Software
Houzz Logo Print
christiner117

Replace or refinish pine stairs?

6 years ago


We have already ripped up the carpet on these stairs and learned (sadly) that they're pine which I know is super soft. Now deciding - do we replace the treads with a harder wood or just sand and stain what's there?


Thinking it might be easier to replace them anyway so we can sand and stain them before they get installed.


Thanks for your thoughts!

Comments (21)

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    It would be far harder to rebuild your stair than to refinish the wood you already have. Hopefully it's in halfway decent condition.

    christiner117 thanked Johnson Flooring Co Inc
  • 6 years ago

    Often times stair treads are made from yellow pine which is strong and durable, hard too.

    christiner117 thanked Rose Pekelnicky
  • 6 years ago

    Thanks, all. I don't think these in particular are very durable - the ends (noses?) of the treads are already pretty worn on most of the steps even being protected by the carpet and padding all these years. Sounds like replacing with a harder wood is not worth the effort regardless. We will have to be okay with them developing a 'patina' over the years :)

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    If the edge was squarish before, it would be more prone to damage because the load is concentrated on a smaller area. Rounding the front edge will distribute the load and help it hold up better. Keeping the finish in good shape helps too.

  • 6 years ago

    your railing look pretty far from code, so if you start tearing up your stairs, that is something that would need fixing as well. regardless, I would look into that as your openings look pretty darn wide and I would not want that kind of liability should a kid get hurt in my house.

  • 6 years ago

    I definitely think it’s worth getting some quotes for replacing the stairs. It looks fairly poor quality, especially the handrail which doesn’t appear to be very sturdy at all. Plus all the gaps would put me off in terms of safety.

  • 6 years ago

    Agreed - we realize the stairs are not up to code and don't quite have the budget to replace them after just purchasing the home. Just looking for the best 'band-aid' solution to getting rid of the eyesore that was the carpet.

  • 6 years ago

    Keep in mind, there are very few things that are required to be "brought up to code" in a house if they are left as is or just repaired. If it was built to code at the time of construction, it's still "to code". There are a few exceptions like smoke and CO detectors, swimming pool rails, etc. No building official should tell you to change your rail system just because you replace your stair treads.

  • 6 years ago

    Christiner117 - Looks like you could pretty easily add a spindle between each existing. I bet it might be cheaper than you think. Then, you will have peace of mind when littles come to visit (if you don't have any of your own)

  • 6 years ago

    I vote for rounding the stair nosing and doing a sand and refinish. It is MUCH cheaper than dealing with new treads. If you cannot afford to deal with the railing (just yet) then I can guarantee you do not have the funds to redo the stair nor the treads.


    Do what you can with what you have. You'll be fine until you find $10K - $15K to deal with the stairs entirely.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    i count about six diff wood stain colors in that room. if you can't stain them to match the floor or the ceiling, I say paint them. plus, it's easier. Or try doing the railing in black and staining the treads.

    give it this kind of look, (minus the cables. which you could DIY later)



  • 6 years ago

    We had pine stair treads for 17 years in our previous house.

  • 6 years ago

    I would recarpet them, and call it done. I would also try to add one more spindle, in between those you have, to make it much safer. Carpet will not be as slippery as stained wood anyway.

  • 6 years ago

    @SJ McCarthy we can certainly afford to fix the railing - just not rip out and replace the whole structure. Is the railing the main thing that needs to be fixed as opposed to having the open steps?


    @Beth H. : I love this idea!!

  • 6 years ago

    The railing is the biggest issue we can see (with a single side-on photo). I'm agog at the lack of railing on the WOOD BURNING STOVE side of the stairs. You've got 3 steps and a landing that are open (without a railing) to the stove side. Yikes. One wrong step at 2am and you have 3rd degree burns because you fell onto the stove.

  • 6 years ago

    @SJ McCarthy how crazy is that?! First thing we noticed when we went to look at the house.

  • 6 years ago

    ;-P I know...The ONLY thing I can think of for this is the wood stove is too close to the stairs/landing to use a WOODEN railing. The wood being too close could be a fire hazard. Therefore the previous owner decided to forego the safety aspect of the stairs for the warmth factor of the stove. Insane but we've all seen what happens when people get what they want vs what is needed....which was to scooch the stove to the right by a few feet. The hearth and the stone wall certainly could handle it.


    As they say, "There's no fix for stupid."


    Congrats on your home. Let us know if there is anything else we can help with.

  • 6 years ago

    @SJ McCarthy I'd be so interested to see the progression of their updates over the past years to see how these choices were made :) Maybe we can go iron on the railings.

  • 6 years ago

    I'm guessing DIY work, unpermitted.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I think the treads are in better shape than the railings are. Unless they squeak or sag when you step on them, I wouldn't make any changes there. Additional spindles should fix the issue with the railings.