Software
Houzz Logo Print
lora_moore42

Whats going on with my cactus..?

6 years ago

I got a cactus earlier this December it's a Peruvian cactus. I haven't watered it since I received it about 3 weeks ago and after I got back from my trip I noticed the smallest cactus of the 4 has fractured near the base and the base is completely black. The black rot ends where it fractured. I also just put the pot in a new vase so I dont know if that jostles it around. Or is this root rot? I don't know how it could be because I literally hadn't watered since I received it 3 weeks ago. Could it be the temperature/humidity?



Comments (14)

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Once you’ve followed the advice above & repot, I would suggest a better draining mix. To me, your growing medium looks to contain a lot of peat which holds too much water for cacti & succulents promoting rot.

    I use a commercially prepared cacti & succulent mix to which I add pumice at a 1 to 1 ratio.

  • 6 years ago

    Hey! So I did cut the dead part out and put cinnamon on it. The moisture sensor I used showed moist-wet next to the cacti. The small cactus roots were very wet and mushy. The others didn’t seem affected (yet) and 2/3 of the remaining cacti seemed to be cuttings that haven’t totally rooted yet. I ended up making a new mixture of my own soil of soil, coarse sand, and perlite! I hope this will help but I dont know if it could be something else too :(

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    The potting mix should be improved: if it is still in same soil you purchased it, it could be mostly peat. Using sand is not generally recommended unless it is coarse as you mentioned. Grit and/or pumice are also great amendments if you have any. I use mix of grit and sifted perlite (approx. 50/50) and small amount of turface (maybe 10-15%). You didn't mention ratios of ingredients, but using more inorganics than soil usually works better. Even mix of soil and perlite (at least 50% of perlite) is better than very peaty soil. Do you have photo (with measuring tape for size) of coarse sand yo used?

    Repotting into better draining mix should be great help.

  • 6 years ago

    I used a ratio of 3 soil: 2 coarse sand: 1 perlite. It was a recommendation online that used what I saw was available in stores when I went. I don’t have a photo but it was similar in size to the perlite or maybe a little smaller

  • 6 years ago

    Get rid of the sand entirely. In a succulent mix it is not needed, wanted or at all desirable. Half soil and half perlite is one ratio that's used quite wisely.

  • 6 years ago

    Hm, why is it not desirable?


    I used this recipe: they made it seem like it is a good thing!

    https://getbusygardening.com/diy-succulent-potting-soil/

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    You've no doubt heard that not everything you read on the Internet is true, I trust. This is one of those times. Just to quote one line from your link:

    ' Succulents grow best in a porous sandy potting soil, so amending your potting soil with sand is super important. '

    Not only is it untrue, but the sand is counterproductive to good porosity. If that sand had been sieved down to just the large gravel, that would have a decent addition to the soil, but it wasn't.

    The link does contain some good information, but the sand in your mix (combined with, perhaps, other cultural practices) likely led to the rot.

  • 6 years ago

    Very little watering and brighter than usual lighting needed to keep desert cacti and succulents happy inside ordinary household interiors during winter.

  • 6 years ago

    Short answer of why not sand.

    'Cause if it's fine sand, it can clog the roots of the plant, impeding its ability to get oxygen & sort of breathe. Plants' roots need to get some air too, not just water.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Agree with Jeff (cactusmcharris) about the sand (and about all he said). What they show in the photo has too much fine grain in it. If they sieved it, it should have been mentioned and shown.

    ... "I used a ratio of 3 soil: 2 coarse sand: 1 perlite"... Small amount of perlite is not helping drainage, it just 'improves the look' of the mix. It is also good idea to sift perlite to get rid of dust and very small particles. Tyler (SoCal Stewart) suggested: I use a commercially prepared cacti & succulent mix to which I add pumice at a 1 to 1 ratio. That mix would be much better draining than using just small part of perlite. I do not have pumice, so use sifted perlite.

    As you can see, suggestion is to make mix more grainy. Here is photo of grit and perlite I use in my mix (in 1:1 ratio):

    You can use different mix, but should be aiming for improved drainage - small particles (like fine sand) just clog it up.

  • 6 years ago

    Thank you for your advice.


    Quite honestly it was a lot of work to remove all those cacti and remove the damp soil So I think I will wait a few days or so before I decide to do that again. I haven’t watered the plants yet - when do you guys suggest I should water them again and how much? i appreciate the advice.


    also I just got home so I’ll send a photo of the soil just for reference Since I’m sure y’all I wondering what I did



  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    JMO, so take it that way. There seems to be mixture of fine and more grainy particles, perhaps too variable in size. The fine ones will sink between the large ones, and eventually they may impair drainage. How long it will take? - depends on other cultural practices.

    I am sure it was lots of work, especially with such large plants. But if you want to make sure there are as few problems as possible, good drainage is one of the most important improvements you can make. Plant will love it, and it will be easier on you - to overwater succulents in fast draining mix is less likely. I am just assuming, but think you got it to keep inside (and sort of decorate the room?) Nothing wrong with that, just make sure they get appropriate light.

    As for mix: it is lots of work to get the ingredients and 'make' them closer in size. I use large sieve - could be used for sifting or rinsing perlite (and in your case, that sand). I aim for particles to be in 4-6mm in size. Usually do it in bulk, since I have few hundred pots...when is time to repot, it is lots of work. Luckily, most succulents do not be repotted every year unless they are too crowded. I still pot many each year, since I start many new plants from cuttings.

    I wouldn't water rootless succulents for at least couple of weeks or longer. Plants with roots should be watered few days after repotting, sometimes even same day - but I would wait if plant was in water retaining soil.

    ETA:

    I copied coupe of photos from site you linked to:

    ( https://getbusygardening.com/diy-succulent-potting-soil/ ). Sand and perlite are of very variable size, and I didn't see any recommendation to sift them. Mixing such size-variable ingredients doesn't really improve drainage much, so I would think it is lots of work for not so good results - it is sort of defeating the purpose of making the mix in the first place. BUT, again, JMO and I do not want to offend the site.


    ETA:

    Here is what Al (tapla) said about size of soil/potting mix particles:

    The key to good drainage is size and uniformity of soil
    particles. Mixing large particles with small is often very ineffective
    because the smaller particles fit between the large, increasing o/a surface
    area which increases the capillary attraction and thus the water holding
    potential.

  • 6 years ago

    The sand recommended at https://getbusygardening.com/diy-succulent-potting-soil/ doesn't look so bad to me. Their mix looks like something I would have used a few years ago except I probably would have used equal parts potting soil, sand like in the pic, and perlite. I would have washed out the finer bits of sand the result being the sand would become a bit more coarse but not much. I see fines in the perlite and I probably would have left those settled at the bottom of the bag and not used them. I'm not sure how much of an impact the finer bits of sand and perlite would have made for me if they were included in my mix- particularly if in a soil mix in a big pot. Watering habits can make a big difference.

    For a bit I tried a 1 to 1 mix of quartz play sand from Home Depot and coconut coir which worked OK for most of the cacti and succulents I tried it with but they didn't grow very much. I'm guessing the mix is nutrient poor. Recently I found an inexpensive source of coarser granite sand and all the free pumice I can cart away so I've been trying some mixes based on that.