No dark counter or backsplash with those cabinets --- will look like a cave. I'd keep things light as they are now and add spots of color with accessories instead. New lighting will go a long way here, too, as would stainless appliances.

I agree with the suggestion to keep things light. However, as someone who loves color (including the blue you're considering), keep in mind that if you can modify your lighting, you should do that first and then decide whether you still want a darker backsplash. Any color or shade will look different under different lighting.

If at all possible, install undercabinet lights and maybe cans spaced around the perimeter to replace the existing ceiling fixture. Then it will be easier to tell whether the improved lighting can keep the space from becoming too dark if you do a blue backsplash tile.

I'd also replace the valence. If you decide on a light backsplash, then you could bring in some blue with a roman blind or box valence.

Cape Cod · More Info

Kitchen Valence · More Info

Love the second one! Thank you