Yes, I should have mentioned the SW Extra White will be in different sheens. I'm leaning toward eggshell for the walls because I have three kids, though.

Happy to hear you like how yours turned out! May I ask what your floors are like? Light/dark, wood/tile, etc?

Wow, sounds like an impossible decision. I always do eggshell on my walls. New house- so exciting!!! Maybe just plan on repainting some rooms once you get settled.

Okay, I can't help myself. I keep researching paints. Anyone have thoughts on SW Pearly White or White Flour?

Oh, goodness. Maybe Alabaster. GAAAHHHHHH!!!

There IS no paint you can pick online. Write down, SW Exta white" /latex egshell finish and stop agonizing, and sign your name. . It's paint. : ) Short of hopping a plane? That's the decision. It isn't a thing you die with, no matter the color.

Afraid? Pick the palest gray in SW. ..........Fleur de Sel anyone?It's still just paint.

Elder White? It is still just paint........

Different whites do not play well with some other whites. You already have white cabinets, and have closely matched the simply white for your trim. If you really want to go white, use simply white flat on your ceiling. Simply white eggshell or satin on the walls (your preference), and simply white either semi gloss or satin on the trim. If you want satin on your trim, do not use satin on the walls. Once you are settled in a yr or so, you can always repaint in a color that goes well with your furnishings, if you choose too. You have three kids, so I would use satin sheen in their rooms anyway.

Jan, I'm sure you're right. Getting down to the wire, I'm finding myself second-guessing all of my decisions. It feels even harder being unable to see anything in person any longer.

Keep it simple as mentioned , it’s paint can be changed later.