You didn't post the poll choices, but i like it painted as in pic #2. That said, your entry seems to be taking a back seat to the garage. Any plans to change that?

The darker one looks better here because it matches the garage door, but I think either one would work, if it matches the garage door color. If you go with the lighter option, match the garage door to it.

I also think that I prefer the lighter color you have chosen to be also used for the garage door, then the garage doesn't compete with the front door (which has a contrasting color). Also, I would paint the sidelight trim next to the front door the same color as the front door.

I prefer the darker color as in photo #2 as well.

I decided to paint it to match the trim but still think it lacks curb appeal. What can I do?