Most houses including every craftsman I’ve owned have simpler trim on the outside than the inside.

Nobody can answer without interior and exterior pictures of the home.

We need pics and generally exterior trim does not need to match interior trim.

Thank you! Apologizing for my lack of photography skills, but here are some shots:

Thank you! (We’d like to replace eventually, but were thinking that in the short term, we’d replace any rotting boards/fascia and then paint.)

You already did the inside, yes? The inside trim, while you may love Craftsman style, is at odds with the feeling of the house. Just a simpler, palin and beefier trim to the exterior.

Craftsman, is SO obviously a trim style, it is best where it makes sense.......and the doors are particularly telling. Some styles work anywhere. A single recessed panel, a two panel at most. Neither screams any specific style. Craftsman is another story, altogether.

In your home?

It's the pics below. Fits.....and maybe too much a style "stretch".

Nobody would suggest that a sixties or seventies home must retain slab doors and ranch molding. But you don't want a gigantic "surprise" , either. You can't take a frosted San Francisco Victorian, and be anything but shocked to find it stripped of all trim inside, anymore than a farmhouse would be laden with gooey frosting INSIDE.

For those expensive re trimming projects? Consider the feel. Carefully. : )

Thank you!!