Software
Houzz Logo Print
treetoronto3

Tree wound honeylocust

7 years ago

Hi there. Long story short my neighbour trespassed onto my property and hacked the main leader of my honeylocust. It was close to his property and told us he doesn't want a "forest" in his backyard. We love and cherish the tree and he hates it. He is an awful person who has hated us since we put up a fence over 20 years ago (he was under the impression that his backyard was 8 feet wider that it actually was, we were under the impression that only 4 of the 8 feet was ours, when he disagreed we got in a surveyor and it turned out that ALL 8 feet was ours! Anyways, regarding the tree vandalism, he is getting a fine from the city for tree vandalism (this is a thing in Canada).


We were distraught by the damage. We are having it seen to by a certified arborist (who has cared for our trees in the past). The wound is large, do you think it will heal or is the tree a forfeit?


p.s. I retaliated by planting two columnar oaks under the honeylocust to block him out some more. Here are pics of the damage and the wonderful man (the neighbor's brother in law) who cut it and then slammed the branch with a shovel to break it off. Special souls!






Comments (16)

  • 7 years ago

    Sad story. But the tree will survive. Plants are tough.

  • 7 years ago

    Tree will be OK, but like mentioned, it'd be best for those hack-offs to be made cleaner cuts.

  • 7 years ago

    pruning never really kills anything .... done properly.. and you can easily have this cleaned up properly ...


    is that him in the first pic? ... wonder what he was going to do with the shovel ...???


    good job on already setting up the arborist visit ... we can commiserate with you ... but having an onsite inspection always trumps us ....


    ken

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Tree has been ruined, possibility that it will recover previous size does not mean that it won't continue to be visually unattractive later due to the recent cutting - or that poorly attached replacement trunks won't break off later. Also you have it located right next to your house - this species gets a lot bigger in time than yours is now.

    Finally if no measures were in place to convince the neighbor that he was not entitled to come over the fence and wreck your tree this time then what's to stop him from cutting it again after it has grown back for awhile?

    Same with the oaks, probably all you have done at this point is give him additional future targets. And these are probably too large growing to be so close to your house.

    Since you have photos of the trespassing and damage in progress you probably should see if you can get an attorney to go after him. (I've had multiple episodes of similarly entitled neighbors reaching, sometimes even coming onto my place and cutting, spraying etc. - my attorney said to set up cameras and get video, otherwise he couldn't help me).


  • 7 years ago

    It is his house. The back of my backyard is the side of his house (that is his house). The entire branch in actual fact did not hang over, only about 20% of of it did abut 40 feet up. If he had asked us to take care of it we would have! He used the shovel to break the brach off. The branch snapped and fell onto his room (sadly missing his chimney), and the branch became lodged. It did damage his gutters!


    He is being charged 10K by the city. If only he had a professional take care of it (or just ask us), he would have saved money! But instead he's going to pay more than it would have cost him to have the tree prune professionally.


    We are probably going to sue him for the cost of the tree, the removal of it, and the replacement of very large trees (and personal damages).


    The law is that you can prune overhanging branches, but what he did was remove the entire branch because him and his brother in law couldn't reach the top of the tree.


    After he is fined and sued I am sure he will not be cutting those oaks!



  • 7 years ago

    Good, he has to pay a hefty fine and possible fines from a law suit.

    Sounds like he lacking some brain cells.

  • 7 years ago

    I'm talking about the house with the corner right next to the tree, on the lot to which the ladder was pushed and not on the lot from which the ladder came. I definitely think removal of the tree is a good idea.

  • 7 years ago

    Ya that is his house! This pic was taken about 40 ft away from the back of my house.

  • 7 years ago

    What is that thing on the left side of the pic? Is that an umbrella or something? I suspect that’s what is confusing us.

  • 7 years ago

    ha ha ha ya its just an umbrella!!! Our house is far from that tree!

  • 7 years ago

    Him putting his ladder on your tree is trespassing, no?

  • 7 years ago

    It is 100% trespassing!

  • 7 years ago

    10k fine?? ouch! Does that go to the town or to you?

  • 7 years ago

    It goes to the city of Toronto. I don't mind who it goes to, I am just happy they are being fined. We have not decided if we will sue them or not. They trespassed, damaged our property, damaged multiple trees (they cut everything at least 1-3 feet on our side. We had our arborist come in and take a look at the tree. His first impression was that he saw the tree as a write off, but also said we could probably train the canopy to recover a bit over about 8 years. His worry is that the wound won't be able to heal and it will invite rot. If we decided to remove it, we will sue the neighbor for the removal and replacement. Its a lose-lose for the neighbor, he is being fined, and the tree will stay, or he is being fined and sued, and the tree is going. But I think by removing the tree he wins!