Software
Houzz Logo Print
mtvhike

Smoke detector problem

4 years ago
last modified: 4 years ago

My relatively new house has 5 hard-wired and interconnected smoke detectors installed by the builder in 2015. I've never done the routine annual "change the batteries" procedure, just replacing one when it starts chirping. The other night, they all went off and it took awhile to find the guilty one, it was in my wife's art studio. She had been working in it the day before and never heard the chirp.

Today, I decided to replace the rest of them. 4 of them have regular 9-volt batteries, but the fifth, in the utility room is a smoke/CO2 combo and has 2 AAs. They were marked Kidde, so I assume they were installed when the house was completed. I replaced them also, but now that detector is chirping and has the message "battery low". These batteries are new, unused, with a date of March 2030, but I've had them about a year. I will buy a pair of new ones from the local hardware store, but do any of you think there might be another problem?

On a related matter, it was suggested to me that my array should include two different types; some photocell based ones and some ionization ones. What do you think. Since, as I understand it, all smokes should be replaced every 10 years and these are almost 7 years old. My house is all electric, except for a propane cooktop upstairs from the utility room.

Comments (18)

  • 4 years ago

    The new batteries are fine. What you are hearing is the 7 year end of life chirp. You can read about it here.

    Here is a link about photoelectric vs ionization smoke detectors. Given you have 5 smoke detectors I don't think you have to worry about it.

  • 4 years ago

    There was no chirp until I replaced the batteries.

  • 4 years ago

    The previous owner may have installed the batteries incorrectly or the batteries were completely dead. You can try another set of batteries. If it continues to chirp you will need a new smoke/carbon monoxide detector.

  • 4 years ago

    Replacing the batteries didn't help. I happen to have another new detector, but it's not a CO detector. I'll replace them all when most are 10 years old, in three years. How important is it to have a CO detector in a room with no devices which burn anything? This is my utility room and only has an electrically powered boiler and DHW heater.


  • 4 years ago

    "it was suggested to me that my array should include two different types; some photocell based ones and some ionization ones"

    Correct. Types of Smoke Detectors.

    "How important is it to have a CO detector in a room with no devices which burn anything?"

    Maybe just get a combo model.

  • 4 years ago

    "How important is it to have a CO detector in a room with no devices?"

    VERY. Need one in my home on second floor outside BRs... detects CO from generator outside my garage.


    "Carbon monoxide detectors should be installed on every level of your home — specifically outside of sleeping areas, in the kitchen, in living/dining areas, and in the garage. Also install one near your gas furnace, if you have one, as well as in the laundry room if you have a gas clothes dryer."



  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Smoke detectors have a finite life expectancy. They require annual maintenance while includes replacing batteries and vacuuming out the detectors--at least the photoelectric type. You'll be well served to replace all of them with new detectors and install one or more combo detectors as suggested above to include CO detection.

  • 4 years ago

    The only combustion I have within 500 feet of my house is my propane stove in the kitchen and, potentially, a campfire 200 feet away (other than motor vehicles, which aren't left running). However, I'll replace all of them with combo units.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    The Battery Life info above may be out of date - or not correct in many states.

    My batteries, both Smoke Detectors, CO, and Combo have ten year batteries and here in my State the Smoke Detector batteries must be 10 year. YMMV.

    "Maryland law now requires all Maryland residents to have 10-year lithium batteries on their smoke detectors that are tamper-resistant with the silence/hush feature. There must be one on every level of a home."

    My Smoke Detector/CO Alarm COMBO - TEN YEAR BATTERY

    The old batteries may be legal in Cady, TX. Wait for a post from there to see. lol

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    "The only combustion I have within 500 feet of my house is my propane stove in the kitchen... "

    Here in Maryland this propane stove would require CO detectors.

    Also, if you have an attached garage. Likely no one intentionally leaves a car running so as to kill their family members or themselves!

  • 4 years ago

    I buy only ten year sealed battery alarms now. Even if they cost a bit more, the peace of mind and no hassle of chirps and replacing batteries makes them a good investment.

  • 4 years ago

    Are they interconnected?

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    In my case no, had the house been built in 2009 or later they would have to be interconnected.

    "Any new home in Maryland constructed after January 1, 1989 required at least one hardwired electric smoke alarm on every level of the home, including the basement and required the units to be interconnected in order that activation of any one of the required smoke alarms resulted in the sounding all of the required ..."

  • 4 years ago

    Perusing the Big Box stores, it appears that the 10-year battery ones are promoted to not require hard wiring or interconnection. My existing ones are powered and interconnected, and I would like to replace them with ones which the batteries don't have to be replaced.

  • 4 years ago

    They're all hardwired, can be interconnected, and have a backup battery.

    In 2015 I bought detectors that didn't have batteries but they're not manufactured anymore.

  • 4 years ago

    The Home Depots in my area carry hardwired smoke detectors. I'm not sure if all can be interconnected or not. All have onboard battery backups.


    When I did an addition, then prevailing code required a hardwired smoke detector. It was placed near the top beam in a room with an open beam ceiling. I got frustrated when the battery started chirping some years later because I, moi, am not someone ready to climb up a ladder to reach something 15+ feet off the ground. I got an electrician to disconnect it and then put a battery operated smoke detector in the room on the wall, at a level I can reach using a stepstool. It may be less useful at that level but it was either that or nothing.

  • PRO
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I'm not sure what the applicable building code in the OP's state requires, but the 2018 IRC (R313.4.4) requires physical interconnection (i.e., hardwiring) of smoke detectors. However, interconnection is not required when listed wireless alarms are installed and all alarms sound upon activation of one alarm.