I think it's totally fine if you like it. Color and proportions work.

What's the look you want here? The gold seems suited to the cabinet, but not the floor. Take some more pics. Are you painting the vanity? Just changing hardware? What/where is lighting?

Feels a bit disjointed in the middle of process. Did you have an inspo picture? A nice big 36 inch round could work, but need a bit more info as to final look you want

Not changing the cabinet. we Replaced the floor and vanity top along with the sink and faucet. Will add a few more photos :)

If you like the mirror, keep it. Since you asked what I would do, I don’t have a problem mixing metals. If you don’t like mixing gold and silver tones, dry brushing silver paint on the mirror frame. If you don’t like the mirror, the new mirror only needs to be as wide as the sink and you could add sconces flanking it for less shadows on the face. If you have 2 people using the vanity at the same time, add 2 separate mirrors on either side of the sink. .

it works w/the light and the vanity. the floor is what's throwing it off.

maybe put down a small runner in front of the vanity.

or, you could paint the frame white to match the countertop.

Or paint it in a silvery finish. .............but it feels too formal a frame, honestly. What size is it? I'd re purpose and get new: ) Simple nickel frame. Maybe even a 36 inch diameter round.

Pottery barn

anything else going in there? some shelves or art over the toilet? any type of countertop decor?

maybe a frame stained to match the vanity would look better

here are some similar combos

Hi Beth H. yes we definitely want to put something over the toilet just not sure what yet. Shelves seem to make it look smaller though. Do you have any suggestion?

not sure why it would look smaller.

I'd do a glass shelf (or a wood one) maybe some art, or some towels, or faux plants. just depends.