if you get 5 stars on all things except one (usually location, which is ridiculous as you can’t change where you are and can’t make people fully read the description). Which then gets Airbnb sending notices to lower your price in order to get more bookings.

    Oh, and yes, it is a seasonal pricing platform. Just like airline tickets, if you book farther in advance you get a better price. Then as you get closer to a holiday and spaces start booking up, the price goes up. Then at the last minute you can get a lower price (fire sale!) if the place doesn’t get reserved. But for me personally, I don’t take the fire sale bookings as I am listing my place for fun, I don’t make my living doing this.

    As to the cleaning fee, it’s a common dilemma for hosts. Many hosts pay a cleaner as they are not on site, so they add it to their listing. I just upped my nightly a few bucks so I can cover the costs if I need to have someone do it for me. The original model for Airbnb was a home share situation so guests were expected to be courteous and and not expect their hosts to clean up after them. So that usually meant wash their own dishes, strip the beds and start a load of towels for example. I personally don’t like people doing my laundry as I’m very particular about it, so my check out rules just ask guests to put used towels in the basket and load and start the dishwasher. I prefer to strip the bed myself as that’s the easiest way to look for and treat stains. If you saw some of the pics hosts have posted of the way people sometimes leave the space you’d be shocked.

    Can you post a link to the listing? I can take a look and see how it’s set up. For example people who accept Instant Bookings have a different way of listing rates. I belong to a forum for hosts and we spend a lot of time looking at fellow hosts listings in order to give insight on glitches, or pricing and such.

  • 7 years ago

    That's very interesting, Annette, and provides a lot more insight into the inner workings. Thank you for sharing this.