Software
Houzz Logo Print
3katz4me

What do you feed your cats?

4 years ago

My two older cats eat prescription food. The kitten is supposed to eat kitten food until she's a year old. She was eating Fancy Feast when I got her and my perception has always been that it's not the greatest quality food. So I asked the vet's office what a good quality over the counter food is. She doesn't like any of these relatively expensive foods. She devoured the Fancy Feast when I first got her - not sure if she still likes it or not. I tried a few other cans of over the counter kitten food today - she won't touch it. She loves the very expensive small cans of prescription food which the vet said she can continue to eat - okay for kittens. I generally spare no expense for my cats but the cost of this food, considering how much a growing kitten eats, is over the top. She doesn't need to eat this food and my other cat does. He will also eat dry so it's not cost prohibitive just for him.

Anyway, just wondering what my virtual cat friends are feeding their cats and what your thoughts are regarding quality of cat food and what kind of difference it makes.

Comments (21)

  • 4 years ago

    One of my cats has a sensitive stomach and is picky on top of that. (And he has lymphoma. And an eye problem I need to take him to a veterinary eye specialist for on Friday. Sigh.)


    I feed him an the other two cats Core Signature Selects grain-free canned food, in the Skipjack Tuna & Salmon and Shredded Chicken & Chicken Liver flavors (https://www.chewy.com/wellness-core-signature-selects/dp/146916). Pricy, but probably not as much so as prescription. I don't know if it's appropriate for kittens, though I think it's pretty high protein.

  • 4 years ago

    My cats have eaten Hill's dry food since I adopted them at the shelter (that's what they ate there). Zephyr has a sensitive stomach so they get Hill's I/D. Both love it. I've tried to transition them to wet food, but they don't like it, not even Fancy Feast.

  • 4 years ago

    When I foster kittens, I feed them Fancy Feast or Royal Canin wet kitten food, and Purina Kitten Chow Naturals dry food.

    The older cats get Young Again, a high protein dry food, because one of them is diabetic.

  • 4 years ago

    Mine eat Royal Canin hypoallergenic. They love the dry; not the wet.

  • 4 years ago

    Our cat (14) has done very well on Iams kibble (orange bag when she was younger). The vet approved. She's finicky and has a sensitive digestive system, but does well on and loves her Iams kibble. She doesn't like canned food unfortunately. After all the high end and moderate lines of canned food being rejected, she was liking the Blue Wilderness canned for a while, then thought it was yucky. Thought I had a winner there, but she changed her mind on it. I let her have what she likes, which is her Iams dry senior formula (green bag) now. She also does well on and likes Blue Wilderness kibble, but she got too skinny on it so I switched her back to Iams. I think BW might be a better overall meal nutrition wise, but I can't have lose weight at her age as she goes outside.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Origen for dry and Against the Grain in select tuna flavors for wet. It's the only wet food both kitties don't turn their noses up to, and I've tried just about every grain-free brand that our local pet store sells. Even then, they only eat a 3 oz. can a day between them, which is probably good since I know they shouldn't eat too much tuna. But they won't eat chicken or turkey.

    When our black kitty was a kitten, he had a voracious appetite up until his first birthday and became pickier after that. So it's best to get your kitten on a wet food that you want to feed him during that first year.

  • 4 years ago

    We feed them what they will eat. These days, it’s Friskies Pâte, any of their fish varieties except salmon. And a little kibble, I think we’ve been getting Beyond.

  • 4 years ago

    Earthborn Organics Dry food


    I Love You and You Wet. Prior to I Love You and You, wet, their wet food was Fancy Feast. They made the switch with no issues. The impetus for switching was supply, but like you I never really felt great about the Fancy Feast's quality, so I havent looked back. You can buy on Chewy or direct and I do both depending on who is offering the best deal. The manufacturer sends me Flash Sales. My cats cannot eat rich meats, they eat pate only, and only turkey, chicken, fish. Everything else is a vomit-fest and my pillow is a favorite locale(it doesnt matter if my head is on the pillow !!)


  • 4 years ago

    You might find this helpful.


    https://catinfo.org/commercial-cat-foods/


    Vegetables and starchy foods provide cheap calories vs. protein, but cats need high protein diets. It's no wonder there's so much diabetes among cats. Plus it's an agency problem...the food has to appeal to the owner who makes the purchase decision, but the cat consumes it...so when it's full of "natural" foods like peas and cranberries and pumpkin and rice, it all sounds delish to humans, but it can't hold a candle to real proteins cats need from poultry and fish and such.


    Also, I find my cats won't eat any canned food in a sauce. They both walk away from them.

  • 4 years ago

    We recently changed from a Hills Prescription kibble to a different over the counter kibble plus we added an organic frozen chicken product that he just loves. Plus we pour some organic chicken bone broth over the morsels after they thaw.


    He gets three or four of the chicken thingies, with the broth, once a day plus he nibbles on the dry stuff whenever wants.


    We switched because his fur had started to look less than healthy. I knew that something was lacking in his food when his annual wellness check came back fine for the blood work.



    Stella and Chewy frozen morsels

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Well I’m subject to what appeals to the cat and she loves the food with rice and carrots and won’t touch the meaty, high protein, grain free stuff.

  • 4 years ago

    Knock on wood...until my cats get quite old, they are not picky. They eat one can of Aldi canned per day. Yesterday, Venus supplemented that with a squirrel!! She is a barn kitty.

  • 4 years ago

    I cook for my cats. Have done so for several decades. Every couple of months the little princesses get a can of commercial cat food to remind them that they selected good servants.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    our current adult cats settled on Blue buffalo for dry - this is their snack food they go to when hunger pangs hit. Wet food consists of mouse sized portions of chicken Weruva brand for the most part (beef makes one cat vomit, and neither likes the smell of fish based cat food) . They also get boiled chicken bits if I cook a chicken dish.

    Previous cats…one had ibd, and would only eat dry (prescription was fine) and specific flavors of friskies. Human food and anything looking like real meat was inedible and apparently a form of torture.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I've heard good things about Taste of The Wild dry cat food. Mine also gets high protein dry twice a day (Farmina). She also gets a tbls of Weruva chix canned once a day.

    I honestly don't know how much difference it makes. There seems to be so much hype about pet food, says the person who cited reviews of Taste of the Wild, lol.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Both are 3 years old. Picky eaters. High energy! Ivan can eat 6-8 Sheba Perfect Portions servings a day. Some days he can eat kibble...most of the time he instantly regurgitates kibble. Apen likes kibble and gravy. He licks the gravy out of the cat food. Aspen will also eat a Purina Probiotic every once in awhile. Both cats are in-shape....no tummy, soft thick fur. 2 meals a day.

    My last cat had a grain/corn alergy. We started him out on "Taste Of The WIld". I try to feed boy cats wet food. Apen likes Meow Mix crab & salmon in a cup...it's dark meat....if you've never tried it...it looks very meaty. I feed those about once a week for variety.

    We also shop the pet stores...for variety. They won't eat the doctor, good-for-you varieties.

  • 4 years ago

    I used to work at a pet food store, which doesn't make me an expert, but I can confirm that we were taught that Friskies and Fancy Feast were at the lower end of the nutrition scale (but still provided cats with basic daily requirements, so would be fine for most cats). Iams , Pro Plan, and Nutro were the next step up. Then Royal Canin, Beyond, Science Diet, and the store brand. Then there was a jump up to Blue Buffalo, Nulo, Tiki Cat, Applaws, Halo, and Nature's Variety Instinct. The Blue Buffalo rep always said better quality food up front reduces vet bills down the line.


    The best food, though, is the one your cat will actually eat.


    Every line of cat food makes at least one kitten food product (and it's almost always chicken pate). Kitten food is more calorically dense to support their rapid-growth needs and high-energy shenanigans. Most brands have different formulations for different life stages (senior formulations tend to be lower calorie and have stuff for hip and joint health); Royal Canin, Science Diet, and Pro Plan have tons of targeted formulations for specific health concerns (hairballs, urinary tract health, sensitive tummies, etc.).


    I've been through a variety of brands with my own cats. The current cat eats Weruva and Nutro, but only certain flavors, and only ever pate. It can be overwhelming at times trying to sift through all the options. Good luck!

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Highly recommended reading, learned this from feline specialty vets I've volunteered with.
    [ ] “The Carnivore Connection to Nutrition in Cats,” Debra L Zoran, DVM, PhD, DACVIM. Journal American Vet Med Assoc, Vol 221, No. 11, Dec 1, 2002
    [ ] https://catinfo.org/ (by Lisa Pierson, DVM) Good info in "Feeding your Cat" pdf on page

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Canned Fancy Feast, Iams, Purina, Science Diet; vary to provide variety.

  • 4 years ago

    Well you are all confirming my thoughts about Fancy Feast. Since that's the only other food she's had much interest in eating, and she's rejected more other kinds than I can count, I guess I will stick with the expensive small cans of Hills ID that she loves - for now. I noticed there were a lot of non-prescription foods that were just as expensive. Part of the problem is the small cans and the additional packaging cost built into those. She does eat some of the dry too so that helps. Every now and then when I think about my pet expenses I remind myself that the total amount I've spent so far is still less than one year of college - something I'm not paying for since I have no kids.

  • 4 years ago

    My 4 cats are robbing me blind. Just today I ordered from amazon 1 carton of canned, big bag of dry, 2 containers of Temptations, and 1 box of litter. It came to $74.00.


    Fancy Feast canned, not gravy.

    Dry is a tough one, they're finicky.

    Temptations, oh lord, don't forget the Tempations. :)