Software
Houzz Logo Print
almajess

Stone decision for a kitchen with a black countertop and a white one..

6 years ago

Hi all, first time here and first time remodeling. Just bought a home with a somewhat dated kitchen. I am staying with my walnut color cabinets as are in good condition but to modernize the kitchen am planning on enlarging the island with a charcoal-black waterfall countertop and use that material as well to box the kitchen hood and cover it with that same stone. For the rest of the kitchen countertop and backsplash have been searching for a soft vein white quartz.


For the charcoal one at first chose the Charcoal Soapstone Suede from Silestone but read that with certain light looks blueish.... then was introduced to the brand Dekton that is more like a porcelain and they have a black one with white subtle vein called Laos which I like looks modern. And finally yesterday at MSI they offered me a Granite called Nero Mist that is elegant satin black with light tones of golds in the veins which actually I kinda' like a lot despite the fact I was totally not into granite thinking it was 90's and dated and thought granite was only spotted not with veins instead like I want so this one surprised me. Also I know that granite is a real stone and more sturdy and low maintenance rather than quartz thats manmade...


For the whites I am between Eternal Calaccata Gold in polished from Silestone (since even though prefer suede for the matte look; their polish is not to shiny and obviously better idea for the kitchen easier to keep clean etc... The other option is Calacatta Arno from MSI but is not as white overall as the Calaccatta Gold... I will post pictures in comments....





Comments (29)

  • 6 years ago


    THIS IS MY ACTUAL KITCHEN... LEAVING CABINETS SAME COLOR (EXCEPT FOR ISLAND THAT IS BEING ENLARGED AND IN A WATERFALL AND WITH HAZEL COLOR CABINETS) ALSO THE CROWN MOULDINGS ARE BEING REPLACED TO MORE MODERN AND PLAIN LOOKING IN ALL CABINETS. WILL DO BRASS HARDWARE.. ISLAND BLACK WATERFALL AND SAME STONE TO COVER THE HOOD THAT IS BEING BOXED AND COVERED BY SAME SONE.... BACKSPLASH AND REST OF COUNTERS WHITE MARBLE LOOKIN STONE....

  • 6 years ago


    ANOTHER VIEW

  • 6 years ago


    Here is an idea with a render..... no white cabinet next to the hood though... will leave all walnut except for the island cabinets....

  • 6 years ago


    So now you have an idea here next are the stones for the countertops and backsplash....

  • 6 years ago


    FIRST OPTION: Calacatta gold and Black Dekton Laos... what I like about the Calcutta is that is white overall and has subtle grayish veins with discrete touches of gold that will look amazing with walnut cabinets and hardware... the Black Dekton I love love is more a porcelain (for outdoor too so later can combine kitchen with barbecue counters) and the fact that apparently is very resistant easier to take care than quartz since has no resin...

  • 6 years ago



    OPTION TWO FOR THE DARK ONE... is this granite (sorry for the terrible pictures) (looks darker in life but does have a goldfish veining look..... What do you guys think?

  • 6 years ago


    And this is OPTION TWO for the white countertop and backsplash.... this one is not as white as the Calacatta Gold has a more beige-gray tone to it I guess....

  • 6 years ago

    Lovely kitchen. I wouldn’t mix granite with Quartz. I think you should go with all Quartz or all Granite.

    Almajess thanked ortochini
  • PRO
    6 years ago

    For the white top - I would get a sample next to your cabinets and think of what sort of backsplash you are going to do - that might break the tie for you since they look so similar. As far as Dekton goes, you better have an awesome fabricator. We had a display put in that we got a deal on because the fabricator was testing out how to work with it. It really did not come out too great. There are chips and the miter edges are only so - so... I have to say I'm not a fan. Also we managed to get a stain on it. There was a plant there and the pot had a small leak on the bottom we didn't know about until we discovered the green ring left ( so much for good cleaning people ). Did n't wipe off... had to do all sort of cleaning and soaking and finally got it to a point where you can't see it except at a certain angle... Now of course it is a white countertop so a darker top is more forgiving.

    I have seen the Nero mist ( there is one similar called jet mist too ) - they are beautiful! I personally would take that over man made any day...

    Good luck!

    Almajess thanked Debbi Washburn
  • 6 years ago

    Thank you! So excited for my first answers and very helpful.... Ortochini, I hadn't thought about combining two different type of stones would not be ok but sounds logical and totally get the idea one is natural and the other one manmade... Thanks for that!


    Debbie, first of all really appreciate your time and your advice :) As far as the Dekton one, they did specify the complexity of fabricating it. I did ask my fabricator and said he's savvy, but I am aware it has it's risks... But in case I don't find another black I like, if it weren't for that issue, what do you think about the look of it and pairing it with the white calaccata, the walnut cabinets and gold hardware?

  • 6 years ago

    Also, by any chance do you recall a White Marble that can go well with the Nero Mist?

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    I do like it!

  • 6 years ago

    I am very eager to see what you come up with. I have a very similar kitchen and am updating it with new countertops as well. I am looking at The Calcatta Arno in Quartz from MSI or possibly going with quartzite Venus (formerly Taj Mahal). I can't wait to see pictures of what you come up with

  • 6 years ago

    @Almajess What is the photo you have a few comments up? MSI Calacatta Arno, by chance?

  • 6 years ago

    @michellejaff What did you decide on countertop? And what color cabinets do you have? I'm between the exact two countertops


  • 6 years ago

    Sorry guys took me forever! I was drained didn’t know how stressful remodeling was 🙈 anyhow I decided on the Dekton for the island and couldn’t be happier! I added the almond color cabinets in a more modern look to combine with the walnut I had and try to save at least on that and sticked with the travertine floor I also didn’t want to spend on. So did what I could with what I had.... am not finished yet but almost done :-)

  • 6 years ago

    what color did you go with for the white counters?

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    It looks beautiful!! Nice and modern but so warm and inviting! Such a refreshing space from all of the white and gray - I love it!! Such a great update .

  • 6 years ago

    Hi :) Is that the Calacatta Arno or Calacatta Gold counter you ended up going with?

  • 6 years ago

    Hi please post your decision ASAP. I am in the process of deciding whether to go wi Calacatta Gold or Calacatta Arno. Please post pictures

  • 6 years ago

    hello, I am also in the process of deciding between Silestone CG and MSI CA. Which did you go with and what made you choose it? Your kitchen turned out beautiful!

  • 6 years ago

    Which white did you go with??? I am deciding between the Calacatta gold and Arno as well

  • 5 years ago

    Mary Moawad - I am dealing with same issue. Did u choose Arno or Gold? Can you share pics?

  • 5 years ago

    I too am deciding between Arno and Gold! Would love to see them side by side!

  • 5 years ago

    We were looking at Arno and Gold too. We saw the Arno slab and were disappointed. Another counter supplier told us that MSI changed the formula (not for the better) and it no longer looks like the samples. They said they were going to have to remove the Arno counter from their display. He recommended we look at MSI Valentin (warm white) or Monaco (cool), which are new designs. The Valentin sample looks great for our needs - warm white with gray and subtle brown veining -- and better than the picture on MSI website. We hope the slab looks as good in person. We also plan to look at Gold slab too.

  • 5 years ago

    KerriD - thank you for the info. Valentin was my other option and I saw a slab and loved it.

  • 5 years ago

    Mary thank you for the update. Good luck & post pics.

  • 5 years ago

    hello your kitchen looks beautiful and warming! pls advise if this is Gold or Arno?