Software
Houzz Logo Print
li92

Rehab/Replace tile "wainscoting"

4 years ago

My 1890's farmhouse has an open kitchen/dining room - we are re-doing the kitchen and thinking about some changes to dining room as well. The dining room area has a painted tile "wainscoting" - according to our elderly neighbor there used to be wood paneling on the wall. The rest of the wall is plaster.




It wasn't the best install if you look at the bottom where the trim meets - there is some slapped on plaster down there. I don't even know if it is individual tiles or some kind of tile board. I'm thinking I want to take it off, but not sure what to do to replace... should I try to repair the plaster wall underneath, or cover it with some kind of wood board or beadboard, like this picture below? Would that look significantly better than the tile? Any other suggestions?


Transitional Dining Room · More Info


Comments (10)

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Is it real plaster and lath or drywall. I think I would remove it carefully and then see how much damage there is . If really bad drywall over the whole wall is probably the best since trying to find an actul plasterer will be impossible. 20 yrs ago I Calgary I founnd an old Italian guy who did some repair for me but I was lucky to have found him.The other thing is what are you planning for that wall in the new kitchen?

  • 4 years ago

    It is real plaster - I think there might have already been damage and that's why the tile board went on.


    the only thing going on the wall with the tile is a peninsula (lower cabs only) and the big gray pantries are leaving, excuse the poor drawing




  • 4 years ago

    Thats tile board, and its been there a long time. It is usually glued with that nasty type glue, that is nearly impossible to get off. Unless, you really hate it, I would paint it and put a molding at the top of it. I had identical to that in the kitchen of the first house we bought, many years ago.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    I think you need to share the kitchen plan since this makes no sense to me.

  • 4 years ago

    Please, more pictures. 1890s farmhouses can be all kinds of crazy and you might get a few great ideas here.

  • 4 years ago

    Plaster can be repaired and (good) beadboard would be an improvement. Whichever you choose, I think the squares ought to go. :)

  • 4 years ago

    My next question would be, how far up to do beadboard? the ceiling is 116" tall and the current tileboard comes up to 53"


    This is my overall layout so far (with approximate lighting)



    and some more pictures of the current space





  • 4 years ago

    So cute. It looks about the right height now--maybe a little high. You gotta replace the floor molding with something similar to the old stuff in the hall (because it's so good). That's taller so it might affect the proportions. Or not, since you'll probably be painting it. A chair rail at the top might look nice...


    I'd look at photo of old houses and see if anything feels especially correct to you. Is there any paneling elsewhere in the house to use as a guide?


    But if you decide to go with a beadboard (or other type of wainscoting) I think you should nail down the other aspects of the kitchen before deciding on height as they all need to work together.

  • 4 years ago

    @Fori thanks for the comment about the trim, thats a great idea! the tall trim is all throughout the house except for the kitchen so it would look nice.


    another inter highlight from our house, these huge pilars in the living room (probably not original though)




    we took off a light switch board to see the tileboard and it basically looks like masonite or cardboard, and its definitely gonna come off.




  • 4 years ago

    I am pretty sure there is another name for it, but, years ago, in our area, it was called tuff board. It is quite thin.