What color is your roof?

Craftsman style lean toward earth colors.

In the picture the exterior looks peachy. If you want to stay with a light color you just want to stay away from a color with a peach undertone. Colors look a lot lighter on exteriors under sunlight, so choose a medium to light tone. Do you or your painter have a preference for a particular brand of paint? Take a look at Benjamin Moore's historical colors - maybe Shaker Beige or Grant Beige. Whatever you do, be sure to look at samples on all sides of your house at different times of day for a couple days before you commit to a color. If you find a shade you like but you think it's too dark, the retailer can cut the tint by 25% or 50%. Gray would be my last choice for a house of this style.

This color scheme should work for your home.

Light, grayish aqua or turquoise-y gray. SW aquasphere or rain.

This is a little bit late, actually quite a bit late…but thank you all for the suggestions. I never got notifications of responses and forgot I posted !

My roof is on the gray/brown side.

I do like the earthy darker colors

My neighbors have lighter colors, so I’m still trying to find a color so I won’t stand out TOO much