Nothing at least until everything else is in place.

I agree with deb. The backsplash should be last. You need to see the off white will look on your cabinets with your lighting.

Thank you!

I never like brown paint it always looks like you wanted wood and cheaped out. I agree wait until the cabinets are painted for any other choice. Make sure all your lighting in that space for sur eis LED 4000K and be careful when trying to mix whites they often do not play well together

Are you actually planning on painting the island brown, or do you mean you will leave it cherry?

I’d like to get the island stained brown, not painted. I am tired of the cherry stain. I like the idea of painting the rest of the cabinets a warm white. Thank you, everyone for your suggestions!