These are a few additional photos of the dining area and adjoining room

bumping this- I'd love to see some of the suggestions. Your home is lovely.

I like the second light...not as cool as brushed nickel but not as warm as brass. Keep in mind that it will only light the table, which I think is fine, unless you need more light in the room.

I think the middle one goes best with your space. You don't have any other gold in the space that I can see, so the other two look random. Of course, if you are looking to bring in more color, vibrancy, and dimension beyond just the gray, silver and white you have right now, the first one in all brass would look beautiful. I would recommend bringing in other shades elsewhere though not just with the one fixture.

I owuls change all the lighting to 4000K , 5K is too blue and harsh IMO for any space and my whole house is 4000K and it mimics daylight . The light you have no matter what bulb you put in it will always look bad since the shades are yellow toned

I don't think any of those oversized heavy pendants fit your space. I'm not sure what is the matter with what you have. looks pretty nice. other than its a bit too large. I would be going more simple, not adding more weight to this room. I also think it need to work with the existing pendant lights.

You have a beautiful house!. I'd go with the first or third one. Your current lamp looks builder grade and personally I don't like lights that point up. That might be part of your issue with the fixture.

Thank you! Agreed - I feel that the light pointing up may be what’s throwing me off.

Thanks all for the suggestions :) Unfortunately, I’m still torn as to what direction I want to go.

just keep in mind you dont have tall ceiling, and the room is not huge, and fairly full of deco, so I would want the light to be simple and open. This angle tells me you dont need anything large notice how much the room "grew" without a fixture at all.

If it was me, I would remove the 2 pendants, as they seem rather "staged" and then do a series of three pendants over the nook table.

Here we have a variety of dining room chandeliers which might work in your space or interest you. Please note the rugs, chairs, and window treatments.

Modern Glam · More Info

Modern Glam · More Info

Modern Ranch: Dining Room · More Info

Transitional Home: Dining Room · More Info

Dining room · More Info

Dining room · More Info

Dining room · More Info

Dining room · More Info

W`d like to offer you some variants for your dining table. Consider, please

I think the room would benefit from some warmth and texture.

Open Weave Cane Rib Dome Pendant Lamp, Natural · More Info