Software
Houzz Logo Print
ajitha_antony_diaz

Need recommendations for small/medium tree in Chicago area

I am replacing a chokecherry with black knot and need suggestions on what to replace it with. The photos show the location.
My main goal is privacy between my 2nd story deck and my neighbors 2nd story deck, so would need a height of at least 25 feet. Ideally a single trunk as the spot is a little narrow. Would love to have some sort of seasonal interest. I loved the red leaves of the old tree, but flowers, fall color, or pretty foliage would fit the bill. I also want something that will be reliable/hardy and not require replacement in my lifetime. I am nervous about zone 5 trees because we had a sweetbay magnolia that thrived, then killed off by a bad winter. We are avoiding maples because we already have a maple and want variety. Also, the faster it can grow, the better!
If I could get opinions on the following trees, or suggestions on what to plant, I would be so grateful.
1. Spring Flurry Serviceberry
2. Galaxy Magnolia (zone 5, does anyone have one that is thriving in zone 5?) Is there a single trunk saucer magnolia that is preferred?
3. Thornless Cockspur Hawthorne
4. Royal Frost Birch: my husband loves this one, I am scared a birch will not last very long
Thanks!

Comments (9)

  • 5 years ago

    You only want privacy in summer, and no (attempt at) noise abatement from their a/c condensers?

    Arborvitae and then your splash of specimen tree color a little farther down the hill away from the arborvitae?

  • 5 years ago

    That is a great idea! Those a/c units are constantly running and drive me nuts!

  • 5 years ago

    how big are you buying.. and how many years are you willing to wait .... in tree time.. for it to grow to height ... ???


    there are many more considerations.. than a name of a tree .... in this particular situation ..


    anything that will grow to the requisite height... in a short time... will not magically stop growing at said height.. and will soon.. in tree time.. become a problem ... as it will just keep growing... for your life time ....


    tree time is counted in decades.. not a season or two ..


    frankly .. i think your solution is a garden drape an the edge of the deck .. for immediate impact and use ... and then you could plant a tree to solve the problem in 10 or 15 years


    and if you are planting huge.. have it professionally done ... with a guarantee ... that hill/slope is going to be problematic.. a not only as to planting.. but also proper watering for the number of years it will be required for a transplant .... and even longer for a huge transplant ... lawn irrigation will not be enough or proper in transplanting ....


    i used balcony for the search term... as deck solutions would probably be more ground level


    https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffnt&q=garden+drape+for+balcony&iax=images&ia=images


    ken


    ps: buying and maintaining a single trunk.. is just a matter of some pruning... of which it is easy to become expert at.. it should not be thought of as magical nor mysterious ... birch can have borer issues .. though some 'claim' to be resistant .. yeah.. sure .. the one you sold me had such claim.. and it wasnt .. and i doubt you will get a z5 mag to get that large .... in your lifetime anyway ... and in z5.. arbs arent going to grow all that fast ...


    pps: where are you .... big city name.. z5 is about half the US... and very divergent for reasons other than min winter temp ... which all zone is ....


  • 5 years ago

    Title says Chicago area, I'm guessing a happy outer ring suburb and 5a/5b.

  • 5 years ago

    Ken, thank you for all your input. I am in the Chicago suburbs, 5b. We plan to have the tree professionally planted and looking to plant a tree that is at least 2 inch caliper. I appreciate the advice about the garden drape, it's something I could look into.

    I understand that patience is needed. our chokecherry took 9 years to get as tall as it is. I am hoping to get to to 20 feet tall within 10 years. If a tree without ornamental value could not achieve this, I am open to getting a shade tree.

    It sounds like magnolia is out, and I do not want to bother with birch. Is serviceberry a reasonable option? This "spring flurry" has a pyramidal or oval shape that I like. would "autumn brilliance" behave the same way (that seems easier to find). I have never seen the thornless hawthorn in person, so opinions on that are appreciated.

    Any suggestions are appreciated.

  • 5 years ago

    Either the serviceberry or the hawthorn would work for you. Both can have issues - pretty much any kind of tree does - with the serviceberry generally having less than the hawthorn.

  • 5 years ago

    Hawthorne flowers have a smell to them as well. I'd sniff before buying and the one at my old house was covered in rust every year.


    I like serviceberries. Spring flowers, summer fruit for the birds and fall color.


    A couple of others to look at would be a disease resistant crabapple, Japanese tree or peking lilac. However, I'd recommend sniff before you buy on the lilac trees as well.

  • 5 years ago

    I see noise was mentioned, plantings have just about no effect on noise.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Looks like a south facing slope - do you have irrigation? If you do, one of the hardy magnolias could actually work. Photo (below) of Yellow Lantern Magnolia (early May 2018) - a relatively strong grower. And there are other hardy magnolias that you could probably find in tree form. Or for foliage color, instead of Royal Frost Birch, maybe a Red Fox Katsura.

    If no irrigation, maybe a European Hornbeam (either the species or one of the columnar varieties) - will become a decent sized tree and has dense branching that is good for screening. Or possibly one of the pines with a more upright form - maybe Silveray Korean Pine, or Columnar White Pine (fast grower, will become very large).

    Serviceberry, hawthorn, tree lilac, are relatively slow growers, and the latter 2 are not very upright at maturity. Crabapple is a bit faster, but most crabs are also not very upright at maturity.


Sponsored
Industry Leading Kitchen & Bath Remodelers in Franklin County, Ohio