Software
Houzz Logo Print
tamar_kornbluth

Grade #1 White Oak Floors

4 years ago

Hi!
I purchased a new construction home from a builder that allowed certain upgrades to be chosen and paid for (semi custom I guess). As part of his standard package he gives red oak grade #1 floors 3.25 width in the whole house. I really wanted light white oak floors so I paid about 2k to upgrade to white oak. I’m also upgraded the sealer he uses to Bona from Minwax (either using Nordic or Natural still deciding) as from everything I’ve read here that’s an important step to getting nice light floors that won’t yellow. To upgrade my floors to select would be an additional 5k which is really much more then our budget allows now. Will grade #1 floors sealed with Nordic or Natural still be nice looking? Do you have any pictures you can share of similar looking floors? As much as I don’t want to spend more at this point I also want them to be nice and right looking because I still am paying a nice amount for the upgrades I’m doing… thanks in advance for any information you can share!

Comments (20)

  • 4 years ago

    I just went through this exact decision. I am redoing the floors in my entire house. We have a lower grade of pine throughout the house now but are only replacing the floors downstairs with white oak and just refinishing the pine upstairs. We just redid the staircase and the treads are white oak select. So the choice was select downstairs which would match more closely with the steps or a #1 which would have more mineral streaks and some knots and feel a bit closer to what we have upstairs. It was a close call but we went with the select. Honestly Honestly, we could have gone either way. I think the knots and streaks add a bit of interest but the select feels a bit more contemporary. I don't think you can make a bad decision here unless you are going for a very contemporary look.

  • 4 years ago

    Thank you so much!! Any chance you have any photos of the #1 white oak? Or anyone else who’s reading it would love to see!

  • 4 years ago

    I don’t but you can google images of both select and #1 to compare them.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    $7k upgrade for 3 1/4" select white oak from what price? Not sure how many square feet you have, but did you try getting a quote from a outside source and compare the cost? Sounds like it would be cheaper to have a outside source install and finish the flooring or provide your own flooring for the builders floor guy to put in.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    That often will not happen with a new build since builders have the stuff they use and the warranty is usually covering the stuff they use. I do not like oak so in my head the better the quality the better the finished product . can you post pics of the samples they gave you. I agree alot depends on your style , for me knots and busy grain would make me crazy.

  • 4 years ago

    @G & S floor service it’s a 2800 square foot house that all the floors are wood - the only tile I have is in my upstairs bathrooms. If I would have done the red oak he gives as standard I wouldn’t have paid anything. I wanted white oak so that was a 2k upgrade. To do the select would be 5k - I’m not sure if 7k total or 5k total. I’m sure he is also making money off any upgrades because that’s generally how these builders usually work. Putting in my own floors isn’t really an option for me because he wouldn’t let. I am curious how much you think that would cost for that size house. Is the white oak upgrade price reasonable? What about the 1800 he is charging me to upgrade to Bona stain.

  • 4 years ago

    @Patricia Colwell Consulting he didn’t give me samples - he’s not the easiest person to work with in general. That’s why I was asking if anyone had any photos of floors finished like that so I can get an idea of what they would look like. I do like oak but i am trying to decide if the knots and streaks would bother me on my own floors. When I was googling pictures I only really saw small samples not fully stained and installed lighter floors so it’s hard to really know.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    The $1800 upcharge for staining is a good price, should be at least $3k for 2800 square feet. Your 2800 square feet wood floor project with 2 staircases should have at least a budget from $50k-$60K. Lean on the high side for subfloor prep, specialty underlayments and fasteners. Cost of flooring is around $18k. Cost difference between select red oak and select white oak in my area ranges from $.25-$1.00 per square feet depending on quality. A $5k upgrade is reasonable but, in my opinion $7k is too high. You're at the mercy of the builders. They have to make their money.

  • 4 years ago

    In addition to Grade 1 vs Select, be sure you are getting longer board length. IMO even a lower grade floor looks better if the boards are long, avoiding that chopped up look of short boards.

  • 4 years ago

    Thank you all so much, I really appreciate the input it really helps me! Do any of the flooring professionals here have any photos of select #1 white oak projects they have done in a natural or light look? I think that would really help me with this decision as I’m having a hard time finding on google… seeing a lot of select or character but not #1.

  • 4 years ago

    A P - gorgeous floors!!

  • 4 years ago

    Thanks for commenting! Love the herringbone - what finish/stain did you use?

  • PRO
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago



    Prefinished white oak, refinished with two coats of nordicseal and two coats of traffic hd satin.

  • PRO
    4 years ago


    New 4” select white oak finished with three coats of Ciranova Wood Look.

  • PRO
    4 years ago


    Existing white oak floors refinished with three coats of Ciranova Wood Look.

  • 3 years ago

    #A P I know this post is from earlier this year but I have been looking for the exact color you have on your floor with no avail.
    What stain and finish did you have on your floors?

  • 3 years ago

    @abesmum I don’t know that this is what they used but look at Bona intense seal, amber seal or classic seal looks like it could be one of those to me. I ended up with Bona Nordic seal bc I wanted a whiter lighter look. The Bona seals are amazing in that they only give the floor a bit of a tint and allow the natural wood to really show… hers definitely give that look

  • 3 years ago

    Hi
    We used neutral and weathered from bona. Sealed with matte bona traffic

  • 3 years ago

    T F and A P Thank you both for taking the time to address and answer my question! I greatly appreciate it!