Hi,

I'm sweating that very decision. (I eliminated the Verticyl as I'm worried about poor drainage with the flat bottome) Which did you go with and how do you like it?

I haven't seen the Caxton in person and am so-so on the Ladena, but it's better than the other options.

Thanks!

We chose this Kohler Elmbrook undermount sink for our guest bathroom. While we wish the overflow hole was on the opposite side so you don't see it directly under the faucet, we preferred the look of the Elmbrook over the Ladena.

Our designer specified two XL Katie sinks for our 10 ft floating vanity in our primary bathroom (currently under construction). We're planning to install our sinks with a slight positive reveal and the Obrien sinks have a finished rim. Also they can be installed so the overflow hole doesn't appear directly under the faucets.

The Caxton is a classic, and people seem to like it. I like the shape of the Ladena better, and I feel like it is more popular now (reaching Caxton level.) I find the oval small and kind of silly, but you don’t have a ton of room with two sinks, so consider that. You are at decision-fatigue stage, but for this, I say drag yourself over to Ferguson and stand in front of both. Neither one is a bad choice. Good luck!

Thanks to both of you!

Hi smalloldhouse_gw and JD H,

May I ask which sink you both went with? I also am contemplating one of these 2 sinks for a project and can't figure out which to go with. I do like the curvature of the Ladena and Caxton over the Verticyl because I think the Verticyl could have potential drainage and cleaning issues. Thanks for any help.