They are both very nice choices, and while I usually ( not usually---always) go for blue and white, this time I do prefer the more colorful option. (and as of this moment, it looks like the votes are 3 for color and 1 for blue). Not to drive you crazy, they are both good options.

Thank you Salona! I appreciate your input. My only hesitation with the blue rug is it is an indoor/outdoor rug. Im Not sure if it will look too casual for my dining room.

I like the first one, not sure if my vote registered.

Thank you!

I’m including some mockups of the

colorful rug in my space and one with similar colors as the blue and ivory rug.

Thank you!!

I think I’ll get a sample of each and see which one feels right in my space. I will Keep you posted.

Do you think I can get away with keeping my curtains with the multicolored rug?

Not a pro, but I would say yes, judging from your picture. You may eventually want to change to ivory- or cream-colored curtains, which would be less busy, but your current curtains are inoffensive, IMO.

Thank you for your input.

Right when I was ready to finally make my decision, pottery barn put their scroll tile rug on sale!!

Not nearly as pretty as the medallion rug you've been considering, and it actually reminds me more of an outdoor or patio rug than a dining room rug.

Thank you Ida!