Monogram would be the better choice. It is more well-known and produces some beautiful designs as well as supplying long-standing customer service with avenues for complaints if you aren't getting what you need. Repair parts may also be easier to find in the future if needed. Shop around to different dealers on price since many showrooms carry or can order Monogram.

Thanks! I think we've decided to go with Monogram. Went to one dealer who sold American Range who said they've stopped since they cant get in touch with their service dept. Now I just need to figure out which fridge to get :)

American Performer and Monogram are very different ranges. If you are interested in the AP, have you looked at BlueStar? The star burner is very similar, no burner cap and similar star shape. It does have an open burner tray that comes apart for cleaning.

Thanks! I looked hard at BlueStar, but the additional cost for open burner took it out of the running, I feel like BlueStar isn't worth it for the sealed burner and with the monogram I can get a rebate toward a speed oven.

Monogram makes good ranges and ovens. If you shop around, some retailers offer significantly below MSRP in addition to the usual Monogram promotion.