Software
Houzz Logo Print
beth_greenstein

Questioning the way my hickory range hood has been finished

5 years ago

We are Building a house and wanted a driftwood range hood and island to go with my white kitchen. When I saw the wood finish on the hood and island, I don’t like the way they were finished, particularly the striped staining. My design center is saying that’s what I picked and it’s the type of wood we chose, hickory. We were not advised that the wood would look striped and circus like. I really want them replaced or redone so there is no striping. Is this look acceptable? Would love feedback?

Comments (23)

  • 5 years ago

    Yes, it's acceptable. In fact the workmanship looks fantastic. You get stripey with hickory. It's a busy grain.

  • 5 years ago

    But shouldn’t we have been told hickory is stripey?

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    But shouldn’t we have been told hickory is stripey?


    Why would you expect that?


    Why didn't you ask what it would look like?



  • 5 years ago

    How did you select hickory? It’s difficult, I believe, to have looked at hickory and be unaware that the wood tones are variegated and often striped. I think expecting your cabinet maker to tell you that is a bit like expecting to being warned that water is wet or the sky is blue. I’m sorry your hood isn’t want you were looking for. I agree with the commenter above that the workmanship looks nice.

  • 5 years ago

    A customer’s hickory cabinets came in with the finished side of the pantry looking exactly like a backgammon board. Whenever I worked with customers getting hickory I made a point of showing them just how much the grain varies. (Hickory is very popular in Maine)

  • 5 years ago

    Shouldn’t you have seen the stripey-ness in the showroom? Or, in a COVID environment, on a sample door sent to you? Did you really choose that species without seeing what it looks like?

    What you’re seeing is the nature of hickory. Once you signed off on the cabinets, you have little recourse.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    What you received is the character of hickory. It's not my favorite wood because of the stripes and variegated look that hickory often has. I can understand why you would be frustrated if that wasn't what you expected. What made you choose hickory? Did you request a "driftwood" look (as you describe in your original post) and the builder suggested hickory?

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    If I was ordering cabinets, I would minimally do a google search for hickory cabinets. 60 seconds looking at images online would have shown you cabinets that look exactly like yours. It's the nature of the wood.



  • 5 years ago

    If you hate them that much, may as well have them redone in a different wood species or painted over so you don’t see them stripes anymore. I guess it depends on your budget of course...:(
    Is probably easier and cheaper to have this fixed now that later on when everything is in place...

  • 5 years ago

    Its decent grain-matching on that hood. Guess you'll have to paint over it.

  • 5 years ago

    The builder I am building with has a half ownership in a design center. They send you there to pick all of your selections. I went with many pictures of what I wanted my kitchen and cabinets to look like, color wise. I NEVER requested hickory wood. My designer pulled a stained wood door and told us this was a match to my pictures. There was never a discussion about type of wood or how it will have a stripey look. It didn’t even Dawn on us to ask what the hood will look like, I assumed that it would look like the pictures I brought. It wasn’t like I came in to the design center and said, I want hickory. I wanted a certain look. I will attach a pic.

  • 5 years ago

    Hmmm, just tell the builder what you said and show them how your pics differ from finished product but the lesson is the same, you need to be way more involved, no one will care as much as you do... it’s your money so always triple check you and the designer are in same page... they leave the project once it’s done but you have to live with it....

  • 5 years ago

    Because wood it’s natural product now you know the grain is important too... it would be like telling someone I want cream colored counter tops but not taking a moment to determine if you want cream colored marble, quartz or granite... of course they will look different...even if the “same” color

  • 5 years ago

    If you showed them the bottom it looks to me like walnut. And you can see different darknesses in the grain. Not as dramatic as your hickory, but still definitely there. BTW, be lucky they seem to have taken some effort to get select. All the hickory I have seen has also had knots.

  • 5 years ago

    Just ow commenting to say the view out of your windows is nice...:)

  • 5 years ago

    When you find a picture of a look you like you are well served to investigate and understand what makes up that look. Things are so variable with a unique product like natural wood or stone counters. You have to be the artist.

  • 5 years ago

    When you say finished What is the finishing? A darker stain evens out hickory . They could have asked but you should have requested input on stain selection. Is there stain on these pieces? It all has an unstained appearance . I’d find out what has been done and if darkening by a finisher is an option. Last resort is paint.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    IMO the hood is all wrong for that kitchen anyway. Cabinets that do not go to the ceiling just look ridiculous with a fancy wood hood . BTW wood hoods get gross with steam oil and dirt that is always present with cooking and your cabinets are all stipey too what did you expect from the hood in the same wood . I guess if you hate pay to have it redone IMO get a nice stainless one or spend the money to get that whole wall redone to keep the hood from looking silly on a wall with tiny cabinets.

  • 5 years ago

    The stripes should have been more random on the hood for sure. Have you had a test stain done on a sample piece to see how it changes it? It may look even better and less stripey with stain. See what it would take to redo it or parts of it, can't hurt to ask. Also, ignore @Patricia Colwell Consulting do NOT exchange that out for a stainless one. Wood hoods, when sealed properly are perfectly easy to wipe down and clean. It looks great the size it is and brings the eye up.

  • 5 years ago

    is that hood and island finished? I mean the wood. is it finished? nothing else is going on it? clear coat, stain??

    i've never seen hickory w/a pickling done to it.

    Is the hood smooth to the touch? oiled and sealed? I put two coats of varnish on the wood trim around my vent hood. makes it easier to clean.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    I have a hickory Island. Love it.