Thanks so much for taking time to reply to my posting, Bruce! Interesting that you mention how much heat it produces — I noticed that in the store display model and wondered if that means the rest of the home stays cold (depending where the thermostat is located). Glad to know you’re liking it, otherwise!

@Reese what did you pick? We are debating the same two but linear versions.

We chose Mendota, which we’re quite satisfied with. They definitely do put out heat, even at low settings! And looks great. Good luck with your choice!

@Reese may i ask why did you end up going with Mendota? i am also debating the same two which are pretty similar to me

Netanel, I’m afraid I don’t recall why we chose one over the other. I believe the Mendota provided a better installation option (we have a slotted vent up near the ceiling that helps) and the size was better for our space as well. Both manufacturers looked excellent! I’d say go with your gut feeling of which you prefer. Good luck! Fireplaces are so lovely and warming

Hi Netanel,
Both manufacturers seemed excellent, I believe we chose Mendota for the size options (better fit and look for our space) and installation style. I’d say go with your gut feeling of which seems better for your room. Good luck! Either choice will make your room delightfully cozy :-)