Not too big and yes it should be framed in the window.

Don't think it is too big. My only concern is the finish, as you seem to have a lot of "gold" in the other room.

Yeah, we have brass fixtures throughout but for some reason i did not like the look of brass in the foyer space

I would take the current light down before trying to decide. Your eye will keep comparing them.

Yes, i wish i could. we have to hire someone to take it down and install the other one because its so high!

Ore pics of the husband please…from the rear!!😉

It's great. Your old one was too small.

Large space and it looks great!

Beauty!!
You have great taste. Trust yourself 💖

Did you end upnhanging the light? i have the same size foyer and wondering if the light worked out? Thank you!

If you did use the new fixture am interested to see how it turned out.