Software
Houzz Logo Print
lone_elm_z6

How messy are River Birch?

7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago

I have a spot too wet for a lot of trees and decided on maybe a River Birch yet read complaints of mess. Is it a lot of work like Weeping Willow? My Willow came down in a storm this summer and I was sad, and also a little relieved.

Comments (22)

  • 7 years ago

    Yes, less brittle than a WW, but fully as messy always losing small branches. If above deck (mine) always needing swept from branchlets and leaves.

    I loved it..but not good for a high maintainance area, best in a wilderness or unmaintained area.

    lone_elm_z6 thanked dbarron
  • 7 years ago

    The low spot narrows my options. I may plant it anyway. The Willow had such a nice profile in the yard I put up with the constant clean up.


  • 7 years ago

    The surface roots will make mowing under it challenging. We had a big river birch that came down in a storm and I don't miss it.

    lone_elm_z6 thanked cecily 7A
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Any suggestions for wettish clay? No standing water -- saturation for much of spring and winter, with drainage into the hollow. I have a Blackgum I like, is there a faster growing cultivar? Many of the trees for wet conditions I am ho hum about and went back to the idea of the Birch. I planted two Metasequioa this month on the property. They don' t mind water but two is enough.

  • 7 years ago

    That's true Cecily, I had forgotten, but it wasn't too bad (I've had worse).

    Hee, I was about to suggest bald cypress, but if it's too wet, you'd have knees, and they look almost identical to metasequioa, though easier I think to grow (least for me).

    If you're happy enough with a small tree, I can strongly suggest magnolia virginiana. I planted one here in an extremely saturated yard (mine).

    lone_elm_z6 thanked dbarron
  • 7 years ago

    wettish clay? No standing water -- saturation for much of spring and winter, with drainage into the hollow.


    ==>>> how you plant might be as important as what you plant ...


    you need to give the transplant a couple years.. to put its roots where it can cope ... allowing the tree to acclimate to it all ...


    many might suggest planting on a berm .... of some sort ... to accomplish such ...


    ken

    lone_elm_z6 thanked ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
  • 7 years ago

    Ken, yes I figured I'd have to plant it a little high no matter what.

  • 7 years ago

    Except they say when you are high it can be difficult to work productively.

  • 7 years ago

    yeah.. probably lose focus.. and just end up taking a nap with your head in the partially dug hole .... lol ... ken

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Thanks for the cautionary advice.

  • 7 years ago

    Buckeyes are good trees for those conditions, particularly if it rarely dries out completely.

    lone_elm_z6 thanked mad_gallica (z5 Eastern NY)
  • 7 years ago

    Magnolia virginiana would fit the conditions you described for a smaller tree. Tilia americana would probably work too.

    lone_elm_z6 thanked Skip1909
  • 7 years ago

    Skip, are the Tilia Americana cultivars also OK?

  • 7 years ago

    I have no first hand experience with the cultivars but would try it. The descriptions say clay tolerant so with proper planting it should do okay. I was going to suggest sycamore too (and silver maple), but you were hesitant about messy trees.

    lone_elm_z6 thanked Skip1909
  • 7 years ago

    If you might consider maples, then a sugar maple could work...as would a red maple for sure. Silver maples are the worlds worst weeds, please never plant one intentionally.

    At least here, sugar maples often occur in the woods near seeps.

    lone_elm_z6 thanked dbarron
  • 7 years ago

    Dbarron, I am stuck with a few Boxelders, which I think are worse than Silver Maples in the bad tree sweepstakes.

  • 7 years ago

    In my swamp, red maples start, then die off after a few years. Pin oaks do better.

  • 7 years ago

    Interesting mad_gallica, as I've never intentionally planted but one sugar maple, I will defer to you. No red or silver ever ;) There are a couple of swamp oaks, one that I grew was quercus nigra (water oak)...don't know why I didn't think of those.

  • 7 years ago

    Metasequoia grove at Morris Arboretum - where two wasn’t enough ;-)



    I have the space so I will be planting several next spring.

    lone_elm_z6 thanked indianagardengirl
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Indianagardengal, I so wish I had the space to plant a grove of anything. That pic is a dream. I planted one Gold Rush Dawn Redwood at the corner of the lot (beyond is farm field). I would love to make a trio grouping. When I pace out the space it just does not work out. Maybe a pair.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    My wet, poor draining area has a Magnolia virginiana, one of my favorite trees. There are smaller things like Button Bush and the Asian version, Adina rubella. Three species of Alder (a North American native, the invasive A. glutinosa I dug from a neighbor, and Alnus cordata). Carpinus caroliniana and a Hackberry grow on the area a few inches higher.

    There are several Oaks (Q. nigra, falcata, bicolor, and acutissima). I know, nigra and acutissima are weeds, but given the choice of no tree and a weed tree, you make a choice. There are 2 hickories and 2 species of Nyssa. Red Maple grows naturally there too. I will add Chamacyparis thyoides next spring, and will try (again) Larix laricina, the native Tamarack. Finally, if you want to cuss and swear, poison the soil and make trouble for the ones who come after you, plant a Black Walnut.

    lone_elm_z6 thanked HU-435404624