Software
Houzz Logo Print
midwestmelissa

Sherwin-Williams Alabaster white paint help!!!!

5 years ago

I have a painter coming in one week to paint over 2000 square feet of ceiling. And I cannot decide on a white paint for them!
Most all of the walls in our main living spaces are SW ALABASTER.
Would SW HIGH REFLECTIVE WHITE or SW EXTRA WHITE coordinate better?
I know the SW Alabaster can be tough when trying to pair with other whites.
Thank you so VERY much. 😊

Comments (11)

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago







    Both of the above will work with Alabaster should you fancy the contrast. See there the difference in Chroma. 🌈

    midwestmelissa thanked Marylee H
  • 5 years ago

    Thank you so much for this information! And for simplifying it for me since those color wheels make my head spin, LOL! The painter wanted to go with pure white, however, someone told me that would make the Alabaster look strange. They said something about it not being far enough from Alabaster or something? And the wrong hues? That same person suggested either High reflective white or extra white by Sherwin-Williams.

    I just really wanted to ask someone else's professional opinion before giving them my final choice since I had different opinions from others. We saved for quite awhile to be able to do this. So it's a one-and-done thing. Thank you so very much!

  • 5 years ago

    You may find this article of interest, also from The Land of Color like the Colorographies above,


    https://thelandofcolor.com/the-best-paint-colors-to-go-with-sherwin-williams-alabaster-sw-7008/

    midwestmelissa thanked Marylee H
  • 5 years ago

    Pure White will also work but the contrast will be less crisp than with those mentioned above as Pure White has more Chroma than they.



    midwestmelissa thanked Marylee H
  • PRO
    5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Extra White is one of my favorite colors of white - but not on a ceiling.

    HRW isn't a ceiling color either.

    Pure White technically works well with Alabaster but I wouldn't choose it for a ceiling color.

    Delicate White is your best bet. Both Ben Moore and Sherwin Williams can color match it. (I've done it and analyzed the results many times and can say confidently that color matching in this case results in pretty colors)

    Def grab a sample and make sure you like how it looks with Alabaster before you paint 2K sf of ceiling.

    midwestmelissa thanked Lori A. Sawaya
  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Thank You. May I ask why Extra White is not a ceiling color? I just had 3 people tell me that it works really well with Alabaster. So I was thinking that would be a good choice for the ceilings. Am I wrong? Oh no!

    Would I be better off going with the painters original suggestion of Pure White?

    I'm really looking at just getting a paint color directly from Sherwin-Williams instead of having them match it. Reason being, I think I'm already irritating my painter because we were supposed to choose the paint last week and now I told her I just changed my mind. She said to send her the Sherwin-Williams number by Friday.

    I feel so badly bothering everyone but I need to get a paint color to the painter for the ceilings and I guess I have no idea what I'm doing. I've just never spent this much money on my house. :-)

    (We do have a couple of rooms that are Agreeable Gray and we have one kids bedroom that is SW Smoky Asurite... the rest of the house is all Alabaster white on the walls).

    Thank you soooo much!

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    May I ask why Extra White is not a ceiling color? I just had 3 people tell me that it works really well with Alabaster.


    EW and Alabaster work well together in terms of multiple levels of color relationship. But application matters.


    The ceiling isn't the "5th wall". Only people who don't do paint/color for a living refer to the ceiling as the 5th wall. (I think it's a stupid comment if you can't tell)


    Because when you do this every day, you learn very quickly that color renders differently on the ceiling - a horizontal plane above your head - vs. a vertical wall.


    Color on the ceiling 'grays out' and gets darker.


    There aren't that many colors of white to choose from when you get down to it.


    And the number of whites that have the right pitch of hue, brightness and chroma are even fewer.


    If there was a comparable color in SW to Delicate White, I would have recommended it.


    There isn't.


    I'd tell your painter to meet you at the house to sample the colors so you can compare and make the final decision. Promise to keep your end of the bargain to decide and not look back.

    midwestmelissa thanked Lori A. Sawaya
  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Lori A. Sawaya,

    I can't thank you enough for your time. I really truly appreciate it and your knowledge is Way Beyond mine. So thank you.

    Unfortunately, we have already met with the painter 3 times and we did view large samples up against the Alabaster. She suggested Pure White. I was torn between High Reflective white and Extra White. To be fair, she has given me ample time to make my decision but I just came across all this new color information too late in the game. I'm really down to deciding between one of the Sherwin-Williams whites.

    I spoke with her and she said the extra white has already been purchased. I already changed on her once because I first decided on High Reflective White. She let me change because she had another project that she said she could use it on for....someone who was painting their she shed and just wanted it any color white.

    She said she could be willing to swap out for that, but that's all she can do for me now. If she has to go get new paint for me again, I would have to pay for both colors even though I would only be using the one.

    I truly appreciate all of your time that you have taken to answer this question for me. Unfortunately, this time I waited too long and I'm just going to have to try to decide between the High reflective and the Extra White at this time.

  • 5 years ago

    @midwestmelissa Let us know what you ended up choosing. I am facing same choice - using SW High Reflective White for trim as it matches semi-custom cabinets but unsure about using it on ceiling. I have read several comments that recommend using same paint color on ceiling as on trim. It does seem very bright but maybe that is a good thing?

  • 5 years ago

    Has the work been completed? Are you happy? I am looking into the exact same colors as well!