Black with white down spouts.

+2 🌿

If the downspouts can all be on corners, then all black can look really sharp on this home! Otherwise, black gutters and white downspouts.

Thank you all for your opinions! I'm really stuck between all black or a mixture of the two. My worry is that the transition from the black gutter to the white downspout won't flow well and look odd.

cute house. I think you can go either way.

I tend to lean white against the siding, and black when it's along the trim.

or, you could do all black like this

Or, do a copper colored spout/rain gutter. (but paint your shutters black)

You aren't making this any easier!

I'm guessing you looked online at all the white houses with black trim? They can look so nice. I wouldn't highlight downspouts. Agree those should be white. Yes, gorgeous tree!